The food was really good. We had a crema di pistachio pizza, meatballs, breadsticks with beer cheese, charcuterie, and Reuben's (they were a special). The pizza was great. The breadsticks and beer cheese were yummy. One person liked their Reuben and one person did not (it wasn't a super traditional Reuben flavor to her). We really enjoyed everything, and the patio was nice, the heaters kept us warm enough on a 60 degree evening with sweatshirts on. The service was good. It overall was a great dinner, the only drawback was the price. Two adults and two teens and we spent almost $150 for dinner. I'm not saying the food wasn't worth it, just to be prepared.
Cee B.
Maybe New Jersey has spoiled me? This is hipster ground zero serving fake Neapolitan fanfare. I had a meatball sandwich and it was dismal at Best. The bread was light and airy but very squishy and overly chewy. Consistent with leaving good Italian bread in a zip lock bag overnight. The marinara was too sweet and felt like it was designed for pizza and used for everything else. The meatballs weren't fried first and appeared to be done in the oven with water then covered. They were tiny as well. Overall, for a 20 dollar sandwich it falls real short of the mark.
Jen M.
Love the outdoor rooftop but the service the last two weekends has been terrible. Last Saturday night we had dinner inside the restaurant and the server brought the wrong beer, was extremely slow to replace and not friendly. This past weekend we went for drinks on the rooftop and service was non-existent. Not just us but everyone around us. Disappointing.
Kelsey R.
Great stop in New Buffalo! We stopped on our way out of Detroit to Milwaukee and were impressed. It is a really nice environment and I bet very fun in the warmer months. The food was very good, we got a prosciutto sandwich, Caesar Salad, and a pizza. The Hazy IPA was also a hit. Overall, a bit overpriced but would still come back!
Jordan D.
DON'T COME HERE IF YOU'RE UNDER 30 AND WANT TO BE TREATED WITH RESPECT. Food was great, but I'm left with a bitter taste in my mouth. I'm not one to ever write a poor review. However, I'm extremely disappointed with the service. Our waitress was quite rude. Many of the members in our group have served in food services, and were still planning to tip. We were charged automatic gratuity, which places normally do, however, we were overcharged and we were not compensated. Extremely disappointing that we had to catch the error in our bill, and they claimed to correct it, but the total was still incorrect. Very frustrating and disappointing. Food was great, but not worth this experience.
Kim T
Good place. Food is great and drinks are good. Wish they turned the sound off on the TV'S, lots of background noise
Amber F.
Went on a Thursday afternoon, the weather wasn't great but the place still had a few other guests there. I had the sour and we tried the adult koolaid shot. Overall good time. The building is an old church as the name suggests. Our server was so nice and helpful explaining the menu and helping on of the non drinkers find something. Will definitely be back!
Konrad AmunRa
Amazing brewery! Good selection of beers ,the food was delicious! I will be back soon.
Nora Comeau
First time here, and I was very impressed with the food, service, and beer. Excellent atmosphere as well.
Christopher Nablo
Food was good, but not worth the expensive prices for what you get. It was also unnerving looking at half eaten food and chicken wing bones on other tables for 25 minutes while we waited for our order. 40 percent of the tables were unclean in outdoor seating.
My friend and I went there, the beer was good, so was the food. The service was terrible. Neither of us had been there before, given one beer menu, expected to immediately order, one food special menu, same thing. Get our drinks. Then shortly, not bad time at all. Get food. No utensils or napkins. Not one of the excessive amount of staff, I know I can see some back of house staff, but there were at least 12 for a place with empty tables. They didn't check on us or the empty cups. Would have loved to try more of the beer, but apparently one and done is what they want.The "trendy" mixed chairs don't do well. Especially when a group of 3 parents are moving the empty seats to have strollers and kids close to them. They were taking chairs from empty tables that suited them better.Overall, I can say I've been there, I live 15 minutes from there. There are better options.
Laura Sloman
Our group of 12 dined here over the weekend, and we weren't disappointed! The pizza was exactly what we needed after a few hours at the local wineries; the carbonara, funghi, diavola, and prosciutto di parma all received rave reviews. The diverse beer menu had something for everyone. Will definitely be back the next time I'm in town.
Tony M.
We sat for two hours and our server only came 4 times literally walked passed never checked on us never warned us to say it would maybe be a little wait just only came to us when it seemed it was convenient and we always tip very well and still did but it was very frustrating in the end
Sarah S.
The pizza was a step above Tosi's, and the sour beer was amazing! We will be back every time we are in town. What a cute location and a cute (though mildly sacrilegious) theme.
Laura Bowman
We really liked this place. Great with a pretty rambunctious toddler and chilled 10 yr old. Good sport on the TV, great music and as a non beer drinker - some very tasty beers ? Food good too, we had the special Italian thin beef sandwich dunked in gravy, cheese pizza, pancakes and sausage, chicken caesar salad - all v good. Will return when we visit New Buffalo again.
The food was really good. We had a crema di pistachio pizza, meatballs, breadsticks with beer cheese, charcuterie, and Reuben's (they were a special). The pizza was great. The breadsticks and beer cheese were yummy. One person liked their Reuben and one person did not (it wasn't a super traditional Reuben flavor to her). We really enjoyed everything, and the patio was nice, the heaters kept us warm enough on a 60 degree evening with sweatshirts on. The service was good. It overall was a great dinner, the only drawback was the price. Two adults and two teens and we spent almost $150 for dinner. I'm not saying the food wasn't worth it, just to be prepared.
Maybe New Jersey has spoiled me? This is hipster ground zero serving fake Neapolitan fanfare. I had a meatball sandwich and it was dismal at Best. The bread was light and airy but very squishy and overly chewy. Consistent with leaving good Italian bread in a zip lock bag overnight. The marinara was too sweet and felt like it was designed for pizza and used for everything else. The meatballs weren't fried first and appeared to be done in the oven with water then covered. They were tiny as well. Overall, for a 20 dollar sandwich it falls real short of the mark.
Love the outdoor rooftop but the service the last two weekends has been terrible. Last Saturday night we had dinner inside the restaurant and the server brought the wrong beer, was extremely slow to replace and not friendly. This past weekend we went for drinks on the rooftop and service was non-existent. Not just us but everyone around us. Disappointing.
Great stop in New Buffalo! We stopped on our way out of Detroit to Milwaukee and were impressed. It is a really nice environment and I bet very fun in the warmer months. The food was very good, we got a prosciutto sandwich, Caesar Salad, and a pizza. The Hazy IPA was also a hit. Overall, a bit overpriced but would still come back!
DON'T COME HERE IF YOU'RE UNDER 30 AND WANT TO BE TREATED WITH RESPECT. Food was great, but I'm left with a bitter taste in my mouth. I'm not one to ever write a poor review. However, I'm extremely disappointed with the service. Our waitress was quite rude. Many of the members in our group have served in food services, and were still planning to tip. We were charged automatic gratuity, which places normally do, however, we were overcharged and we were not compensated. Extremely disappointing that we had to catch the error in our bill, and they claimed to correct it, but the total was still incorrect. Very frustrating and disappointing. Food was great, but not worth this experience.
Good place. Food is great and drinks are good. Wish they turned the sound off on the TV'S, lots of background noise
Went on a Thursday afternoon, the weather wasn't great but the place still had a few other guests there. I had the sour and we tried the adult koolaid shot. Overall good time. The building is an old church as the name suggests. Our server was so nice and helpful explaining the menu and helping on of the non drinkers find something. Will definitely be back!
Amazing brewery! Good selection of beers ,the food was delicious! I will be back soon.
First time here, and I was very impressed with the food, service, and beer. Excellent atmosphere as well.
Food was good, but not worth the expensive prices for what you get. It was also unnerving looking at half eaten food and chicken wing bones on other tables for 25 minutes while we waited for our order. 40 percent of the tables were unclean in outdoor seating.
Restaurantji Recommends
My friend and I went there, the beer was good, so was the food. The service was terrible. Neither of us had been there before, given one beer menu, expected to immediately order, one food special menu, same thing. Get our drinks. Then shortly, not bad time at all. Get food. No utensils or napkins. Not one of the excessive amount of staff, I know I can see some back of house staff, but there were at least 12 for a place with empty tables. They didn't check on us or the empty cups. Would have loved to try more of the beer, but apparently one and done is what they want.The "trendy" mixed chairs don't do well. Especially when a group of 3 parents are moving the empty seats to have strollers and kids close to them. They were taking chairs from empty tables that suited them better.Overall, I can say I've been there, I live 15 minutes from there. There are better options.
Our group of 12 dined here over the weekend, and we weren't disappointed! The pizza was exactly what we needed after a few hours at the local wineries; the carbonara, funghi, diavola, and prosciutto di parma all received rave reviews. The diverse beer menu had something for everyone. Will definitely be back the next time I'm in town.
We sat for two hours and our server only came 4 times literally walked passed never checked on us never warned us to say it would maybe be a little wait just only came to us when it seemed it was convenient and we always tip very well and still did but it was very frustrating in the end
The pizza was a step above Tosi's, and the sour beer was amazing! We will be back every time we are in town. What a cute location and a cute (though mildly sacrilegious) theme.
We really liked this place. Great with a pretty rambunctious toddler and chilled 10 yr old. Good sport on the TV, great music and as a non beer drinker - some very tasty beers ? Food good too, we had the special Italian thin beef sandwich dunked in gravy, cheese pizza, pancakes and sausage, chicken caesar salad - all v good. Will return when we visit New Buffalo again.