Seriously amazing pizza. The quality of the ingredients is so apparent you’ll never go back to chain pizza ever again. Just wish I would have gone there sooner.
Lindsay Monette
Pizza is very good and one of our go-tos, but we've been disappointed to find that the last 10 times we've tried to order (including tonight), they've been closed during the few days and limited hours they're open. We keep going back and trying because the food is delicious and we want to support a local business, but it's almost not worth it anymore. We hope whatever is going on behind the scenes will resolve itself soon.
Lorie Kiley
It was AMAZING. Clean atmosphere and the owner Todd was great. They use fresh ingredients every day and make their own sauce. Can not wait to go try other kinds. We had half Hawaiian and half Hot BBQ Chicken and it was delicious and price is worth it. Amust try.
Allyson Carlton
this place is a hidden gem. I've been searching for good pizza in GR with little success and this has become my new favorite. really impressed with the care and precision taken with the making of each pizza.
Frog Bro
Hey ? just wanted to give my input on the Tomato Pie Pizza Shop.So I Ordered an 8' 2 Toping Ham and Pine apple and thought the pizza could use a Rating.5 Standered Rating1. Flavor: I thought the Pizza ? had a smokey and sweet flavor because of the way it was made. Very full of flavor from the Pine Apple and Ham.I would give it a 4 ? out of 5 ?2. Pie Crunch and Hold: So the Pie had a nice full crunch when you bit in to it. The Items held on and commonly in previous pizza's I had the Items would just fall off ? ? and left with you just picking up the items to just put them right back on your Pie.I would rate that 5 ? out of 5 ?3. Presentation: So the 8' I had came out Hot and ready on a Pizza Tray very nice and clean display ? ? and commonly the pizzas I came across like that are a bit blotted and not as clean. The Display was fit for a King ? ? ?.I would rate it 5 ? out of 5 ?4. Cleanliness and Loudness of the Shop: I have nothing to say about the Shop I was very impressed with the quality of the shop and Tables and Floors and Display of Operations was very Professional and Clean. You would think your Eating at a hospital ? ? ? all Jokes aside it was very Welcoming ? and so was The Staff on my first ever visit to Tomato Pie ? ? ?.I would rate it 5 ? out of 5 ?5. Location and clarity: So I found the the Tomato Pie Shop was more then visible from the General public and very eye catching even from a 10 foot Radius.I think there should be a bit more Eye spectacular Items to help draw in so hungry Customers. I see small businesses and Corporations using characters and Items displayed in there store fronts to draw in curiosities from New youths and Old. That's what they might need ? ? ?.I would rate it a 3 ? out of 5 ?Over all the place is very wholesome and fresh for the upcoming ? years and I feel like there should be more customers making the place a bit more alive.Idea ? : Maybe even start making a Memorable moments. For the customers to share there photos and build a wall dedicated to your engaging customers.It's nice that they can hold a piece of Pie even when there not there but others can share and enjoy in the moments of the one's that showed a better love and appreciation for the Tomato Pie? ? Great work Tomato Pie ? ?You made me full and very Happy ?Final Rating 4 ? ? out of 5 ? ?
J K
We were very excited to try Tomato Pie. We ordered 3 small pizzas with 2 or less items each with nothing fancy and it was just shy of $50.Over the next hour we kept receiving apologies about the wait and the empathy was nice. When we ordered we were not informed it would take 60 minutes. This was not communicated to us at any time. We were simply told it shouldn’t be much longer every 10-15 minutes.The plain cheese pizza wasn’t cooked very much, the bottom being almost translucent and the dough had a sour taste to it. It tasted like very old dough. I don’t know if they’re using too much yeast or if they’re using 5 day old dough but it tastes like it’s one of those. Maybe we just came on a bad day.I’ve never seen my husband throw away pizza but there’s a first time for everything. The third person in our group enjoyed theirs.To be honest, the cheese and sauce was pretty good. I’d eat it again but only if they fixed their dough problems, cooked it on a hot spot in the oven and respected people’s time by being honest about the wait time before taking my money.
Trevor
Just stopped in and had the $8 lunch deal. The pizza was fantastic. Probably the best tasting wood fired pie I've ever had. Definitely will be back!
Marianne Guthrie
I would highly recommend the pizza here! The dough is great and the toppings all seemed to be quality. The pizza oven was awesome, and cooks the pizza in just a couple minutes. The service was decent - quick, pleasant, able to get us in and out in a timely manner for a pickup order.The Hot BBQ Chicken pizza was great. Honestly, it was hard deciding which pizza to get because a lot of them sounded great. Wish we could have ordered multiple!
Jakery
Friendly staff, relaxing eating area, the food was just amazing, you see the sub/pizza made right In front of you. The smothered sausage was tasty and good portioned, this is a must try if you are in the area!
Elise B.
Stopped in here for a weekday lunch after wanting to try for a while. They had a lunch special of a 12" 1 topping pizza (4 decent size slices, but a personal size for a hungry adult) with a drink for $8. And you could upgrade to a speciality pizza for $1! I got the prosciutto and arugula speciality pizza and my husband got pepperoni. I loved it, there was ample cheese and the crust was a great texture, not too hard or crisp like a thinner crust can be. It was cooked right in front of us at the big wood fire oven. Great deal and tasty food, plus seemed it was a family owned business- i think it was dad and daughter working together! You love to see it. We will be back for sure.
Best artisan pizza around! The dough and sauce is exquisite. Todd made my wife and I a pizza and it was outstanding!!! I’m a big fan of the sausage! The pizza oven is so cool and it was very tidy and clean. Will definitely be back!!
Dung Pham
Absolutely Delicious! Owner and staff are very personable and friendly... great experience!Make your own pizza option too!
Gimmee F.
Had the Greek salad tonight and a sausage, kalamata olive and artichoke pizza. The pizza was terrific with a nice red sauce and wonderful crust. The employees were friendly and helpful. The Greek salad was okay but nothing special. It was made with spring mix lettuce which is kind of unusual for a Greek salad. Overall a good experience and we will be back.
Matt F (Farriswheel15)
$21 got us a 4 topping 12" pizza and garlic bread. "I liked everything about it. Perfection." -Rachael
J T (Dadt2)
Pizza was delicious! The tre fomaggio was outstanding with the homemade garlic sauce. Homemade red sauce was on point. All ingredients were fresh as well as made right in front of you. Building was very clean including the restrooms. The customer service was top notch, super friendly and personable. Highly recommend
Seriously amazing pizza. The quality of the ingredients is so apparent you’ll never go back to chain pizza ever again. Just wish I would have gone there sooner.
Pizza is very good and one of our go-tos, but we've been disappointed to find that the last 10 times we've tried to order (including tonight), they've been closed during the few days and limited hours they're open. We keep going back and trying because the food is delicious and we want to support a local business, but it's almost not worth it anymore. We hope whatever is going on behind the scenes will resolve itself soon.
It was AMAZING. Clean atmosphere and the owner Todd was great. They use fresh ingredients every day and make their own sauce. Can not wait to go try other kinds. We had half Hawaiian and half Hot BBQ Chicken and it was delicious and price is worth it. Amust try.
this place is a hidden gem. I've been searching for good pizza in GR with little success and this has become my new favorite. really impressed with the care and precision taken with the making of each pizza.
Hey ? just wanted to give my input on the Tomato Pie Pizza Shop.So I Ordered an 8' 2 Toping Ham and Pine apple and thought the pizza could use a Rating.5 Standered Rating1. Flavor: I thought the Pizza ? had a smokey and sweet flavor because of the way it was made. Very full of flavor from the Pine Apple and Ham.I would give it a 4 ? out of 5 ?2. Pie Crunch and Hold: So the Pie had a nice full crunch when you bit in to it. The Items held on and commonly in previous pizza's I had the Items would just fall off ? ? and left with you just picking up the items to just put them right back on your Pie.I would rate that 5 ? out of 5 ?3. Presentation: So the 8' I had came out Hot and ready on a Pizza Tray very nice and clean display ? ? and commonly the pizzas I came across like that are a bit blotted and not as clean. The Display was fit for a King ? ? ?.I would rate it 5 ? out of 5 ?4. Cleanliness and Loudness of the Shop: I have nothing to say about the Shop I was very impressed with the quality of the shop and Tables and Floors and Display of Operations was very Professional and Clean. You would think your Eating at a hospital ? ? ? all Jokes aside it was very Welcoming ? and so was The Staff on my first ever visit to Tomato Pie ? ? ?.I would rate it 5 ? out of 5 ?5. Location and clarity: So I found the the Tomato Pie Shop was more then visible from the General public and very eye catching even from a 10 foot Radius.I think there should be a bit more Eye spectacular Items to help draw in so hungry Customers. I see small businesses and Corporations using characters and Items displayed in there store fronts to draw in curiosities from New youths and Old. That's what they might need ? ? ?.I would rate it a 3 ? out of 5 ?Over all the place is very wholesome and fresh for the upcoming ? years and I feel like there should be more customers making the place a bit more alive.Idea ? : Maybe even start making a Memorable moments. For the customers to share there photos and build a wall dedicated to your engaging customers.It's nice that they can hold a piece of Pie even when there not there but others can share and enjoy in the moments of the one's that showed a better love and appreciation for the Tomato Pie? ? Great work Tomato Pie ? ?You made me full and very Happy ?Final Rating 4 ? ? out of 5 ? ?
We were very excited to try Tomato Pie. We ordered 3 small pizzas with 2 or less items each with nothing fancy and it was just shy of $50.Over the next hour we kept receiving apologies about the wait and the empathy was nice. When we ordered we were not informed it would take 60 minutes. This was not communicated to us at any time. We were simply told it shouldn’t be much longer every 10-15 minutes.The plain cheese pizza wasn’t cooked very much, the bottom being almost translucent and the dough had a sour taste to it. It tasted like very old dough. I don’t know if they’re using too much yeast or if they’re using 5 day old dough but it tastes like it’s one of those. Maybe we just came on a bad day.I’ve never seen my husband throw away pizza but there’s a first time for everything. The third person in our group enjoyed theirs.To be honest, the cheese and sauce was pretty good. I’d eat it again but only if they fixed their dough problems, cooked it on a hot spot in the oven and respected people’s time by being honest about the wait time before taking my money.
Just stopped in and had the $8 lunch deal. The pizza was fantastic. Probably the best tasting wood fired pie I've ever had. Definitely will be back!
I would highly recommend the pizza here! The dough is great and the toppings all seemed to be quality. The pizza oven was awesome, and cooks the pizza in just a couple minutes. The service was decent - quick, pleasant, able to get us in and out in a timely manner for a pickup order.The Hot BBQ Chicken pizza was great. Honestly, it was hard deciding which pizza to get because a lot of them sounded great. Wish we could have ordered multiple!
Friendly staff, relaxing eating area, the food was just amazing, you see the sub/pizza made right In front of you. The smothered sausage was tasty and good portioned, this is a must try if you are in the area!
Stopped in here for a weekday lunch after wanting to try for a while. They had a lunch special of a 12" 1 topping pizza (4 decent size slices, but a personal size for a hungry adult) with a drink for $8. And you could upgrade to a speciality pizza for $1! I got the prosciutto and arugula speciality pizza and my husband got pepperoni. I loved it, there was ample cheese and the crust was a great texture, not too hard or crisp like a thinner crust can be. It was cooked right in front of us at the big wood fire oven. Great deal and tasty food, plus seemed it was a family owned business- i think it was dad and daughter working together! You love to see it. We will be back for sure.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best artisan pizza around! The dough and sauce is exquisite. Todd made my wife and I a pizza and it was outstanding!!! I’m a big fan of the sausage! The pizza oven is so cool and it was very tidy and clean. Will definitely be back!!
Absolutely Delicious! Owner and staff are very personable and friendly... great experience!Make your own pizza option too!
Had the Greek salad tonight and a sausage, kalamata olive and artichoke pizza. The pizza was terrific with a nice red sauce and wonderful crust. The employees were friendly and helpful. The Greek salad was okay but nothing special. It was made with spring mix lettuce which is kind of unusual for a Greek salad. Overall a good experience and we will be back.
$21 got us a 4 topping 12" pizza and garlic bread. "I liked everything about it. Perfection." -Rachael
Pizza was delicious! The tre fomaggio was outstanding with the homemade garlic sauce. Homemade red sauce was on point. All ingredients were fresh as well as made right in front of you. Building was very clean including the restrooms. The customer service was top notch, super friendly and personable. Highly recommend