This place is a must-try. We usually take pizza to-go, but have eaten inside the restaurant as well. There's a very warm and welcoming environment; we really felt cared for. The pinball machine was a hit with my 6 yr old and husband alike. We usually order a pineapple pizza (my son's favorite), but have also tried the pepperoni and both were delicious. Perfectly crunchy crust, no frills, just yummy pizza. Oh, and the creme brulee was to die for!! I want so badly to try the taco pizza, but nobody in my family likes it and I haven't been able to justify getting a whole pizza for myself. So if anyone's got leftover taco pizza, send it my way! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Thomason
Great pizza, always friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
madison feine (madi)
I came in a few nights ago, and I didn’t get sat down for around half an hour. I was standing in front of the door and because of how cramped and small the place is. The servers were coming out behind us and we couldn’t move out their way. Once when we had finally got seated we would hear yelling and screaming coming from the back the rest of the night while we were trying to eat. Serves were good, it’s not their fault they have to work in an environment like this. However the meal was not so good. The crust was burnt and paper thin. Never in my life have a seen such greasy pizza. Definitely wouldn’t recommend the house pizza. The sausages were completely overcooked. The manager was pretty weird, he seems to want everyone to know his views on things. We left without saying a word however, didn’t want to deal with the place anymore. Absolutely disgusting. So sorry for the workers.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
Brenda Kalmbach
We love to order pizza to-go from O'Niells. The pizza is always amazing. We usually order a taco pizza half no olives and a pepperoni pizza. It is always done well and is delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Taco Pizza, Cheese Bread
Gabriel Tanner
Great people, great food, pretty decent service, and wonderful for takeout. Not personally a fan of how the interior set up, but to each their own still would go here anytime.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
sean okerlund
This place is amazing! Owner is so kind and the pizza is sooooo good
Lyle Wright
Very friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Thein
To survive in a small town, you must appeal outside of your general area. O’Neills does that by arguably offering the best pizza in SE MN. They pair that with super friendly service and a quaint atmosphere. Definitely worth the drive!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
MinnesotaRandy
O'Neil's used to be located in Rochester. Bilotti's and O'Neils were my favorite pizza places in Rochester. Both were very similar but O'Neil's had a bit of an edge with their crust. Happy that they did not move too far away! Excellent pizza and very friendly owner!
Benjamin Kath
We accidentally stumbled upon here when nothing else in town seemed open and boy let me tell you this was a great accident! The WHOLE staff is awesome. My husband and I were at a local cabin celebrating my birthday. This place made me feel special and our host kept us laughing the whole time. We got the veggie pizza and it was so fresh , goey and hot! It was so good we thought about driving back to pick up for dinner. We highly suggest this place! 10/10 for vibes and pizza. Hope to be back if ever out here again. Thanks for making me smile on my birthday.
We were in town for a boys' soccer game and O'Neills came up as a restaurant in the area. Great food selection and it was very tasty. Only minor issue was that the garden salad was a bowl of Iceberg lettuce with chopped tomato. Rest of the meal was great and staff were very attentive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Renae Wesenberg
Great Minnesota thin crust pizza served by wonderful people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ultranitro
I lived only 50 feet from this place for about 2 years and only ate there once. This is the only restaurant in Elgin too btw. I ordered a large supreme pizza and what I thought were buffalo chicken wings. I got the food only 10 minutes later and brought it home to eat. The pizza was literally just like a cheap paper thin crust frozen Jack's and it honestly didn't taste as good as a Jacks. The toppings were pathetic, diced tiny and had no flavor. The pizza was way overpriced for what you got and it was sad that a "Pizza place" would serve such bland pizza. The "Chicken wings" we're disgusting! They were just 3 medium sized plain breaded chicken fingers that were obviously microwaved. The meat was dry and had tons of nasty looking cartilage and dark spots. I have no idea how this place has such a high rating on Google. Another smaller point to make is they are only open until 8:00pm on both Friday and Saturday night!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 4
Missy Wilde
So glad to see this place resurrected! It was always a favorite in Rochester. We had the Greek pizza with gyro meat and it was EXACTLY as I remembered it, right down to way they make the crust, with the little folds around the outside. A real treat - can’t wait to come back ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Crazy Pickles
Amazing pizza, great customer service, down home feel. I remember when this place was still located in Rochester, still the same awesome small town pizza joint.
This place is a must-try. We usually take pizza to-go, but have eaten inside the restaurant as well. There's a very warm and welcoming environment; we really felt cared for. The pinball machine was a hit with my 6 yr old and husband alike. We usually order a pineapple pizza (my son's favorite), but have also tried the pepperoni and both were delicious. Perfectly crunchy crust, no frills, just yummy pizza. Oh, and the creme brulee was to die for!! I want so badly to try the taco pizza, but nobody in my family likes it and I haven't been able to justify getting a whole pizza for myself. So if anyone's got leftover taco pizza, send it my way! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza, always friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I came in a few nights ago, and I didn’t get sat down for around half an hour. I was standing in front of the door and because of how cramped and small the place is. The servers were coming out behind us and we couldn’t move out their way. Once when we had finally got seated we would hear yelling and screaming coming from the back the rest of the night while we were trying to eat. Serves were good, it’s not their fault they have to work in an environment like this. However the meal was not so good. The crust was burnt and paper thin. Never in my life have a seen such greasy pizza. Definitely wouldn’t recommend the house pizza. The sausages were completely overcooked. The manager was pretty weird, he seems to want everyone to know his views on things. We left without saying a word however, didn’t want to deal with the place anymore. Absolutely disgusting. So sorry for the workers.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
We love to order pizza to-go from O'Niells. The pizza is always amazing. We usually order a taco pizza half no olives and a pepperoni pizza. It is always done well and is delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Taco Pizza, Cheese Bread
Great people, great food, pretty decent service, and wonderful for takeout. Not personally a fan of how the interior set up, but to each their own still would go here anytime.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
This place is amazing! Owner is so kind and the pizza is sooooo good
Very friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
To survive in a small town, you must appeal outside of your general area. O’Neills does that by arguably offering the best pizza in SE MN. They pair that with super friendly service and a quaint atmosphere. Definitely worth the drive!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
O'Neil's used to be located in Rochester. Bilotti's and O'Neils were my favorite pizza places in Rochester. Both were very similar but O'Neil's had a bit of an edge with their crust. Happy that they did not move too far away! Excellent pizza and very friendly owner!
We accidentally stumbled upon here when nothing else in town seemed open and boy let me tell you this was a great accident! The WHOLE staff is awesome. My husband and I were at a local cabin celebrating my birthday. This place made me feel special and our host kept us laughing the whole time. We got the veggie pizza and it was so fresh , goey and hot! It was so good we thought about driving back to pick up for dinner. We highly suggest this place! 10/10 for vibes and pizza. Hope to be back if ever out here again. Thanks for making me smile on my birthday.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
We were in town for a boys' soccer game and O'Neills came up as a restaurant in the area. Great food selection and it was very tasty. Only minor issue was that the garden salad was a bowl of Iceberg lettuce with chopped tomato. Rest of the meal was great and staff were very attentive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great Minnesota thin crust pizza served by wonderful people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I lived only 50 feet from this place for about 2 years and only ate there once. This is the only restaurant in Elgin too btw. I ordered a large supreme pizza and what I thought were buffalo chicken wings. I got the food only 10 minutes later and brought it home to eat. The pizza was literally just like a cheap paper thin crust frozen Jack's and it honestly didn't taste as good as a Jacks. The toppings were pathetic, diced tiny and had no flavor. The pizza was way overpriced for what you got and it was sad that a "Pizza place" would serve such bland pizza. The "Chicken wings" we're disgusting! They were just 3 medium sized plain breaded chicken fingers that were obviously microwaved. The meat was dry and had tons of nasty looking cartilage and dark spots. I have no idea how this place has such a high rating on Google. Another smaller point to make is they are only open until 8:00pm on both Friday and Saturday night!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 4
So glad to see this place resurrected! It was always a favorite in Rochester. We had the Greek pizza with gyro meat and it was EXACTLY as I remembered it, right down to way they make the crust, with the little folds around the outside. A real treat - can’t wait to come back ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing pizza, great customer service, down home feel. I remember when this place was still located in Rochester, still the same awesome small town pizza joint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5