I've been buying pizza here for over 10 years. (FKA Woodland). This place beats any take in bake in Minnesota as far as I'm concerned. I forgot Little Murphy's or whatever the name is, even exists any more...However, Pizza Supreme is only 4 stars... if you have them cook it. They need to optimize their cooking, it's not the best.You can provide +1 star if you cook it yourself.The cooking instructions are nearly perfect but I recommend these instructions for perfect pizza:(hand tossed crust)425F, set cook time for 20 minutesPlace on center rack (with baking tray)at 13:00 remove tray (this will get the bottom crust crispy)at 18:00 , place pizza one rack higher than middle, to brown the cheese and warm the toppings.at 20:00 , remove pizza and let cool for 5at 25:00, eat perfect pizzahydrate with beer
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Preston Swartz
Great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nels Liebel
Nice mom and pop place, owner is really nice guy, have lots of options, great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John O.
Every time I either sit down or take my pizza to go, I am happy with the customer service. The owner has one heck of a sense of humor and the memory of an elephant. I have a food allergy and he remembers when I frequent the establishment. Let me put it this way, if pizza was illegal, I would have been to rehab 3 dozen times and meeting Pizza Supreme staff in an alley for that deliciousness all up in my face hole!!! I have to limit myself to only so many times a month or I won't even be able to fit into zubas pants (for you young cats, those are stretchy pants and you'll find them in black and white photos)
Shannon G.
Best pizza and most generous kind employees in EVERY way. I will DEFINITELY be coming back!!!
Tara Kadow
First timer and the pizza was amazing!!! Fresh and quality ingredients. Staff was extremely friendly and courteous. We have full and happy bellies!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Leon
The pizza here is pretty good and is very similar to carbones. It was very good. Nice crispy crust with a lot of veggies.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Nick Thurnau
Polar bear pizza all day! Thin crust it’s so good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Becky Prestley
The employees were very nice and friendly. Lots of pizza and topping choices. The hand tossed crust was perfect.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Denzel Dakota
Service was amazing and the person serving us gave us a free dessert pizza, food was really good as well.Parking: A lot of parking spots that are very spacious.Kid-friendliness: They have a lot of kid friendly options like the margarita pizza ?
I somewhat randomly stopped into this place on a weeknight to have dinner with the family after a school event. The Pizza was great and they took good care of us. We were told they do Hand Tossed or Thin Crust with and it can be cooked for us or take-and-bake.We ordered a hand tossed pizza and ate it in the restaurant. Quite a few outside patio tables and some low tops and high tops inside. Most every kind of pizza available with some apps salads sandwiches and other things on the menu.I enjoy Dominos as much as the next guy, but I also like to see small and family run restaurant businesses that make good food and provide something different than the national chains thriving in my community. I'll definitely be back to try more of what's on the menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Edward S.
Decent pizza place. Not many places to sit inside. The pizza was good but a bit expensive ($20 for a medium). I really liked the gyro pizza, even though I asked for no olives they put olives on the pizza (I picked them off). The margarita was not very good, not much cheese. They did give us a free desert pizza, which was nice. I think they may have realized they made a mistake on the gyro pizza.
Kim L
I had the pleasure of trying a new pizza establishment for me. It's in Savage and called Pizza Supreme. The owner was so welcoming and nice.They let us try the sauces the red sauce was a little sweet and seasoned well, it was very well-balanced. It was a homemade pizza sauce and we tasted the garlic white sauce and it was really rich and lots of garlic and amazing! All his sauces are homemade (except the Marinara sauce) and he's working to sell them in stores. It tasted like your Italian grandma made them. This might be my new favorite pizza place.We got a thin-crust Grand Teton with white garlic sauce, spinach, red onions, oven-roasted tomatoes, fresh rosemary that is roasted, and Asiago cheese. We made a substitute (he was like no problem) we substituted the garlic chicken for the meatball.The crust was buttery the bottom was a little soft but that didn't bother me.We also had the cheese bread and it had a great fresh garlic taste and was very cheesy. We got the pizza sauce and tried the Marinara sauce it was not as good as the pizza sauce, but still good!If you want to try an awesome mom-and-pop, local independent pizza place (with lots of gourmet pizza options) with a Great owner, Definitely try them out.Dietary restrictions: Gluten-free, vegan, vegetarian
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grand Teton Pizza
jozey benson
I was eating at the Yogurt Lab next to the Pizza Supreme and my family and I were sitting at a table. My brother was touching the umbrella, not creating any problems.A worker comes out and starts yelling at him, she said “I don’t know what you’re doing or why you’re doing it but you need to leave right now. Everyone get off the tables and go now!”I think there was no civil or logical explanation for this outburst.She was aggressive and rude and I won’t be going there ever again.Kid-friendliness: BE MORE KIND TO KIDS
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Judy L.
The food was authentic Italian and the best I have ever eaten. The service was great and the owner was so generous and kind. Very reasonably priced. Absolutely recommend this place to anyone. You won't be disappointed.
I've been buying pizza here for over 10 years. (FKA Woodland). This place beats any take in bake in Minnesota as far as I'm concerned. I forgot Little Murphy's or whatever the name is, even exists any more...However, Pizza Supreme is only 4 stars... if you have them cook it. They need to optimize their cooking, it's not the best.You can provide +1 star if you cook it yourself.The cooking instructions are nearly perfect but I recommend these instructions for perfect pizza:(hand tossed crust)425F, set cook time for 20 minutesPlace on center rack (with baking tray)at 13:00 remove tray (this will get the bottom crust crispy)at 18:00 , place pizza one rack higher than middle, to brown the cheese and warm the toppings.at 20:00 , remove pizza and let cool for 5at 25:00, eat perfect pizzahydrate with beer
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice mom and pop place, owner is really nice guy, have lots of options, great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Every time I either sit down or take my pizza to go, I am happy with the customer service. The owner has one heck of a sense of humor and the memory of an elephant. I have a food allergy and he remembers when I frequent the establishment. Let me put it this way, if pizza was illegal, I would have been to rehab 3 dozen times and meeting Pizza Supreme staff in an alley for that deliciousness all up in my face hole!!! I have to limit myself to only so many times a month or I won't even be able to fit into zubas pants (for you young cats, those are stretchy pants and you'll find them in black and white photos)
Best pizza and most generous kind employees in EVERY way. I will DEFINITELY be coming back!!!
First timer and the pizza was amazing!!! Fresh and quality ingredients. Staff was extremely friendly and courteous. We have full and happy bellies!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza here is pretty good and is very similar to carbones. It was very good. Nice crispy crust with a lot of veggies.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Polar bear pizza all day! Thin crust it’s so good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The employees were very nice and friendly. Lots of pizza and topping choices. The hand tossed crust was perfect.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Service was amazing and the person serving us gave us a free dessert pizza, food was really good as well.Parking: A lot of parking spots that are very spacious.Kid-friendliness: They have a lot of kid friendly options like the margarita pizza ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza, Meatball Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
I somewhat randomly stopped into this place on a weeknight to have dinner with the family after a school event. The Pizza was great and they took good care of us. We were told they do Hand Tossed or Thin Crust with and it can be cooked for us or take-and-bake.We ordered a hand tossed pizza and ate it in the restaurant. Quite a few outside patio tables and some low tops and high tops inside. Most every kind of pizza available with some apps salads sandwiches and other things on the menu.I enjoy Dominos as much as the next guy, but I also like to see small and family run restaurant businesses that make good food and provide something different than the national chains thriving in my community. I'll definitely be back to try more of what's on the menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Decent pizza place. Not many places to sit inside. The pizza was good but a bit expensive ($20 for a medium). I really liked the gyro pizza, even though I asked for no olives they put olives on the pizza (I picked them off). The margarita was not very good, not much cheese. They did give us a free desert pizza, which was nice. I think they may have realized they made a mistake on the gyro pizza.
I had the pleasure of trying a new pizza establishment for me. It's in Savage and called Pizza Supreme. The owner was so welcoming and nice.They let us try the sauces the red sauce was a little sweet and seasoned well, it was very well-balanced. It was a homemade pizza sauce and we tasted the garlic white sauce and it was really rich and lots of garlic and amazing! All his sauces are homemade (except the Marinara sauce) and he's working to sell them in stores. It tasted like your Italian grandma made them. This might be my new favorite pizza place.We got a thin-crust Grand Teton with white garlic sauce, spinach, red onions, oven-roasted tomatoes, fresh rosemary that is roasted, and Asiago cheese. We made a substitute (he was like no problem) we substituted the garlic chicken for the meatball.The crust was buttery the bottom was a little soft but that didn't bother me.We also had the cheese bread and it had a great fresh garlic taste and was very cheesy. We got the pizza sauce and tried the Marinara sauce it was not as good as the pizza sauce, but still good!If you want to try an awesome mom-and-pop, local independent pizza place (with lots of gourmet pizza options) with a Great owner, Definitely try them out.Dietary restrictions: Gluten-free, vegan, vegetarian
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grand Teton Pizza
I was eating at the Yogurt Lab next to the Pizza Supreme and my family and I were sitting at a table. My brother was touching the umbrella, not creating any problems.A worker comes out and starts yelling at him, she said “I don’t know what you’re doing or why you’re doing it but you need to leave right now. Everyone get off the tables and go now!”I think there was no civil or logical explanation for this outburst.She was aggressive and rude and I won’t be going there ever again.Kid-friendliness: BE MORE KIND TO KIDS
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The food was authentic Italian and the best I have ever eaten. The service was great and the owner was so generous and kind. Very reasonably priced. Absolutely recommend this place to anyone. You won't be disappointed.