Went here and the first thing we saw was racks of pizza sitting out without a heater. We ordered one slice for a child and they take the pizza sitting out and reheat it. We also ordered the Mac and cheese pizza for us and it was very bland and not great either. The guy at the counter also did not say a word to us. Not hello, not thank you, nothing. We were also harassed by a guy who walked in to eat other food and wanted to talk to our child after us all ignoring him and then telling him to stop we just left because the child was crying. I would give the place and the experience less than 0 starts if I could.
Connor Garside
Good pizza, fair price, if you want a good amount of sauce make sure you ask for extra, I know I will next time!
Jacob Isaacs
This was exactly what we wanted. It's a good, inexpensive college-town pizza place. Nothing fancy with the food or the restaurant. Nothing too crazy, but just enough to get your attention. When you just need a slice of decent pizza to help you feel full on a Friday night, this does the job. It's just right.
Seth Weinand
Just had Politos for my first time ever. Ordered a 20” supreme with a side of the CinnaKnots. The pizza was very good, no complaints there. HUGE slices! However, the CinnaKnots tasted very plain which was a bit of a downer… Won’t stop me from ordering another pizza, however! Probably the biggest pizza I’ve ever ordered from a restaurant before. Truly a great value for the price you pay!
Lexi Patynski
Awesome pizza at a great price!! They will heat up your slice right after you order it and it tastes super fresh. Best place to stop for a quick bite!
Allison Waggoner
Simply good pizza. The server was all by himself, Oder taker, cook, server , and bus boy. Did a great job.
Kelly Marie
We ordered a Monster pizza for my son’s 10th birthday party and it was a huge hit! The kids were amazed how big it was and it tasted fantastic. I highly recommend Polito’s Pizza for feeding lots of hungry people without breaking the bank.
Katie Webster
Delicious pizza. Fun place.
Don Williams
This place was REALLY good when it first opened, but my last 2 visits have seen undercooked pizza with toppings that just slide off and have also been really greasy. I like a little grease but this has been grease that drips off the pizza and puddles in your plate. Hopefully they will return to the standards that made them a great pizza place but right now I wouldn't recommend.
T Downs
I enjoy their pizza and I’d go there from time to time when I worked downtown for a slice at lunch. I really like their garlic knots. I wish they had fresh basil, I’d be inclined to visit more if they did, but I can understand why they don’t also. My biggest complaint is I’ve experienced extremely rude customer service there when I ordered delivery and got a regular cheese pizza, then added feta and basil. It came with no cheese except feta. It was covered inch by inch in feta... what a waste. Who would want that? I called to have it fixed and they argued with me and said I didn’t opt to include the regular pizza cheese and I pulled up the order from my email while on the phone and pointed out that it specifically listed that out, to which he finally looked up also and agreed to, but was completely unapologetic. It was honestly this huge back and forth argument that didn’t even need to take place; just fix the problem! I haven’t been back since. I just go to Jet’s and get their New York style when I want that type of pizza now. I’d be willing to try them again if they delivered pizza themselves rather than through high-priced third parties (and the fresh basil would be a draw too lol).
Initially ordered online for delivery. When we learned that the wait would be over an hour, we called to see if picking it up ourselves would be an option. They couldn't pronounce my sister's last name, but they changed the order to pickup without issue and we got our pizzas in about half the time.My brother spent years living and working in NYC. He took one bite and said, "Wow! This is New York Pizza! I haven't had this in AGES!"Slices are huge and foldable; the crust has the right balance of chew and snap. The toppings are fresh and flavorful.Two 20" pizzas were perfect for 5 adults and 3 kids. At about $50, it was a steal. We'll be back.
kurt sjelin
Exceptional pizza. Multiple flavors available. Fast friendly and very clean facilities. Perfect choice for group orders.
Freddy Ragsdale
Amazing pizza Closest to new york pizza your gonna get
Amber Baumgard
love it here, great pizza
Emily Schandorff
Pizza is amazing! Quick and friendly. Favorite is the Big Mac soo delicious!
Went here and the first thing we saw was racks of pizza sitting out without a heater. We ordered one slice for a child and they take the pizza sitting out and reheat it. We also ordered the Mac and cheese pizza for us and it was very bland and not great either. The guy at the counter also did not say a word to us. Not hello, not thank you, nothing. We were also harassed by a guy who walked in to eat other food and wanted to talk to our child after us all ignoring him and then telling him to stop we just left because the child was crying. I would give the place and the experience less than 0 starts if I could.
Good pizza, fair price, if you want a good amount of sauce make sure you ask for extra, I know I will next time!
This was exactly what we wanted. It's a good, inexpensive college-town pizza place. Nothing fancy with the food or the restaurant. Nothing too crazy, but just enough to get your attention. When you just need a slice of decent pizza to help you feel full on a Friday night, this does the job. It's just right.
Just had Politos for my first time ever. Ordered a 20” supreme with a side of the CinnaKnots. The pizza was very good, no complaints there. HUGE slices! However, the CinnaKnots tasted very plain which was a bit of a downer… Won’t stop me from ordering another pizza, however! Probably the biggest pizza I’ve ever ordered from a restaurant before. Truly a great value for the price you pay!
Awesome pizza at a great price!! They will heat up your slice right after you order it and it tastes super fresh. Best place to stop for a quick bite!
Simply good pizza. The server was all by himself, Oder taker, cook, server , and bus boy. Did a great job.
We ordered a Monster pizza for my son’s 10th birthday party and it was a huge hit! The kids were amazed how big it was and it tasted fantastic. I highly recommend Polito’s Pizza for feeding lots of hungry people without breaking the bank.
Delicious pizza. Fun place.
This place was REALLY good when it first opened, but my last 2 visits have seen undercooked pizza with toppings that just slide off and have also been really greasy. I like a little grease but this has been grease that drips off the pizza and puddles in your plate. Hopefully they will return to the standards that made them a great pizza place but right now I wouldn't recommend.
I enjoy their pizza and I’d go there from time to time when I worked downtown for a slice at lunch. I really like their garlic knots. I wish they had fresh basil, I’d be inclined to visit more if they did, but I can understand why they don’t also. My biggest complaint is I’ve experienced extremely rude customer service there when I ordered delivery and got a regular cheese pizza, then added feta and basil. It came with no cheese except feta. It was covered inch by inch in feta... what a waste. Who would want that? I called to have it fixed and they argued with me and said I didn’t opt to include the regular pizza cheese and I pulled up the order from my email while on the phone and pointed out that it specifically listed that out, to which he finally looked up also and agreed to, but was completely unapologetic. It was honestly this huge back and forth argument that didn’t even need to take place; just fix the problem! I haven’t been back since. I just go to Jet’s and get their New York style when I want that type of pizza now. I’d be willing to try them again if they delivered pizza themselves rather than through high-priced third parties (and the fresh basil would be a draw too lol).
Restaurantji Recommends
Initially ordered online for delivery. When we learned that the wait would be over an hour, we called to see if picking it up ourselves would be an option. They couldn't pronounce my sister's last name, but they changed the order to pickup without issue and we got our pizzas in about half the time.My brother spent years living and working in NYC. He took one bite and said, "Wow! This is New York Pizza! I haven't had this in AGES!"Slices are huge and foldable; the crust has the right balance of chew and snap. The toppings are fresh and flavorful.Two 20" pizzas were perfect for 5 adults and 3 kids. At about $50, it was a steal. We'll be back.
Exceptional pizza. Multiple flavors available. Fast friendly and very clean facilities. Perfect choice for group orders.
Amazing pizza Closest to new york pizza your gonna get
love it here, great pizza
Pizza is amazing! Quick and friendly. Favorite is the Big Mac soo delicious!