Desserts are delicious. But the young female working the counter on Saturday 3/30 (day before Easter) needs a serious attitude adjustment. very bad representation for your business- your desserts are so good, while spoil it with such horrid service?
Sarah Klebolt
Sarah's is a great local shop to stop by and grab an occasional treat for yourself or when you need something special for an event or holiday. They have a great selection of cupcakes and other treats that are always delicious. Sarah's carrot cake and carrot cake cupcakes are a family favorite for all of our holidays, but we have tried many treats and have loved them all.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nava K.
We got a tasting from here while exploring desserts for our wedding and while the cake and cupcakes looked beautiful, we were not impressed with the taste. Some of the flavors and fillings tasted artificial/commercial to us, and some of the items didn't have much flavor or were just one-note sweet. I will say the cream cheese icing on the carrot cupcake and red velvet cake was great - those were the two best items of what we tried.
Melissa Paul
Couldn’t get a call back to even try a cake.
Service: 1
Nick J
I was hoping to leave a wonderful review, but.. I ordered a Mardi Gras King Cake. First time to Sarah's (40 min trip). Shop was nice, the display cupcakes looked good, the worker was nice. The look of my cake was good.My cake was terrible. Seemed as if it was baked a week prior. The cake was hard and dry. Icing was hard. There is an intentional hard toffee type bottom...the taste of that crust is okay if you like that slight burnt type taste, but it didn't help the cake at all. It got thrown away.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Meghan B.
Wedding cake! That is all you need to know about this bakery... Wedding cake! I grew up with a father, who was a baker, and even he raves about the flavor of this cake. It has a light almond flavor to it, and the frosting is out of this world. It never is overly sweet and it is not dry or lacking flavor. Seriously, though there are 100 reasons why to go to Sarahs! They are our one stop shopping when it comes to buying cookies or cupcakes for the holidays. The glitter balls are so much fun and they taste amazing. Their weekly cupcakes, especially their snack cake are out of this world if I had to say anything negative about this place. It is that there is not more. You definitely need to go early in the day if you are just a walk-in because they do run out by the end of the day and I don't blame you. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.! Get a jumpstart on your holiday orders early!
Alex Mcbride
I used Sarah’s for desserts for my wedding. From the very start, communication was flawless. They urged a tasting which was so beneficial in helping choose the desserts we wanted.They stayed up to date with communication during my wedding planning season. Delivery was perfect and on time, and the desserts were DELICIOUS! We will be regular customers at their bakery.10/10 recommend for wedding or catering.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Darla B.
One of my favorite places. Many options walk in store, but can order online and for special occasions. The staff is super friendly and very clean and appealing inside. Not a dine in place, only of you are doing tastings for events. Bring back the pumpkin snickerdoodle please!!! Also the peanut butter dollop pops!
Crystal Reisig
I just had my wedding and the cake was amazing. I was on my way to do photos and had to stop and stare in excitement at it. They were able to incorporate everything (even glitter) I requested. It was beautiful and tasted wonderful. I am excited for the anniversary cake!
Reed Smith
We used Sarah’s Cake Shop for our wedding cake earlier this month and they were incredible! We got dozens of questions on where the cake was from because all of our guests enjoyed it so much!
Sarah's Cake Shop was so easy to work with for our wedding cake! They listened to all our preferences and inspirations and made a beautiful wedding cake that was delicious. We had their cake a friend's wedding years ago and knew we needed to have their cake at ours as well. I can easily say this is the best quality cake we've ever had. Highly recommend using for any important events!
Alona Ivchenko
Awesome service and prices. Our wedding cake was absolutely adorable. Thank you!
Brittany H.
Sarah's Cake Shop was so easy to work with for our wedding cake! They listened to all our preferences and inspirations and made a beautiful wedding cake that was delicious. We had their cake a friend's wedding years ago and knew we needed to have their cake at ours as well. I can easily say this is the best quality cake we've ever had. Highly recommend using for any important events!
Cassidy Norman
From tasting to wedding day, Sarah's Cake Shop was great to work with. The cake was delicious and designed exactly as I had hoped. Nicole (wedding coordinator and cake artist) was responsive and knowledgable. Price was reasonable as well. I will be using Sarah's for future events as well!
Nicole Kirby (Nicole LibNat)
Jordan, the manager, was super friendly and helpful! I tried the pineapple glitter balls, and they may be my new favorite treat, from anywhere!
Desserts are delicious. But the young female working the counter on Saturday 3/30 (day before Easter) needs a serious attitude adjustment. very bad representation for your business- your desserts are so good, while spoil it with such horrid service?
Sarah's is a great local shop to stop by and grab an occasional treat for yourself or when you need something special for an event or holiday. They have a great selection of cupcakes and other treats that are always delicious. Sarah's carrot cake and carrot cake cupcakes are a family favorite for all of our holidays, but we have tried many treats and have loved them all.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We got a tasting from here while exploring desserts for our wedding and while the cake and cupcakes looked beautiful, we were not impressed with the taste. Some of the flavors and fillings tasted artificial/commercial to us, and some of the items didn't have much flavor or were just one-note sweet. I will say the cream cheese icing on the carrot cupcake and red velvet cake was great - those were the two best items of what we tried.
Couldn’t get a call back to even try a cake.
Service: 1
I was hoping to leave a wonderful review, but.. I ordered a Mardi Gras King Cake. First time to Sarah's (40 min trip). Shop was nice, the display cupcakes looked good, the worker was nice. The look of my cake was good.My cake was terrible. Seemed as if it was baked a week prior. The cake was hard and dry. Icing was hard. There is an intentional hard toffee type bottom...the taste of that crust is okay if you like that slight burnt type taste, but it didn't help the cake at all. It got thrown away.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Wedding cake! That is all you need to know about this bakery... Wedding cake! I grew up with a father, who was a baker, and even he raves about the flavor of this cake. It has a light almond flavor to it, and the frosting is out of this world. It never is overly sweet and it is not dry or lacking flavor. Seriously, though there are 100 reasons why to go to Sarahs! They are our one stop shopping when it comes to buying cookies or cupcakes for the holidays. The glitter balls are so much fun and they taste amazing. Their weekly cupcakes, especially their snack cake are out of this world if I had to say anything negative about this place. It is that there is not more. You definitely need to go early in the day if you are just a walk-in because they do run out by the end of the day and I don't blame you. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.! Get a jumpstart on your holiday orders early!
I used Sarah’s for desserts for my wedding. From the very start, communication was flawless. They urged a tasting which was so beneficial in helping choose the desserts we wanted.They stayed up to date with communication during my wedding planning season. Delivery was perfect and on time, and the desserts were DELICIOUS! We will be regular customers at their bakery.10/10 recommend for wedding or catering.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of my favorite places. Many options walk in store, but can order online and for special occasions. The staff is super friendly and very clean and appealing inside. Not a dine in place, only of you are doing tastings for events. Bring back the pumpkin snickerdoodle please!!! Also the peanut butter dollop pops!
I just had my wedding and the cake was amazing. I was on my way to do photos and had to stop and stare in excitement at it. They were able to incorporate everything (even glitter) I requested. It was beautiful and tasted wonderful. I am excited for the anniversary cake!
We used Sarah’s Cake Shop for our wedding cake earlier this month and they were incredible! We got dozens of questions on where the cake was from because all of our guests enjoyed it so much!
Restaurantji Recommends
Sarah's Cake Shop was so easy to work with for our wedding cake! They listened to all our preferences and inspirations and made a beautiful wedding cake that was delicious. We had their cake a friend's wedding years ago and knew we needed to have their cake at ours as well. I can easily say this is the best quality cake we've ever had. Highly recommend using for any important events!
Awesome service and prices. Our wedding cake was absolutely adorable. Thank you!
Sarah's Cake Shop was so easy to work with for our wedding cake! They listened to all our preferences and inspirations and made a beautiful wedding cake that was delicious. We had their cake a friend's wedding years ago and knew we needed to have their cake at ours as well. I can easily say this is the best quality cake we've ever had. Highly recommend using for any important events!
From tasting to wedding day, Sarah's Cake Shop was great to work with. The cake was delicious and designed exactly as I had hoped. Nicole (wedding coordinator and cake artist) was responsive and knowledgable. Price was reasonable as well. I will be using Sarah's for future events as well!
Jordan, the manager, was super friendly and helpful! I tried the pineapple glitter balls, and they may be my new favorite treat, from anywhere!