They have an excellent deep dish, among other great offerings.It's too bad you can't ever order any of it for delivery because not only do they seem to rarely have a driver, but they also have online ordering from Doordash turned off 100% of the time as well.If anyone from Wise Guys is reading this, please know:1. You're trashing the name of a great pizza place that a lot of people enjoyed long before you bought it.2. You are losing money hand over fist by not at least letting people do online ordering through Doordash, if you won't hire more drivers yourselves.Pretty frustrating, but I am sure the folks over at Shakespeares, CiCis, Dominos, and many other places don't mind a bit. You'd be getting a lot of their business if anyone could order the delivery advertised on your site.
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
alicia f
They have a good deep dish but I have been trying to order delivery and the last 3 times I tried was told they dont have a driver. This place used to rock, they were a lifesaver for my husband who was in the hospital for a month and would miss dinner getting tests done, we would order delivery and they would deliver up till 2am. Now I can't even get a pizza delivered at dinner time on an average Thursday!
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Dip Dish Chicago Style Pizza
Trevar Gerken
Staff left my pizza on the bar, and did not let me know my order was ready. Didn’t know it was ready at all. One of the 7 people at the bar(patrons). Told me it’s not a big deal it was only there for ten min. Contacted management. They refused to remedy the situation. Beyond an apology. Was a decent place before ownership changed. Won’t go back to this bar. That was a staple in Columbia. It’s definitely gone down hill. Wouldn’t recommend it to anyone. The bartender was extremely rude. She was talking crap about me to the regulars of the bar. In front of me. Like it was okay. Even though the foods good. It’s not good cold. Was given a lame excuse of why that happened, and ended up eating a cold pizza. That had sat on the bar. Not worth spending your money here.
Adam Weems
The most unprofessional and nastiest kitchen I've ever worked in. Black mold and slugs. If you don't believe me, ask to take a tour of the kitchen. Good luck finding a sober person to make your food.
Brad Pikey
Carry Out or Delivery Only (no dining room).Since they advertise that they are Chicago style pizza, I tried a large deep dish with pepperoni and bacon bits as well as an order of cinnamon sticks. I feel like it was a really good value (a lot of food for a good price) and that the food was really good. I didn't want to give it 5 stars because I've had deep dish pizza in Chicago and it wasn't quite that, but I would recommend giving them a try. This is the closest thing that I have found in Columbia MO to a good Chicago Deep dish.They also have another style that sounded good but I haven't tried yet where they put crust on top and bottom (like a pie). And have cheese and toppings inside and some on top. The description of it sounded like so much food and sounded a bit intimidating over the phone, so I stuck with the Chicago style.The cinnamon sticks were just okay. They were on pizza crust and were dense and dry. The cinnamon was maybe baked on, because it didn't seem like there was any butter or other oil holding it on. I thought they were fine and you get a lot of sticks for a good price. But next time I probably won't order a large (I was feeding 4 people and we only ate about half of the sticks).
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Terry Miller
We called for delivery told no driver for delivery last time we were delivery the xl pizza was greasy as snot horrible food never again
Vali
Just tried to order pizza for delivery and i get told they cant because they dont have a driver. You are a pizza delivery place theres no excuse why you dont have a driver.
Service: 1
James Minor
Don't let the "Cozy" decor fool you, Wise Guys Pizza is GREAT and the staff will make you feel right at home!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepper Cheese, Large Pizza
Gary B.
I've had genuine Chicago pizza before, and although this isn't quite the same, it surpasses authentic Chicago pizza by a long shot. This meat lovers pizza was loaded with an abundance of cheese and toppings. My only gripe is that the crust appeared overcooked, as the picture shows. I hope this was just a one-time occurrence because it's incredibly delicious.
Andrew Gwinn
Wiseguys pizza is a friend favorite in my group! We love the xl pizzas and we have been eating them since we’re teenagers! Great pizza! Friendly staff and you can have a pint at McNallys while you wait on your pizza!
I called and ordered 3 XL pizzas, and 2 orders of wings for pick up. Since the order was over $110 I had to pay over the phone. I was asked if I would like to authorize a tip and I said no, I'm driving to come get it, but thank you. The young man then said "WELL..we are making it for you". I was shocked. I don't care if you felt my response was rude, one should just respond professionally and just say "ok". I have worked full time since I was able to and NEVER asked for a tip for doing my job (unless I was a waitress or something that you typically would tip for) and I certainly was never rude to a customer; no matter what. Do I wish I could ask for a tip every time I helped a client?? Heck yeah, but I don't, and I certainly don't expect one for just doing my job. Not every single job deserves a tip, sorry. I'm sure our order will have something "special" in it now. Yes, I know this is a debatable topic and everyone has their own opinion and this is mine; I am tired of people wanting a tip for just doing their job. Turns out this person was also the manager!
jason weber
Best home-town style and flavor I’ve had in a long while. Huge quantity, and also checks the ‘leftover pizza next morning is great’ box. A bit spendy, but the taste is commensurate with price
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
AMbz Nicole
I love love their food. Its a small hole in wall place. They offer outside seating. Its a little confusing bc its connected to a bar. But the pizza is worth it and their salads are da bomb!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ethan Cordray
Solid pizza. Get the XL, it seems expensive but it's actually a bargain for how much you get. Not gonna lie, sometimes the mess up your order. But if they, do, they make it right and give you a freebie.Parking: Right next to a big cheap parking garage.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Large Pizza, Supreme Pizza
Nikkidemus Phenoix
This pizza is legit. Drove from STL and had to try local. The cheese is phenomenal. Sauce is delicious. Sausage spicy but great. Definitely give it a shot, it's worth it!
They have an excellent deep dish, among other great offerings.It's too bad you can't ever order any of it for delivery because not only do they seem to rarely have a driver, but they also have online ordering from Doordash turned off 100% of the time as well.If anyone from Wise Guys is reading this, please know:1. You're trashing the name of a great pizza place that a lot of people enjoyed long before you bought it.2. You are losing money hand over fist by not at least letting people do online ordering through Doordash, if you won't hire more drivers yourselves.Pretty frustrating, but I am sure the folks over at Shakespeares, CiCis, Dominos, and many other places don't mind a bit. You'd be getting a lot of their business if anyone could order the delivery advertised on your site.
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
They have a good deep dish but I have been trying to order delivery and the last 3 times I tried was told they dont have a driver. This place used to rock, they were a lifesaver for my husband who was in the hospital for a month and would miss dinner getting tests done, we would order delivery and they would deliver up till 2am. Now I can't even get a pizza delivered at dinner time on an average Thursday!
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Dip Dish Chicago Style Pizza
Staff left my pizza on the bar, and did not let me know my order was ready. Didn’t know it was ready at all. One of the 7 people at the bar(patrons). Told me it’s not a big deal it was only there for ten min. Contacted management. They refused to remedy the situation. Beyond an apology. Was a decent place before ownership changed. Won’t go back to this bar. That was a staple in Columbia. It’s definitely gone down hill. Wouldn’t recommend it to anyone. The bartender was extremely rude. She was talking crap about me to the regulars of the bar. In front of me. Like it was okay. Even though the foods good. It’s not good cold. Was given a lame excuse of why that happened, and ended up eating a cold pizza. That had sat on the bar. Not worth spending your money here.
The most unprofessional and nastiest kitchen I've ever worked in. Black mold and slugs. If you don't believe me, ask to take a tour of the kitchen. Good luck finding a sober person to make your food.
Carry Out or Delivery Only (no dining room).Since they advertise that they are Chicago style pizza, I tried a large deep dish with pepperoni and bacon bits as well as an order of cinnamon sticks. I feel like it was a really good value (a lot of food for a good price) and that the food was really good. I didn't want to give it 5 stars because I've had deep dish pizza in Chicago and it wasn't quite that, but I would recommend giving them a try. This is the closest thing that I have found in Columbia MO to a good Chicago Deep dish.They also have another style that sounded good but I haven't tried yet where they put crust on top and bottom (like a pie). And have cheese and toppings inside and some on top. The description of it sounded like so much food and sounded a bit intimidating over the phone, so I stuck with the Chicago style.The cinnamon sticks were just okay. They were on pizza crust and were dense and dry. The cinnamon was maybe baked on, because it didn't seem like there was any butter or other oil holding it on. I thought they were fine and you get a lot of sticks for a good price. But next time I probably won't order a large (I was feeding 4 people and we only ate about half of the sticks).
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
We called for delivery told no driver for delivery last time we were delivery the xl pizza was greasy as snot horrible food never again
Just tried to order pizza for delivery and i get told they cant because they dont have a driver. You are a pizza delivery place theres no excuse why you dont have a driver.
Service: 1
Don't let the "Cozy" decor fool you, Wise Guys Pizza is GREAT and the staff will make you feel right at home!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepper Cheese, Large Pizza
I've had genuine Chicago pizza before, and although this isn't quite the same, it surpasses authentic Chicago pizza by a long shot. This meat lovers pizza was loaded with an abundance of cheese and toppings. My only gripe is that the crust appeared overcooked, as the picture shows. I hope this was just a one-time occurrence because it's incredibly delicious.
Wiseguys pizza is a friend favorite in my group! We love the xl pizzas and we have been eating them since we’re teenagers! Great pizza! Friendly staff and you can have a pint at McNallys while you wait on your pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I called and ordered 3 XL pizzas, and 2 orders of wings for pick up. Since the order was over $110 I had to pay over the phone. I was asked if I would like to authorize a tip and I said no, I'm driving to come get it, but thank you. The young man then said "WELL..we are making it for you". I was shocked. I don't care if you felt my response was rude, one should just respond professionally and just say "ok". I have worked full time since I was able to and NEVER asked for a tip for doing my job (unless I was a waitress or something that you typically would tip for) and I certainly was never rude to a customer; no matter what. Do I wish I could ask for a tip every time I helped a client?? Heck yeah, but I don't, and I certainly don't expect one for just doing my job. Not every single job deserves a tip, sorry. I'm sure our order will have something "special" in it now. Yes, I know this is a debatable topic and everyone has their own opinion and this is mine; I am tired of people wanting a tip for just doing their job. Turns out this person was also the manager!
Best home-town style and flavor I’ve had in a long while. Huge quantity, and also checks the ‘leftover pizza next morning is great’ box. A bit spendy, but the taste is commensurate with price
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love love their food. Its a small hole in wall place. They offer outside seating. Its a little confusing bc its connected to a bar. But the pizza is worth it and their salads are da bomb!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Solid pizza. Get the XL, it seems expensive but it's actually a bargain for how much you get. Not gonna lie, sometimes the mess up your order. But if they, do, they make it right and give you a freebie.Parking: Right next to a big cheap parking garage.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Large Pizza, Supreme Pizza
This pizza is legit. Drove from STL and had to try local. The cheese is phenomenal. Sauce is delicious. Sausage spicy but great. Definitely give it a shot, it's worth it!