Food and ambiance is amazing!! Love this place so much. Great for special occasions or to impress or just love of food.
Aaron Stoppe
This was our first experience eating at a high class restaurant. It was absolutely amazing.. loved the cottage setting, the atmosphere was comfortable, cozy and elegant.. the food was incredible. Chef Carl and his family were so welcoming and friendly.. an experience of a
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J 94
Food is amazing! I have had the fortunate experience of eating here on three occasions. The most recent one did make me wonder if I will be back. Don’t get me wrong, the food is SO amazing. However, we did not end up doing the wine pairings this time, and realized that because of that, service was compromised and left us a little wanting from the time we arrived all the way through the 3-hr meal.On arrival 30 min before the dinner, we had to go find someone to see if we could get a pre-dinner drink. The owner apologized and served us directly, which was nice… but we took this drink into the dining room for dinner and were NEVER asked again if we wanted more… there were 4 of us! And this was through an entire 3-hr meal. We each separately had to chase down servers to get a second drink.In hindsight this seems kind of petty, but with an experience like Stone Soup, I expected them to be a little more on top of service. The owners were on par with serving meals and asking how it was.. but having to chase down people to see if we could have a second drink left our party a little wanting. It made me wonder if a fourth trip was in our future. ??♀️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Steve Cooper
1 of the best experiences you'll ever have with food. The best experience I've had personally. We've been a few times now. You'll taste flavors you never get to.Wheelchair accessibility: Plenty close to the door
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cantal Cheese Souffle, Gulab Jamun, Lobster Bisque, Pork Empanada, Prime Beef, Onion Soup, Eggs Benedict, Sorbet, Dinner, Stella Artois, Wine Pairing, Chilled Sweet Corn Bisque, With Smoked Pork Empanada, Second Course, First Course, Roasted Rabbit, Burrata, Pan Roasted Grouper Fillet, Cobbler, Mochi
Bea Romeo
Best dinning experience we ever had in our life. Thanks Chef Carl. We will visit
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dinner
Aimee D.
I've put off writing a review of Stone Soup Cottage because I'm not sure I can properly sum up how beautiful of a place it is. We've been here several times for their wine pairing dinners, and I am always completely blown away; and that's putting it mildly. The space is just gorgeous. There's this moment when you're driving up in the dark, and suddenly you see this illuminated farmhouse in all of its glory, and you just know it's going to be a special evening. Their wine pairing dinners sell out quickly, so keep your eyes on their website and social media. I'd also recommend waiting for a dinner when you know you're going to love every single course, only because the dinners are quite expensive. We recently went to their white truffle dinner and had, hands down, the best dining experience of our lives. Show up early--I believe you can get to your table an hour before the dinner begins--and let their talented team craft you a cocktail. From there, you can definitely expect top-tier plates and expertly-paired wines. Truly, it's just a delightful experience from beginning to end. I'm always so shocked that this is all going down in Cottleville! We'll be back many times, if we're lucky.
Kathy
It is a full evening experience. Plan on a few hours for dinner. No rushing through this meal. You get to take your time and enjoy every course. My husband and I have not spent that much time together talking in a long time. We celebrated our 33 wedding anniversary. It was a relaxing evening.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
K Taylor
In a country filled with delicious food and wine, Stone Soup Cottage exceeds all restaurants we’ve tried. Chef Carl’s food is beyond delicious and is so beautifully presented. His wife, Nancy, the Cottage’s sommelier, pairs the perfect wine with each course, and her cocktails are also delicious. All this and the charming Cottage nestled on a beautiful farm, with their talented family members assisting with exceptional service. We’ve enjoyed SSC many times, and we look forward to many more times to come.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dinner, Wine Pairing
Jami R.
The food was absolutely amazing in a cozy yet upscale cottage ambiance. Many simple classics made with produce from the farm which equals a fresh wow factor. The fact chef takes his time to serve drinks and food was a very nice touch. Disappointed two items which should have come out warm arrived cold, including our soup. I left very satisfied and full, but my husband left still hungry. I'd say each course came about 30 minutes after the next and by the time the next course came he was starving. Everyone is served at the same time so their is definitely no chance in "rushing" the tastings. Hard to pay a hefty price for dinner and still need to get food on the way home. If you are an early to bed person or have something to do early the next day, this is not your place! We weren't expecting a 4 hour dinner....I think we were ready for bed by course 3 to be honest.
Sue D.
Amazing chef. Exclusive. Expensive. Wine flights excellent. Special occasion. Reserve far in advance.
Chef Carl & Nancy curated an exquisite coursed dinner experience that is second to none in the area. We felt welcomed by the staff, tasted outstanding dishes, and enjoyed every moment of our time there. Each month, Chef changes the menu based on seasonal themes and availability. The October autumn harvest selections did not disappoint; the brûléed sweet potato tartlet and salad was a personal favorite. Bravo! Cannot wait to return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brynn Watkins
This place is stunning and I have had some of my favorite dinners here ever! A must try!
Yitzchak Palatnik
We came here for the cooking experience and the 3 course meal.Nancy met us at the door with sparkling rose, we also met Chef Carl, and got to chat before the dinner experience.They gave us a tour of their beautiful property, where many of the ingredients are grown.The food was top notch. Very delicious, beautiful, and appetizing!We had great cocktails, great mocktails, and great wines!I highly recommend coming here, it’s such a gem of a place! You’re going to love it!Parking: There’s a privet parking lot with plenty of space for everyone!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dinner
Brian D.
Quaint and beautiful property, thoughtfully curated dishes and wine pairings, excellent service and execution.
LUTHER ARRINGTON
Doesn’t get any Better, what a fine Dining experience this is a must experience restaurant. Bon appetite ! ???
Food and ambiance is amazing!! Love this place so much. Great for special occasions or to impress or just love of food.
This was our first experience eating at a high class restaurant. It was absolutely amazing.. loved the cottage setting, the atmosphere was comfortable, cozy and elegant.. the food was incredible. Chef Carl and his family were so welcoming and friendly.. an experience of a
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food is amazing! I have had the fortunate experience of eating here on three occasions. The most recent one did make me wonder if I will be back. Don’t get me wrong, the food is SO amazing. However, we did not end up doing the wine pairings this time, and realized that because of that, service was compromised and left us a little wanting from the time we arrived all the way through the 3-hr meal.On arrival 30 min before the dinner, we had to go find someone to see if we could get a pre-dinner drink. The owner apologized and served us directly, which was nice… but we took this drink into the dining room for dinner and were NEVER asked again if we wanted more… there were 4 of us! And this was through an entire 3-hr meal. We each separately had to chase down servers to get a second drink.In hindsight this seems kind of petty, but with an experience like Stone Soup, I expected them to be a little more on top of service. The owners were on par with serving meals and asking how it was.. but having to chase down people to see if we could have a second drink left our party a little wanting. It made me wonder if a fourth trip was in our future. ??♀️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
1 of the best experiences you'll ever have with food. The best experience I've had personally. We've been a few times now. You'll taste flavors you never get to.Wheelchair accessibility: Plenty close to the door
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cantal Cheese Souffle, Gulab Jamun, Lobster Bisque, Pork Empanada, Prime Beef, Onion Soup, Eggs Benedict, Sorbet, Dinner, Stella Artois, Wine Pairing, Chilled Sweet Corn Bisque, With Smoked Pork Empanada, Second Course, First Course, Roasted Rabbit, Burrata, Pan Roasted Grouper Fillet, Cobbler, Mochi
Best dinning experience we ever had in our life. Thanks Chef Carl. We will visit
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dinner
I've put off writing a review of Stone Soup Cottage because I'm not sure I can properly sum up how beautiful of a place it is. We've been here several times for their wine pairing dinners, and I am always completely blown away; and that's putting it mildly. The space is just gorgeous. There's this moment when you're driving up in the dark, and suddenly you see this illuminated farmhouse in all of its glory, and you just know it's going to be a special evening. Their wine pairing dinners sell out quickly, so keep your eyes on their website and social media. I'd also recommend waiting for a dinner when you know you're going to love every single course, only because the dinners are quite expensive. We recently went to their white truffle dinner and had, hands down, the best dining experience of our lives. Show up early--I believe you can get to your table an hour before the dinner begins--and let their talented team craft you a cocktail. From there, you can definitely expect top-tier plates and expertly-paired wines. Truly, it's just a delightful experience from beginning to end. I'm always so shocked that this is all going down in Cottleville! We'll be back many times, if we're lucky.
It is a full evening experience. Plan on a few hours for dinner. No rushing through this meal. You get to take your time and enjoy every course. My husband and I have not spent that much time together talking in a long time. We celebrated our 33 wedding anniversary. It was a relaxing evening.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
In a country filled with delicious food and wine, Stone Soup Cottage exceeds all restaurants we’ve tried. Chef Carl’s food is beyond delicious and is so beautifully presented. His wife, Nancy, the Cottage’s sommelier, pairs the perfect wine with each course, and her cocktails are also delicious. All this and the charming Cottage nestled on a beautiful farm, with their talented family members assisting with exceptional service. We’ve enjoyed SSC many times, and we look forward to many more times to come.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dinner, Wine Pairing
The food was absolutely amazing in a cozy yet upscale cottage ambiance. Many simple classics made with produce from the farm which equals a fresh wow factor. The fact chef takes his time to serve drinks and food was a very nice touch. Disappointed two items which should have come out warm arrived cold, including our soup. I left very satisfied and full, but my husband left still hungry. I'd say each course came about 30 minutes after the next and by the time the next course came he was starving. Everyone is served at the same time so their is definitely no chance in "rushing" the tastings. Hard to pay a hefty price for dinner and still need to get food on the way home. If you are an early to bed person or have something to do early the next day, this is not your place! We weren't expecting a 4 hour dinner....I think we were ready for bed by course 3 to be honest.
Amazing chef. Exclusive. Expensive. Wine flights excellent. Special occasion. Reserve far in advance.
Restaurantji Recommends
Chef Carl & Nancy curated an exquisite coursed dinner experience that is second to none in the area. We felt welcomed by the staff, tasted outstanding dishes, and enjoyed every moment of our time there. Each month, Chef changes the menu based on seasonal themes and availability. The October autumn harvest selections did not disappoint; the brûléed sweet potato tartlet and salad was a personal favorite. Bravo! Cannot wait to return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is stunning and I have had some of my favorite dinners here ever! A must try!
We came here for the cooking experience and the 3 course meal.Nancy met us at the door with sparkling rose, we also met Chef Carl, and got to chat before the dinner experience.They gave us a tour of their beautiful property, where many of the ingredients are grown.The food was top notch. Very delicious, beautiful, and appetizing!We had great cocktails, great mocktails, and great wines!I highly recommend coming here, it’s such a gem of a place! You’re going to love it!Parking: There’s a privet parking lot with plenty of space for everyone!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dinner
Quaint and beautiful property, thoughtfully curated dishes and wine pairings, excellent service and execution.
Doesn’t get any Better, what a fine Dining experience this is a must experience restaurant. Bon appetite ! ???
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5