Cupcake Fetish Cafe

2286 McKelvey Rd, Maryland Heights
(314) 628-1036

Recent Reviews

Denise Fields

I had the opportunity to enjoy brunch at Cupcake Fetish Café with my group "Brunch Beauties." Brunch tasted superb served by Bridgette, the owner who was lovely herself. The atmosphere and décor of the café was beautiful. I "thank you" Bridgette for an awesome time."Best of All" in your future endeavors.

Jennifer Rigdon

Needed cupcakes for my boss' birthday and decided it was time to visit Cupcake Fetish! And I was NOT disappointed! I did the variety assortment of cupcakes, and WOW! They were not only beautiful but delicious. And the service is outstanding. I can thank you all enough for helping make my boss' birthday wonderful. I will definitely be back - highly recommend!

Jennifer Pitcher

Ordered cupcakes and cake pops for outdoor company event. With recent St Louis heat and temps Bridgette suggested keeping them cool- so the cupcakes got their own cooler! Worked perfectly! Thank you!

Mickey C.

Everything that I have tried had been delicious! I personally love the turtle cup cakes.

Monica Potpourri

Ordered this 6 inch custom cake for my Partner's Birthday, and she loved it! Chocolate cake, chocolate and caramel filling, sea salt caramel, toffee crunch, and chocolate covered strawberries. Moist, delicious, and reasonably priced. She had family who want to get their upcoming birthday cake from there too. (Side note, I added my own Birthday sign and candles).

Joshua Monroe

Stopped by for the first time today. Banana Pudding cupcake was legit and Strawberry Cheesecake in a Jar was life changing! 10/10 would recommend.

E Mo

Cupcake Fetish did the cake, cupcakes and Groom’s cake for my wedding and there was non left! I requested a pink heart shaped cake with cascading pearls and they owe me nothing! The cake was done exactly the way I asked and they even set aside each flavor of cupcake for me my husband to enjoy. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable about what cakes to choose for each Tier and remained in contact to ensure what we wanted would be executed. Cupcake Fetish did a wonderful job and I definitely recommend them for your events: weddings, baby showers, birthdays, etc! Thank you again Cupcake Fetish!! -The Liddells

Beth Wagner

The amazing team made an impromptu birthday party a reality and it went so smoothly! The venue is adorable. The brunch was delicious. The team was a delight! I can't say enough about them. Amazing work!

Emma Johannah Voskuil

Cupcake Fetish stepped up for us when last minute birthday plans for my best friends twin boys 2nd birthday party fell through. We reached out to them on a Wednesday and they made the party happen by that Saturday! Not only was the food amazing, fresh, hot and delicious, but her staff was incredibly sweet and kind to our rather rambunctious group. I would totally recommend them for everything from a quick cupcake pick up to a family brunch party and more. They were so great!

Heather C-E

I've been going to Cupcake Fetish since they opened and I love it! Though I'm mostly in it for the delicious cupcakes and cake pops, they also do special order cake and cupcakes (you can get flavors of cupcakes online that you can't in store, likely boozy cupcakes, and they try to do pickup the next day or two). And they have delivery through Grub Hub. Please stop by and support the lovely women who own and run this business!

Karen T

I was excited to try the cupcakes since I had a craving and saw there's good reviews, however, I was very disappointed. I wasted my money big time. I ordered delivery through GrubHub but it doesn't matter where you order it from. Anyway I selected 6 flavors and they all were bland, the frosting was one glob of butter texture. It was like they unthawed the cupcakes and they were not fresh. Honestly I could have made my own that tasted better. The cupcakes tasted like a cake mix. So I wasted $20 plus all the reduculius fees on top of that. Some places are over rated like this one. Sorry kind of mean but being honest here.

r a

Family of 5 Had breakfast Sunday, . Everything outstanding; customer service, clean dining area, and food. Small breakfast menu which has all the usual favorites. The fried chicken had light crust with good light seasoning and juicy, and I will be back for more! Southern potatoes, again, good seasoning, light oil, good texture. Breakfast croissant sliders, French toast, waffles all good. We decided to pick out our cupcakes for take home before we sat down, which worked out great. Glad we have them not too far away!

Kris Lugosi

Friendly, happy staff! Clean and cute and the cupcakes are wonderfully priced. The butter cream is thick but not overpowering. The cupcake crumb itself is divine. I got five cupcakes and they are fresh and the perfect size. Highly recommend this cute hidden cafe. Looking forward to trying their Sunday brunch!

Erin Erin

We’ve had a few themed birthday cakes made here and every one exceeded our expectations! The little personalized details that they took upon themselves to create so we’d have a more memorable experience is second to none. I highly recommend cupcake fetish for any sweet treat, celebration, need!

Leah Merrifield

Thank you Cupcake Fetish! Tavonna saved the day by making sure my daughter got the cake of her choosing - strawberry lemonade!! Y’all are THE best

Load More