This is my first time going to Pie On The Fly, I have been craving a coconut creme pie for a while now so i decided to search up "pies near me" and it was the first suggested spot and they have coconut creme pies!! I tried it and I fell in love I will definitely be coming back and getting more of this coconut creme pie!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lauren Mosley
Not only is the food good, the couple who runs it are so sweet! I asked if they had a banana cream pie & they did not. The man then said he’d make one for me. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Connie Marti
The couple who own the shop are very personable and friendly . Awesome variety of pies and other assorted baked treats . All that we tried were wonderful and I will definitely get back there in the near
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie
Barb Kieffer
Highly recommend! Had torts and brownies made for a bridal shower! They were amazing! Will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kim S
Place is very small but the food and service are
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Cross
These wonderful people got me some semi last minute pies for Thanksgiving when I was sure I'd be told it was too late. I was the last ones made and they were delicious. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hayley Walton
Hands down the best key lime me and my husband have ever had! Owners are so kind! We’ve ordered a few times and will continue to do so!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lauren Feise
My husband and I used Pie on the Fly for our wedding at the end of September, and we had such a great experience! We ordered mini cheesecakes and brownies and they were an absolute hit! We were able to customize the flavors we wanted and even picked out the wrappers they were in to match our wedding colors! Not only were they great, but they are reasonably priced as well. This is a family owned shop that truly cares about their craft and it shows! We will definitely be back and use them again if we ever have another event! Thank you so much!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It’s Timara
Donna was so welcoming and sweet! Not only was the environment clean and homey, the Pie was fresh and only the fly !! If you’re in O’Fallon I would highly recommend. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jay Cee
So let’s talk about it….my daughter and I JUST literally walked out of this quaint little bakery where we met the owners….I purchased 8 small cakes and pies and their oatmeal and chocolate chip cookies. The only thing I can say is OH MY GOODNESS…..it was literally like being in my grandmothers kitchen but better!!!!! I have never tasted anything this “heavenly” or good before and my Grandmother was a PHENOMENAL baker! We sat here and tried everything I purchased and everything was just as good as the next!!!! I can’t choose what’s my favorite so I’ll just keep buying them all!!!! Thank you both for being so kind and welcoming!! I know we purchased a lot but it is WORTH every single scent! My mother said we have to order pies for the holidays! I thought people exaggerated the reviews….but how wrong was I? Thank you ?? ❤️??❤️??
Truly a fabulous pie shop with absolutely phenomenal pies!! This was our first time having Pie on the Fly (I wanted to find a local pie shop for my boyfriend's birthday, he loves pies!) and it was spectacular!! The mom and pop shop is run by the kindest folks who are so incredibly friendly and sweet!! We purchased a key lime pie (full sized) and then a pumpkin pretzel crust and coconut cream pie (mini pies that are about 6 inches in diameter) - all three pies were magnificent!! You c a tell the recipes are high quality as well as the ingredients. The key lime pie had lime zest throughout that was so delightful and the coconut cream pie had shredded coconut in the custard - just a couple examples of the deliciousness we experienced with these pies! The inside is quaint and lovely! The drive out from Saint Louis is completely worth it and I can't wait to come back and try more of their delicious pies!!
Diala A.
Absolutely phenomenal pies!! This was our first time having Pie on the Fly (I wanted to find a local pie shop for my boyfriend's birthday, he loves pies!) and it was spectacular!! The mom and pop shop is run by the kindest folks who are so incredibly friendly and sweet!! We purchased a key lime pie (full sized) and then a pumpkin pretzel crust and coconut cream pie (mini pies that are about 6 inches in diameter) - all three pies were magnificent!! You c a tell the recipes are high quality as well as the ingredients. The key lime pie had lime zest throughout that was so delightful and the coconut cream pie had shredded coconut in the custard - just a couple examples of the deliciousness we experienced with these pies! The inside is quaint and lovely! The drive out from Saint Louis is completely worth it and I can't wait to come back and try more of their delicious pies!!
Willow Wideman
Seriously the best pies and sweets I've ever had. This is such a gem. Not a single thing we've tried hadn't been amazing and we've tried A LOT of it. I really love their Key Lime pie and their coconut cream pie.
Jeffrey Beaver
What a great experience. Super friendly and amazing product!
This is my first time going to Pie On The Fly, I have been craving a coconut creme pie for a while now so i decided to search up "pies near me" and it was the first suggested spot and they have coconut creme pies!! I tried it and I fell in love I will definitely be coming back and getting more of this coconut creme pie!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not only is the food good, the couple who runs it are so sweet! I asked if they had a banana cream pie & they did not. The man then said he’d make one for me. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The couple who own the shop are very personable and friendly . Awesome variety of pies and other assorted baked treats . All that we tried were wonderful and I will definitely get back there in the near
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie
Highly recommend! Had torts and brownies made for a bridal shower! They were amazing! Will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Place is very small but the food and service are
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
These wonderful people got me some semi last minute pies for Thanksgiving when I was sure I'd be told it was too late. I was the last ones made and they were delicious. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hands down the best key lime me and my husband have ever had! Owners are so kind! We’ve ordered a few times and will continue to do so!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I used Pie on the Fly for our wedding at the end of September, and we had such a great experience! We ordered mini cheesecakes and brownies and they were an absolute hit! We were able to customize the flavors we wanted and even picked out the wrappers they were in to match our wedding colors! Not only were they great, but they are reasonably priced as well. This is a family owned shop that truly cares about their craft and it shows! We will definitely be back and use them again if we ever have another event! Thank you so much!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Donna was so welcoming and sweet! Not only was the environment clean and homey, the Pie was fresh and only the fly !! If you’re in O’Fallon I would highly recommend. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
So let’s talk about it….my daughter and I JUST literally walked out of this quaint little bakery where we met the owners….I purchased 8 small cakes and pies and their oatmeal and chocolate chip cookies. The only thing I can say is OH MY GOODNESS…..it was literally like being in my grandmothers kitchen but better!!!!! I have never tasted anything this “heavenly” or good before and my Grandmother was a PHENOMENAL baker! We sat here and tried everything I purchased and everything was just as good as the next!!!! I can’t choose what’s my favorite so I’ll just keep buying them all!!!! Thank you both for being so kind and welcoming!! I know we purchased a lot but it is WORTH every single scent! My mother said we have to order pies for the holidays! I thought people exaggerated the reviews….but how wrong was I? Thank you ?? ❤️??❤️??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Truly a fabulous pie shop with absolutely phenomenal pies!! This was our first time having Pie on the Fly (I wanted to find a local pie shop for my boyfriend's birthday, he loves pies!) and it was spectacular!! The mom and pop shop is run by the kindest folks who are so incredibly friendly and sweet!! We purchased a key lime pie (full sized) and then a pumpkin pretzel crust and coconut cream pie (mini pies that are about 6 inches in diameter) - all three pies were magnificent!! You c a tell the recipes are high quality as well as the ingredients. The key lime pie had lime zest throughout that was so delightful and the coconut cream pie had shredded coconut in the custard - just a couple examples of the deliciousness we experienced with these pies! The inside is quaint and lovely! The drive out from Saint Louis is completely worth it and I can't wait to come back and try more of their delicious pies!!
Absolutely phenomenal pies!! This was our first time having Pie on the Fly (I wanted to find a local pie shop for my boyfriend's birthday, he loves pies!) and it was spectacular!! The mom and pop shop is run by the kindest folks who are so incredibly friendly and sweet!! We purchased a key lime pie (full sized) and then a pumpkin pretzel crust and coconut cream pie (mini pies that are about 6 inches in diameter) - all three pies were magnificent!! You c a tell the recipes are high quality as well as the ingredients. The key lime pie had lime zest throughout that was so delightful and the coconut cream pie had shredded coconut in the custard - just a couple examples of the deliciousness we experienced with these pies! The inside is quaint and lovely! The drive out from Saint Louis is completely worth it and I can't wait to come back and try more of their delicious pies!!
Seriously the best pies and sweets I've ever had. This is such a gem. Not a single thing we've tried hadn't been amazing and we've tried A LOT of it. I really love their Key Lime pie and their coconut cream pie.
What a great experience. Super friendly and amazing product!
These mini pies are amazing! ? ?