American Pie Co.

$$ •

Hours:
1017 N Olive St, Sullivan
(573) 468-2050

Customers' Favorites

American Pie Co. Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4.7 (46)
Restaurantji Rating

I just had a salad door dashed to me, and now I'm eating it doing a happy dance....these are probably the freshest salad ingredients I have ever eaten while eating out! I also had a special spinach artichoke grilled cheese which tasted better than I had expected it would! The raspberry sweet tea was a little on the unsweetened side so that's good if you don't like your flavored tea too sweet, I didn't expect that but when I think about it I would rather it be on the u sweetened side because I can always sweeten it more if I chose to, which I did not. The coconut creme latte was perfect, and it's not easy to pour espresso and make sure it is the perfect taste and not too burnt. There was the hint of coconut I was expecting and everything I wanted!

Restaurantji Rating

First time and definitely going back! Tried a little bit of everything. Salad bar was top notch. Good pizza and blueberry pie! Expresso was amazing! Super nice, friendly lady taking our order!

More Reviews(46)

Ratings

Menu

Add a Menu
American Pie Co. Menu
American Pie Co. Menu

Photos

Add a Photo
American Pie Co.
American Pie Co.
View All Photos

Hours

Monday 7AM - 5PM
Tuesday 7AM - 5PM
Wednesday 7AM - 5PM
Thursday 7AM - 5PM
Friday 7AM - 5PM
Saturday 7AM - 5PM
Sunday Closed
Updated on: