Excellent food and service. We had pizza, pepperoni bread, and cheesesteaks! We’ve been two times in our 5 nights in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniel Reece
What an exceptional pizzeria located in the most unlikely place. The pizza crust is fabulous, not to mention the ridiculously good red sauce which also comes with the Jersey Buns and homemade meat balls. The atmosphere is incredible, bustling with friendly staff running pizza out to patrons and the smell as soon as you walk through the door tells you you're about to experience a real pizzeria.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Charles H
Was in town for one night and hungry for Pizza, glad I went this route! I used their online ordering, super easy and it gave me a wait time of about 50 minutes. Went with the Animal, was very happy with it. Great crust and sauce that was flavorful, the crust wasn’t too thick so it made for the perfect balanced slices in my eyes! When I got there they were really busy but the staff was friendly and they were doing a great job pumping out pizzas! Excited to try more from Jersey Boys! 9/10. Cheers!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Roy Rodgers
Food was hard as a rock. Ended up having to stop somewhere else. What a shame.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
jonnie weiss
You won't be disappointed! Really amazing pizza. Stoked.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Siri Crain
Pizza was ok… but definitely not worth waiting an hour and a half for!!! Extremely slow!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Brandy V.
Great pizza! Great service! Bit of a wait later on a Saturday night, but worth it. Great NY style pizza!
Angelica Bennett
The best pizza in Montana hands down!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brittany S.
Visiting Whitefish for the first time with my family and we were searching for good pizza. Jersey Boys Pizza had the best reviews so we went to check it out and I can confirm the reviews were spot on. Fresh, homemade and delicious. We got the animal pizza (meat lovers) and my parents got the monster pizza (supreme) and it was a 15/10. Highly recommend.
Whitney Mccarthy
Very small location, not family friendly. Pizza was greasy and undercooked.
We enjoyed a half and half Specialty pizza and a Big Mountain Caesar Salad. The tastefor both was next level. We had it delivered - it was a game changer. You must give this place a try!
Jennifer O.
Jersey boys was a very tasty (and fairly economical ) choice for dinner while visiting. Their pizza roll garlic things are incredible... those are a must order! The pizza was also tasty. Their prices were reasonable for the area. The only downside was that they were so busy (obviously not a problem for them) which meant a bit of a line to order and a bit of a wait, but overall it was very good!
Amar Patel
This place was the bomb dot com ?. If you're looking for good pizza in Whitefish, this is the place to go. No freezer dough/pies like you'll see at some of the breweries.Reasonable prices and solid selection of ingredients. I did wish they split the pricing of ingredients (meats and cheeses more expensive, veggies cheaper), though. We had a custom pie pizza and a hot veggie sandwhich. Both were excellent.Everyone who worked here was awesome - great service and great personalities (notwithstanding being a Duke fan ? ?).If you're visiting from NY/NJ - this place lives up to its name. This was a great last meal for us after a week on the slopes. Definitely our go-to spot when we visit again :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dave S.
Solid pie. Got the combo for takeout. Filled me for dinner and breakfast. Loved the bite to the crust. Nice.
Pilar C.
Consistently delicious pizza, sandwiches and salads. Easy online ordering for pick up and good communication if anything is unclear! It's a family favorite for sure.
Excellent food and service. We had pizza, pepperoni bread, and cheesesteaks! We’ve been two times in our 5 nights in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
What an exceptional pizzeria located in the most unlikely place. The pizza crust is fabulous, not to mention the ridiculously good red sauce which also comes with the Jersey Buns and homemade meat balls. The atmosphere is incredible, bustling with friendly staff running pizza out to patrons and the smell as soon as you walk through the door tells you you're about to experience a real pizzeria.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was in town for one night and hungry for Pizza, glad I went this route! I used their online ordering, super easy and it gave me a wait time of about 50 minutes. Went with the Animal, was very happy with it. Great crust and sauce that was flavorful, the crust wasn’t too thick so it made for the perfect balanced slices in my eyes! When I got there they were really busy but the staff was friendly and they were doing a great job pumping out pizzas! Excited to try more from Jersey Boys! 9/10. Cheers!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Food was hard as a rock. Ended up having to stop somewhere else. What a shame.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
You won't be disappointed! Really amazing pizza. Stoked.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was ok… but definitely not worth waiting an hour and a half for!!! Extremely slow!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Great pizza! Great service! Bit of a wait later on a Saturday night, but worth it. Great NY style pizza!
The best pizza in Montana hands down!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Visiting Whitefish for the first time with my family and we were searching for good pizza. Jersey Boys Pizza had the best reviews so we went to check it out and I can confirm the reviews were spot on. Fresh, homemade and delicious. We got the animal pizza (meat lovers) and my parents got the monster pizza (supreme) and it was a 15/10. Highly recommend.
Very small location, not family friendly. Pizza was greasy and undercooked.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
We enjoyed a half and half Specialty pizza and a Big Mountain Caesar Salad. The tastefor both was next level. We had it delivered - it was a game changer. You must give this place a try!
Jersey boys was a very tasty (and fairly economical ) choice for dinner while visiting. Their pizza roll garlic things are incredible... those are a must order! The pizza was also tasty. Their prices were reasonable for the area. The only downside was that they were so busy (obviously not a problem for them) which meant a bit of a line to order and a bit of a wait, but overall it was very good!
This place was the bomb dot com ?. If you're looking for good pizza in Whitefish, this is the place to go. No freezer dough/pies like you'll see at some of the breweries.Reasonable prices and solid selection of ingredients. I did wish they split the pricing of ingredients (meats and cheeses more expensive, veggies cheaper), though. We had a custom pie pizza and a hot veggie sandwhich. Both were excellent.Everyone who worked here was awesome - great service and great personalities (notwithstanding being a Duke fan ? ?).If you're visiting from NY/NJ - this place lives up to its name. This was a great last meal for us after a week on the slopes. Definitely our go-to spot when we visit again :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Solid pie. Got the combo for takeout. Filled me for dinner and breakfast. Loved the bite to the crust. Nice.
Consistently delicious pizza, sandwiches and salads. Easy online ordering for pick up and good communication if anything is unclear! It's a family favorite for sure.