15 Best Pizza Restaurants near Boiling Spring Lakes

“This is such a little hidden Gem!!!!!!’ I’m giving 5 stars because I can’t give 10!!!! Nichole our server was so awesome!!! She made menu suggestions and overall just a complete joy to do business with. We are from out of state and truly enjoyed the food and OUTSTANDING service we received!!! Whoever is doing the cooking keep up the amazing work!!!! We will for sure be back to dine before we head out of town!“

“I have tried the pizza, pasta, & subs. They were all great! The desserts are awesome too.“

“Well, this review was going to start out as a 1 star...service was almost 90 minutes on a delivery that should have been 45, but the manager remade the food and hand delivered, due to a delivery driver mishap.. either I was starving, due to being with 5 of our grandchildren, or this pizza is just THE best. My Ceasar.salad was incredible and the garlic knots were delicious. Even the picky grandson ate 2 pieces of "cheese pizza". I'm glad I waited on leaving my review, as I was steamed by 730 with no pizza and 5 out of control kids....ty for making it right. And I hope the driver isn't in too much trouble... the food was incredible...and my husband is a chef, so hard for us to find good food. Highly recommend“

“This is the best pizza I have ever had. We drive over 30 mins just to indulge in the food. Garlic knots are to die for! The ingredients are so fresh and flavorful. The atmosphere is amazing and the owners are awesome. I have never had better pizza. Hands down the best.“

“One of the best burgers I've had! Pizza was wonderful as well. I definitely will be a regular customer after giving Mo's a try tonight. I called in my food and it was ready when they said it would be!“

“We make this a must stop every vacation. We get the gluten free pizza and it is delicious! While they can't promise cross contamination, I have never gotten sick.“

“great pizza, little place we happened to find“

“Great little placeStaff is awesome, but I unfortunately had the worst steak and cheese sandwich everyI looked to me like maybe 2 pieces of steak-um meat completely over cooked two little pieces of green pepper and a little bit of cheeseI know I am not in Philly but for $10 dollars I was expecting a lot more than what I was served“

“Chill atmosphere with good beer. We met the owner and he was awesome. He even gave me a sample of a beer he was currently working on and asked my opinion. The beer here was awesome. We didnt eat here vut saw others food which looked very delicious. Highly recommend the peanut butter porter!!!“

“It’s literally a pizza shack so I don’t know why some people expecting fine dining level cuisine here. For what it is it’s fine - pizza you can grab in a pinch when you don’t want to run out and sit down somewhere or head off island for it.I’ve never had an issue with pickup timing, I usually just arrive 7-10 mins after they say it’ll be ready to be safe.“

“Incredible meat sauce, always fresh pasta, salad and bread“

“This place became our favorite family restaurant in January 2024 when we closed on our newly built home. We moved into our house yesterday and had a nice chicken parm dinner to die for! They were busy at 6 pm, but they moved people out fast with a great waitress staff. I can’t praise this place enough. Try for yourself.Dietary restrictions: I had Bariatric bypass May 2022. I often order children size portions. But the dinner size allowed me to get 3 dinners out of 1 meal.Parking: There aren’t many handicapped spaces up front. If you can walk, I’d leave them for the most disabled individuals.Kid-friendliness: The children next to us ate well and no one minded their activities.Wheelchair accessibility: Absolutely. The seater realized quickly I could walk well because of back pain. She was gracious to seat us coming in the door by the pizza/pick up area. Bravo for her kind gesture towards an older woman.“

“We ate here last night. The Tuscan chicken was fantastic! The sauce, meatballs, calamari & cheesecake was delicious. Andre our server is professional, personable, attentive & one of the best servers I have had & we eat out a lot. Kudos!!“

“First time here. I had a take out, and I ordered the spaghetti. Its very basic, and the sauce tasted like it came out of a bottle, no favor, and the noobles needed salt. I only eat what I could, and threw out the rest in the garbage. As for the restaurant itself, it needs be renovated. Looks like an old pizza hut from the 80's.“

“I mean I do recommend it but I got a medium pizza last night that was so sad and soggy and half cooked. I couldn’t even eat it. I had one slice that was good to eat. I ate the crust off another piece and even the crust was sad. I’ve been here so many times that were good. This time was so sad. I called and called and no one picked up. Then I had to go to work before I could go back. In the photo is the sad pizza not even 10 hours later.“