The New York Cheesecake with strawberry sauce was a big hit. It was what my Mom specifically requested for her birthday. The cheesecake was fantastic (creamy, delicate, and light with a thick, flavorful crust) and everyone enjoyed it thoroughly. As a family of many cooks and bakers, there are a lot of high standards. But, hands down one of the best cheesecakes we've had in a long time! Thanks so much!
Robert Schaaf
Must try if you’re in the area!! My wife got the cookie dough and I got the ny style . Will definitely be
Food: 5
Mark
The tiramisu cheesecake is out of this world. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lisa Kilgore
The best NY cheesecake and coconut cream pie we've ever had! The death by chocolate cheesecake was excellent! We've not tried anything that wasn't delicious! I'm glad we live so far away!
Yesterday, We went there for the first time and not only was the cheesecake amazing. Great customer service. Very welcoming and friendly. Just what Cary needs. We will be returning.
Caroline
The cream puffs are amazing!
Mace Farr
I cant believe I finally found a place that reaches my cheesecake standard! ITSS SOOO GOOD!!!!
Meghan D.
This place is AMAZING! We went for the first time. The cream puffs are divine. The peanut butter pie is to die for! We also got Chocolate Covered Strawberry Cheesecake, Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake, and the Deadly Chocolate Cheesecake. All great. Wonderful customer service too!
robert samaskeawicz
Just got home from this place and it's amazing. The lemon bars are incredible and their cheesecake is an amazing blend of taste and texture. I definitely recommend this place and intend to go back soon
Jess O.
Listen, my fiancé ordered some sweets for us from Custom Confections tonight, and all I can say is FANTASTIC. The peanut butter bar? Fudgey, rich, chocolate top layer and the bottom layer was a delightful soft, almost like a peanut butter cookie. He also got me a vanilla cupcake and the icing was phenomenal, light, something I've never tasted but in a good way. He raved about his Heath toffee cheesecake! We are definitely going to be regular customers after tonight's order! 10/10
Our first time there to try the cheesecake. The one person there was less than enthusiastic, with no customer service skills. Asked for recommendations, and he said the plain was most popular and noted the top shelf was also popular. We got the peanut butter cup, and it was just so so. IF we return, it would be to try the plain, but I doubt we'll return.
Christian Bunce
I love this place and the service was amazing, Lucas was a great help and very friendly. I loved the cheesecakes and cannolis were amazing too. Will be revisiting!!!!!
Rachael Healy
Good cheesecakes. Great variety. Friendly staff! Definitely worth it to pick up your own cheesecake instead of using the delivery services. My family and I purchased a few flavors to try: almond joy, death by chocolate, pb cup, white chocolate raspberry, and tiramisu along with a lemon bar and PB bar. My favorite was the almond joy. This is the second time I’ve had the death by chocolate and both times the flourless torte part of it tastes like PB and it’s probably because it’s next to the PB cup in the showcase. I do wish the crusts weren’t as crumbly on them, they often fell apart not making it on the fork with the rest of the cheesecake. Definitely a great spot to get some cheesecake!
Fahad S.
Have passed by this place so many times but never went in until now, and I'm glad I finally did. The cheesecake selection is extensive, and while I only tried the plain NY cheesecake (which was great and light) I am certain the others are also good. In addition to the cheesecake, they do offer a selection of other treats as well. The cheesecake is absolutely amazing, definitely amongst the best in this area. Other goodies from the lemon bars, turtle bar, cannoli and more are all also extremely flavorful and fresh with great textures. I am fairly certain this is primarily a takeout place as there wasn't any seating, or for that matter any decor inside or outside. Also, while I didn't have any issues with the service it wasn't very friendly which added to it not being super inviting. Lastly, I wish the boxes they gave the items in were a bit nicer instead of the standard takeout boxes, just to kind of match the delicious treats inside.Would definitely recommend, especially if you are a fan of cheesecake and will likely grab more stuff from them in the future.
Nicholas Farmer
Lucas Rivas is an amazing worker, he was so polite and helpful. The piece of Key Lime Pie he served me was wonderful
The New York Cheesecake with strawberry sauce was a big hit. It was what my Mom specifically requested for her birthday. The cheesecake was fantastic (creamy, delicate, and light with a thick, flavorful crust) and everyone enjoyed it thoroughly. As a family of many cooks and bakers, there are a lot of high standards. But, hands down one of the best cheesecakes we've had in a long time! Thanks so much!
Must try if you’re in the area!! My wife got the cookie dough and I got the ny style . Will definitely be
Food: 5
The tiramisu cheesecake is out of this world. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best NY cheesecake and coconut cream pie we've ever had! The death by chocolate cheesecake was excellent! We've not tried anything that wasn't delicious! I'm glad we live so far away!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Coconut Cream Pie, Heath Toffee Cheesecake and Chocolate Torte, Chocolate Cake
Yesterday, We went there for the first time and not only was the cheesecake amazing. Great customer service. Very welcoming and friendly. Just what Cary needs. We will be returning.
The cream puffs are amazing!
I cant believe I finally found a place that reaches my cheesecake standard! ITSS SOOO GOOD!!!!
This place is AMAZING! We went for the first time. The cream puffs are divine. The peanut butter pie is to die for! We also got Chocolate Covered Strawberry Cheesecake, Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake, and the Deadly Chocolate Cheesecake. All great. Wonderful customer service too!
Just got home from this place and it's amazing. The lemon bars are incredible and their cheesecake is an amazing blend of taste and texture. I definitely recommend this place and intend to go back soon
Listen, my fiancé ordered some sweets for us from Custom Confections tonight, and all I can say is FANTASTIC. The peanut butter bar? Fudgey, rich, chocolate top layer and the bottom layer was a delightful soft, almost like a peanut butter cookie. He also got me a vanilla cupcake and the icing was phenomenal, light, something I've never tasted but in a good way. He raved about his Heath toffee cheesecake! We are definitely going to be regular customers after tonight's order! 10/10
Restaurantji Recommends
Our first time there to try the cheesecake. The one person there was less than enthusiastic, with no customer service skills. Asked for recommendations, and he said the plain was most popular and noted the top shelf was also popular. We got the peanut butter cup, and it was just so so. IF we return, it would be to try the plain, but I doubt we'll return.
I love this place and the service was amazing, Lucas was a great help and very friendly. I loved the cheesecakes and cannolis were amazing too. Will be revisiting!!!!!
Good cheesecakes. Great variety. Friendly staff! Definitely worth it to pick up your own cheesecake instead of using the delivery services. My family and I purchased a few flavors to try: almond joy, death by chocolate, pb cup, white chocolate raspberry, and tiramisu along with a lemon bar and PB bar. My favorite was the almond joy. This is the second time I’ve had the death by chocolate and both times the flourless torte part of it tastes like PB and it’s probably because it’s next to the PB cup in the showcase. I do wish the crusts weren’t as crumbly on them, they often fell apart not making it on the fork with the rest of the cheesecake. Definitely a great spot to get some cheesecake!
Have passed by this place so many times but never went in until now, and I'm glad I finally did. The cheesecake selection is extensive, and while I only tried the plain NY cheesecake (which was great and light) I am certain the others are also good. In addition to the cheesecake, they do offer a selection of other treats as well. The cheesecake is absolutely amazing, definitely amongst the best in this area. Other goodies from the lemon bars, turtle bar, cannoli and more are all also extremely flavorful and fresh with great textures. I am fairly certain this is primarily a takeout place as there wasn't any seating, or for that matter any decor inside or outside. Also, while I didn't have any issues with the service it wasn't very friendly which added to it not being super inviting. Lastly, I wish the boxes they gave the items in were a bit nicer instead of the standard takeout boxes, just to kind of match the delicious treats inside.Would definitely recommend, especially if you are a fan of cheesecake and will likely grab more stuff from them in the future.
Lucas Rivas is an amazing worker, he was so polite and helpful. The piece of Key Lime Pie he served me was wonderful