This location is closed. We went there just now and it's empty. We went up the street to Original NY Pizza.
Kent Hulick
Possibly the best lasagna I've had in my life. Seriously. Try it, omg. They made custom gnocchi and vodka sauce for me. Divine. Stromboli was fantastic. Someday I have to try the pizza... pic is of gnocchi
Cindy Weichman
What a hidden gem. We were greeted at the door and welcomed right in. The service was amazing and the food outstanding. We chose the house salad with our meal and it was loaded with toppings, not just iceberg lettuce like most places. Me eggplant parm was fantastic. The eggplant was sliced so thin and crispy. My other dinner companions chose the chicken parm and said it was the best they ever had. Sauce was homemade and sooo good. Will definitely go back!
Sal Bova
J&S is always one of the top choices. Their garlic knots are like crack to me and they're huge. The pizza is superb compared to other "NY pizza" places. I have been to every J&S location and they are all good. Personally the one in Apex is my favorite, but Cary offers the same quality and it shows by how busy they are. Love those people and keep that food up.
Chris K (Crispy)
We love their deep fried mushrooms, garlic knots, meatballs in meat sauce, stromboli, and pizza slices. Never had a bad meal and so much to choose from. Staff is always friendly and efficient.
S Mitchell
I have been a huge fan of J&S New York Pizza for 20+ years. My family enjoyed many years of delicious food from their Apex location and now have the good fortune to be just a couple of miles from their Cary location. My favorites are a meat lovers Stromboli with a Caesar salad, but you can’t go wrong with any menu item as this locally-owned family business wants to please your palette.
Dan Wilson
The food and service were really great. I had lasagna and really enjoyed it. My son had pizza and it was also excellent. You gotta try a Rice ball. It's unique and quite tasty.The service was also very good. Our server was prompt and attentive.
Chip Damage
My go to pizza spot in Cary. One of the best in the triangle. Although larger, this location has the same great food as the original in Apex. Try the Grandma and Garbage pies!
Chris K.
Came by a couple weeks ago and returned recently hoping to get their deep fried mushrooms. Unfortunately they don't make them from scratch. They come to them from a supplier frozen and they're delayed like so many things are these days. Too bad cos they're excellent. Maybe they'd consider making them by hand in the interim... We each got a slice of pizza instead that was okay. Hopefully next time we could get one from a freshly made pizza rather than one that's sitting out and gets reheated in the oven. We'll find out tonight when we return!
Tom Krystopa
Amazing food and superb staff!!!My waitress vall went above and beyond and made my experience extremely memorable…would come back just because of her and how she is and does her job not even including the delicious food.Wishing there was a six star review available.?
Moving from nj been looking for pizza similar to home. Was good crust could be a little thinner and put a lil crisp on it . Not a fan of spinach and artichoke dip. Dip was little runny pita chips a little burned. Overall pretty good pizza but nothing like home.
Deepak Rana
It is good place. I have not dine-in till now but I did take out. I just tried garlic knots and garlic bread. First time they are awesomely but second time they were kind of Ok. Iwill post when I will buy third time. Which way it goes. Did not get chance to try Pizza yet. They have space to either dine outside or inside.
Kelvin Bungcayao
The pizza tasted awesome (Large half cheese half veggie) & the family loved it during our visit from Cali. Restaurant was nice & chill and their bar area looked like somewhere I'd like to spend my spare time (didn't get to since I was the driver for the family trip). I'm more of an introvert and I gotta say, the staff is what you'd want to experience during a dining out experience while touring across America. Ben was awesome and personable and the crew in the back were diligently focused on their assigned roles but chill at the same time. It was a very wholesome and family oriented atmosphere during the time we were there. I would definitely recommend stopping by for good eats and a relaxed time.
Barbara Holland
The steak sub with onions, green peppers and mushrooms. All I can say is AMAZING. My husband had the Chicken sub with the same veggies on it and it was also AMAZING. Great food and service.
Youlanda Hudson
I have not had pizza this good since I left Nj... its so good I treated my brother to it last week. Staff is very very nice.
This location is closed. We went there just now and it's empty. We went up the street to Original NY Pizza.
Possibly the best lasagna I've had in my life. Seriously. Try it, omg. They made custom gnocchi and vodka sauce for me. Divine. Stromboli was fantastic. Someday I have to try the pizza... pic is of gnocchi
What a hidden gem. We were greeted at the door and welcomed right in. The service was amazing and the food outstanding. We chose the house salad with our meal and it was loaded with toppings, not just iceberg lettuce like most places. Me eggplant parm was fantastic. The eggplant was sliced so thin and crispy. My other dinner companions chose the chicken parm and said it was the best they ever had. Sauce was homemade and sooo good. Will definitely go back!
J&S is always one of the top choices. Their garlic knots are like crack to me and they're huge. The pizza is superb compared to other "NY pizza" places. I have been to every J&S location and they are all good. Personally the one in Apex is my favorite, but Cary offers the same quality and it shows by how busy they are. Love those people and keep that food up.
We love their deep fried mushrooms, garlic knots, meatballs in meat sauce, stromboli, and pizza slices. Never had a bad meal and so much to choose from. Staff is always friendly and efficient.
I have been a huge fan of J&S New York Pizza for 20+ years. My family enjoyed many years of delicious food from their Apex location and now have the good fortune to be just a couple of miles from their Cary location. My favorites are a meat lovers Stromboli with a Caesar salad, but you can’t go wrong with any menu item as this locally-owned family business wants to please your palette.
The food and service were really great. I had lasagna and really enjoyed it. My son had pizza and it was also excellent. You gotta try a Rice ball. It's unique and quite tasty.The service was also very good. Our server was prompt and attentive.
My go to pizza spot in Cary. One of the best in the triangle. Although larger, this location has the same great food as the original in Apex. Try the Grandma and Garbage pies!
Came by a couple weeks ago and returned recently hoping to get their deep fried mushrooms. Unfortunately they don't make them from scratch. They come to them from a supplier frozen and they're delayed like so many things are these days. Too bad cos they're excellent. Maybe they'd consider making them by hand in the interim... We each got a slice of pizza instead that was okay. Hopefully next time we could get one from a freshly made pizza rather than one that's sitting out and gets reheated in the oven. We'll find out tonight when we return!
Amazing food and superb staff!!!My waitress vall went above and beyond and made my experience extremely memorable…would come back just because of her and how she is and does her job not even including the delicious food.Wishing there was a six star review available.?
Restaurantji Recommends
Moving from nj been looking for pizza similar to home. Was good crust could be a little thinner and put a lil crisp on it . Not a fan of spinach and artichoke dip. Dip was little runny pita chips a little burned. Overall pretty good pizza but nothing like home.
It is good place. I have not dine-in till now but I did take out. I just tried garlic knots and garlic bread. First time they are awesomely but second time they were kind of Ok. Iwill post when I will buy third time. Which way it goes. Did not get chance to try Pizza yet. They have space to either dine outside or inside.
The pizza tasted awesome (Large half cheese half veggie) & the family loved it during our visit from Cali. Restaurant was nice & chill and their bar area looked like somewhere I'd like to spend my spare time (didn't get to since I was the driver for the family trip). I'm more of an introvert and I gotta say, the staff is what you'd want to experience during a dining out experience while touring across America. Ben was awesome and personable and the crew in the back were diligently focused on their assigned roles but chill at the same time. It was a very wholesome and family oriented atmosphere during the time we were there. I would definitely recommend stopping by for good eats and a relaxed time.
The steak sub with onions, green peppers and mushrooms. All I can say is AMAZING. My husband had the Chicken sub with the same veggies on it and it was also AMAZING. Great food and service.
I have not had pizza this good since I left Nj... its so good I treated my brother to it last week. Staff is very very nice.