Stopped by this afternoon to get my usual 2 slices of pizza and I will say it will definitely be my last time. I saw the most grossed out thing ever.I saw an employee put a patrons bare feet on his knees and began to rub her soles this guy worked in the kitchen area and proceeded to go back to work moments later without washing his hands and touch pizza coming out of the oven gently sliding it into boxes. That’s unacceptable and doesn’t make any sense that someone would think that this is appropriate in the food industry. I’m still in shock and shaking my damn head.
Alesa Davis
Best pizza and stromboli in town with the best prices and the best employees. Friendly and fun people. Been coming here since they opened many years ago.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Extra Large Pizza, Garlic Knots
Jason Wilson
Floppy / Bland pizza. Customer Service was Very Polite and Nice. ( 3-15-24 ) Will not be back. Dave P. would give the Pie a 5.7 at best.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Amber Lovano
My son is an extremely picky eater and we usually pick "safe" places to eat but NY style pizza can be hit or miss because of the size of the slice; a wonderful gentleman cut my son's pizza into smaller bite-sized pieces ?They also have some of the BEST stuffed pizza I've ever had ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed, Sicilian Pizza
Megan
The pizza is always so good. I highly recommend this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Extra Large Pizza, Greek Salad, The White Pizza, 2 Slice of Pizza, The White Garden, Stuffed, Garlic Knots, The Greek, Pizza Slice, Hot Wings, BBQ, Buffalo Chicken, Veggie Stromboli, Salads, Small Cheese Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Slice, Sicilian Pizza
Hao Trieu
Good cheese pizza, however, I was not a fan of their sausage topping on another pizza. It lacked flavor.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: 2 Slice of Pizza
Curt Love
This was my first visit to this pizzeria my girlfriend and I was googling New York style pizza. We read the reviews and being from Brooklyn New York I was very skeptical. However, they made me a believer. Everything was excellent I would definitely recommend there pizza ? ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
News Media
Ordered a slice of cheese pizza and a ceaser salad. The pizza was good. The ceaser was a lot of lettuce , stale croutons with one 1.5oz cream ceaser dressing package & no fork included ☹️.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cheese Slice
Jay
Mediocre pizza and lousy service.I visited before heading to the airport after having not come in years. I don’t know if ownership has changed, but the pizza isn’t nearly as good as it used to be.I ordered two slices with sausage, pepperoni and spinach. The spinach was like slapped on top, the sausage was barely cooked and the crust was comically crunchy to the point of being burned.Perhaps worse is the service. I was the only patron in the place when I walked in. The three guys behind the counter barely greeted me, took my order and didn’t even say thanks. As I waited for my food, I watched several others come in and be greeted like family members. When my food arrived the guy just said “your slices are ready”. No thank you or anything. When I left nobody even bothered to say anything, despite the place (again) being empty.I don’t like making assumptions, but as a middle aged man of color I can’t help but notice how I was treated vs others. Perhaps the employees should check their biases. Combine this with lousy food and it’s a recipe that guarantees they’ll never get my money again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Michelle N.
Two of the last 3 times that we have ordered pizza they have not given us the fresh garlic, that we paid a lot for, tonight being one of them. Are there new owners at this location? The pizza seems different lately. Answer to our question would be greatly appreciated.
Well, were do I start ... over the last several months my son has been raving about Original NY Pizza. Sending me pics of the Sicilian slices he was having for lunch. He would stop by on occasion for a quick lunch ... picking up 2 Sicilian slices and a drink txting me that the pizza was just "out of this world delicious". This past Friday instead of getting my weekend pizza from Slice of NY Pizza in Briar Creek, I called Original NY and ordered a 16" x 16" Sicilian pie advertised for $16.00. First some good points: 1. The person who was cooking and serving customers has great customer service. He actually acted as if he was glad to see me even though It was my first time there. This is a rare skill very few have. 2. Their Sanitation Rating Score is something you always want to see. From their kitchen to the restaurant eating area the place look clean ... Great score!! Now the "rest of the story". Upon my arrival my pie was just coming out of the oven and it looked great. When I went to pay, the pizza wasn't $16.00 but $26.00. I was stuned. Because there were other people waiting in line to be served I paid, forgetting to get my receipt I left. When I realize I didnt have my receipt I was going to return but I was caught up in Friday's late afternoon traffic. Well lets continue ... $16 or $26, if the pizza was as good as my son said it was I would rack it up for a lesson in life. When I got home and opened my box there it was my Friday nite pizza treat ... well not so fast ... to my supprise the pizza was the worse I ever purchased. The dough was like rubber (really chewy) and the source was all oregano ... that was all I could taste ... not the cheese or tomato sauce I was totally disappointed. My son knew I was getting a pie from his favorite pizza place, he called and asked how did I like the pie ... another lifes lesson ... my son acknowledge he needed to stand behind his recommendations ... he owes me $26.00. Im going to give this place one more try and see if I can catch that lunchtine Sicilian pie that is truly "out of this world delicious".
B Bailey (Raptor Face)
For starters, the pizza is great! Definitely the highlight of the menu.The wings on the other hand, not so much. I've got them 3 times and not once have them been crispy - including when I specified cooking them longer for crispiness. Also, they don't make their own ranch and give a packet of Ken's ranch.The "Greek" salad is not bad, but they give you Balsamic vinaigrette as opposed to Greek dressing, which I don't get.A few tweaks could really take this place from average to great!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
ryan bitner
Pizza had no flavor. The sauce and sausage were bland. It was a big pizza the crust could have been a little bit thinner. I asked for extra sauce and well done pizza and that was not accomplished. I remember this place having good pizza years ago. I moved out of the area and I breezed true today and was not impressed. Maybe the ownership changed.Also the woman's bathroom had a bad odor in it.34 dollars for a large 2 top and 2 drinks.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Angela Chappell
Our pizza orders have been perfect every time, delicious and hot, and the staff is friendly. This is our No. 1 pizza place now!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Keith W.
Great pizza!! quick service and friendly staff. will def drop back in again when I'm in town!!
Stopped by this afternoon to get my usual 2 slices of pizza and I will say it will definitely be my last time. I saw the most grossed out thing ever.I saw an employee put a patrons bare feet on his knees and began to rub her soles this guy worked in the kitchen area and proceeded to go back to work moments later without washing his hands and touch pizza coming out of the oven gently sliding it into boxes. That’s unacceptable and doesn’t make any sense that someone would think that this is appropriate in the food industry. I’m still in shock and shaking my damn head.
Best pizza and stromboli in town with the best prices and the best employees. Friendly and fun people. Been coming here since they opened many years ago.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Extra Large Pizza, Garlic Knots
Floppy / Bland pizza. Customer Service was Very Polite and Nice. ( 3-15-24 ) Will not be back. Dave P. would give the Pie a 5.7 at best.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
My son is an extremely picky eater and we usually pick "safe" places to eat but NY style pizza can be hit or miss because of the size of the slice; a wonderful gentleman cut my son's pizza into smaller bite-sized pieces ?They also have some of the BEST stuffed pizza I've ever had ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed, Sicilian Pizza
The pizza is always so good. I highly recommend this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Extra Large Pizza, Greek Salad, The White Pizza, 2 Slice of Pizza, The White Garden, Stuffed, Garlic Knots, The Greek, Pizza Slice, Hot Wings, BBQ, Buffalo Chicken, Veggie Stromboli, Salads, Small Cheese Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Slice, Sicilian Pizza
Good cheese pizza, however, I was not a fan of their sausage topping on another pizza. It lacked flavor.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: 2 Slice of Pizza
This was my first visit to this pizzeria my girlfriend and I was googling New York style pizza. We read the reviews and being from Brooklyn New York I was very skeptical. However, they made me a believer. Everything was excellent I would definitely recommend there pizza ? ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a slice of cheese pizza and a ceaser salad. The pizza was good. The ceaser was a lot of lettuce , stale croutons with one 1.5oz cream ceaser dressing package & no fork included ☹️.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cheese Slice
Mediocre pizza and lousy service.I visited before heading to the airport after having not come in years. I don’t know if ownership has changed, but the pizza isn’t nearly as good as it used to be.I ordered two slices with sausage, pepperoni and spinach. The spinach was like slapped on top, the sausage was barely cooked and the crust was comically crunchy to the point of being burned.Perhaps worse is the service. I was the only patron in the place when I walked in. The three guys behind the counter barely greeted me, took my order and didn’t even say thanks. As I waited for my food, I watched several others come in and be greeted like family members. When my food arrived the guy just said “your slices are ready”. No thank you or anything. When I left nobody even bothered to say anything, despite the place (again) being empty.I don’t like making assumptions, but as a middle aged man of color I can’t help but notice how I was treated vs others. Perhaps the employees should check their biases. Combine this with lousy food and it’s a recipe that guarantees they’ll never get my money again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Two of the last 3 times that we have ordered pizza they have not given us the fresh garlic, that we paid a lot for, tonight being one of them. Are there new owners at this location? The pizza seems different lately. Answer to our question would be greatly appreciated.
Restaurantji Recommends
Well, were do I start ... over the last several months my son has been raving about Original NY Pizza. Sending me pics of the Sicilian slices he was having for lunch. He would stop by on occasion for a quick lunch ... picking up 2 Sicilian slices and a drink txting me that the pizza was just "out of this world delicious". This past Friday instead of getting my weekend pizza from Slice of NY Pizza in Briar Creek, I called Original NY and ordered a 16" x 16" Sicilian pie advertised for $16.00. First some good points: 1. The person who was cooking and serving customers has great customer service. He actually acted as if he was glad to see me even though It was my first time there. This is a rare skill very few have. 2. Their Sanitation Rating Score is something you always want to see. From their kitchen to the restaurant eating area the place look clean ... Great score!! Now the "rest of the story". Upon my arrival my pie was just coming out of the oven and it looked great. When I went to pay, the pizza wasn't $16.00 but $26.00. I was stuned. Because there were other people waiting in line to be served I paid, forgetting to get my receipt I left. When I realize I didnt have my receipt I was going to return but I was caught up in Friday's late afternoon traffic. Well lets continue ... $16 or $26, if the pizza was as good as my son said it was I would rack it up for a lesson in life. When I got home and opened my box there it was my Friday nite pizza treat ... well not so fast ... to my supprise the pizza was the worse I ever purchased. The dough was like rubber (really chewy) and the source was all oregano ... that was all I could taste ... not the cheese or tomato sauce I was totally disappointed. My son knew I was getting a pie from his favorite pizza place, he called and asked how did I like the pie ... another lifes lesson ... my son acknowledge he needed to stand behind his recommendations ... he owes me $26.00. Im going to give this place one more try and see if I can catch that lunchtine Sicilian pie that is truly "out of this world delicious".
For starters, the pizza is great! Definitely the highlight of the menu.The wings on the other hand, not so much. I've got them 3 times and not once have them been crispy - including when I specified cooking them longer for crispiness. Also, they don't make their own ranch and give a packet of Ken's ranch.The "Greek" salad is not bad, but they give you Balsamic vinaigrette as opposed to Greek dressing, which I don't get.A few tweaks could really take this place from average to great!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Pizza had no flavor. The sauce and sausage were bland. It was a big pizza the crust could have been a little bit thinner. I asked for extra sauce and well done pizza and that was not accomplished. I remember this place having good pizza years ago. I moved out of the area and I breezed true today and was not impressed. Maybe the ownership changed.Also the woman's bathroom had a bad odor in it.34 dollars for a large 2 top and 2 drinks.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Our pizza orders have been perfect every time, delicious and hot, and the staff is friendly. This is our No. 1 pizza place now!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza!! quick service and friendly staff. will def drop back in again when I'm in town!!