amazing pizza best BLT and Taco in Sheboygan County
Caleb Wuest
We asked what the most recommended pizza was and he said taco and it was amazing!!!
Courtney Badtke
I must say I am always impressed when we order your pizza!! tastes great! hot when it arrives and flavor is spot on!! the nachos Supreme delicious!!!
Liz Nack Kroll
We ordered their pizza for the first time tonight! The taco pizza was so good & the kids loved the pepperoni! The pizza was fresh & hot! Thank you so much! I highly recommend it!
Jim Howard
Just our favorite local no-nonsense unpretentious pizza place, the dough is uniquely delicious. Pretty great salads too! And always, always, the service is absolutely fantastic and friendly.Ask about cheeseburger pizza... (Trying to get this back on the menu)
Jonathan E.
Great pizza! Ordered the cheesy bread, a build your own cheese only pizza with fresh mozzarella, and the Scenes from an Italian Restaurant. Peabody's dough is exceptionally good - it even reheated well the next day. I really enjoyed the Scenes from an Italian Restaurant... the balsamic reduction made it sweet. While I'd want to try other specialties there, I liked this one so much it will be hard to stray. Check out Peabody's if you're looking for good pizza.
Shawn Daugherty
I really like the pizza here, the crust is great! Staff is really friendly every time we get pick up.
Deena Horowitz
We love Peabody Pizza! Discovered during the pandemic - we were happy to find a place with such an extensive menu including vegan options, and you can even order pizza custom by the slice! Their Greek salad is amazing too. A solid favorite that I highly recommend trying.
Gregory Butler
Food was really good just not what I expected for everything I ordered. Thought hot wings were gonna be buffalo style, my fault for lack of research. I was thinking the pepperoni was gonna look like the first picture on slide show should have looked further . And blue cheese was really watered down with no blue cheese chunks in it. Not bad but not worth what I paid for in my opinion. For price I'd recommend at least 7 other pizza places first!
Nyree Williams
They have VEGAN CHEESE!!! Service was superior!! The only thing to keep it from 5 stars is you pay more for vegan cheese , but they dont put alot on your pizza at all. The toppings were slim to none. The up side is the crust was delicious so I will definitely return!!!
Nice people friendly I didn't like the salad but my friend enjoyed it. Pizza was tasty
alleycay
Came to durham for a haircut and found this gem. Great service, delicious pizza with so many toppings to choose from and best side salad!
Flower Girl
the pizza here is soo good and the service was wonderful!! definitely somewhere we intend to come back to :)
Taylor Hunkins
I moved to Durham a few months ago and tried Peabody one of my first nights here. The food is delicious--some of the best pizza I've ever had. Cut to tonight when I ordered from them off Doordash. They processed the order and it was picked up by a delivery person, but that person never showed up to deliver the pizza. I waited an hour and had to work with Doordash to cancel my order and get a refund (which I used towards a new order at Peabody). I get a call from I believe one of the owners of Peabody apologizing for the delay (though it wasn't their fault at all!) He also graciously said he'd be making a new pie and sending the original one too! So all in all, I love this family owned pizza joint because of their great food and incredible service!
Bridget Leslie
We eat here once a month, at least! I love their salads and bruschetta. The owner Jamie is so kind and makes the meal a joy. Im a huge fan and supporter of this place. Always so friendly and warm, plus great veg and vegan options!
amazing pizza best BLT and Taco in Sheboygan County
We asked what the most recommended pizza was and he said taco and it was amazing!!!
I must say I am always impressed when we order your pizza!! tastes great! hot when it arrives and flavor is spot on!! the nachos Supreme delicious!!!
We ordered their pizza for the first time tonight! The taco pizza was so good & the kids loved the pepperoni! The pizza was fresh & hot! Thank you so much! I highly recommend it!
Just our favorite local no-nonsense unpretentious pizza place, the dough is uniquely delicious. Pretty great salads too! And always, always, the service is absolutely fantastic and friendly.Ask about cheeseburger pizza... (Trying to get this back on the menu)
Great pizza! Ordered the cheesy bread, a build your own cheese only pizza with fresh mozzarella, and the Scenes from an Italian Restaurant. Peabody's dough is exceptionally good - it even reheated well the next day. I really enjoyed the Scenes from an Italian Restaurant... the balsamic reduction made it sweet. While I'd want to try other specialties there, I liked this one so much it will be hard to stray. Check out Peabody's if you're looking for good pizza.
I really like the pizza here, the crust is great! Staff is really friendly every time we get pick up.
We love Peabody Pizza! Discovered during the pandemic - we were happy to find a place with such an extensive menu including vegan options, and you can even order pizza custom by the slice! Their Greek salad is amazing too. A solid favorite that I highly recommend trying.
Food was really good just not what I expected for everything I ordered. Thought hot wings were gonna be buffalo style, my fault for lack of research. I was thinking the pepperoni was gonna look like the first picture on slide show should have looked further . And blue cheese was really watered down with no blue cheese chunks in it. Not bad but not worth what I paid for in my opinion. For price I'd recommend at least 7 other pizza places first!
They have VEGAN CHEESE!!! Service was superior!! The only thing to keep it from 5 stars is you pay more for vegan cheese , but they dont put alot on your pizza at all. The toppings were slim to none. The up side is the crust was delicious so I will definitely return!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Nice people friendly I didn't like the salad but my friend enjoyed it. Pizza was tasty
Came to durham for a haircut and found this gem. Great service, delicious pizza with so many toppings to choose from and best side salad!
the pizza here is soo good and the service was wonderful!! definitely somewhere we intend to come back to :)
I moved to Durham a few months ago and tried Peabody one of my first nights here. The food is delicious--some of the best pizza I've ever had. Cut to tonight when I ordered from them off Doordash. They processed the order and it was picked up by a delivery person, but that person never showed up to deliver the pizza. I waited an hour and had to work with Doordash to cancel my order and get a refund (which I used towards a new order at Peabody). I get a call from I believe one of the owners of Peabody apologizing for the delay (though it wasn't their fault at all!) He also graciously said he'd be making a new pie and sending the original one too! So all in all, I love this family owned pizza joint because of their great food and incredible service!
We eat here once a month, at least! I love their salads and bruschetta. The owner Jamie is so kind and makes the meal a joy. Im a huge fan and supporter of this place. Always so friendly and warm, plus great veg and vegan options!