This is a cute cozy spot , very clean and lovely! We were greeted on the way in and out. Service was great and fast. The Pies ? were just what we were needing on this rainy day. The texture of the breading was mouth watering and with the combination of the mixture inside was yummy
LtThompsonCS
Heard great things about this place and am always for exploring locally owned eateries. Came in on a Wed evening and found the place empty; my friend and I were the only customers there. Ended up getting a beef pie (don't remember the name) and strawberry shortcake pie.The beef pie was nothing memorable. It had a dense filling, which surprisingly was quite filling. It had some decent flavor but nothing spectacular. My friend and I half suspected these aren't made daily and perhaps frozen ans then thawed; so that could explain it.The strawberry shortcake pie was surprisingly not quite what I was expecting. Being a pie-centric restaurant, I was expecting a pie crust for it; there wasn't any. Also okay and nothing awesome. The good part was, unlike most American baked- goods, it wasn't overly sweet.The restaurant itself is really nice and well put together. For what I got, I believe the food is slightly overpriced. And judging by the decor of the restuarant I got the vibe they are trying to market a "gourmet" theme, and thus an upcharge in price.Overall - okay eatery. Was great to check the block. Unfortunately nothing enticing enough to want to come back.
Nikki Smith
The Italian stallion pie was okay. Very heavy on the spice and light on the cheese. It seemed like mostly crust, which some people might like, but I prefer a lighter crust. Nice clean atmosphere. Nice employees, just a little too much going on in such a tiny pie.
A. B.
The worst food. The pie crusts were dry. The vegetables looked frozen. There was no gravy. It was dry. I showed them. They replaced it and it was the same bad food. initially went and looked forward to it. The old owner was the worst. I put up a review and she became argumentative. I saw the article that they were closing. I took another shot. It had gravy but it needed seasoning. Thata unfortunate. If I had known, I would have taken over.
therese hawk
OK so I wanted to try Fayetteville Pie company for dinner. When I went in it didn't even seem like a restaurant. I stood at the counter where there were 3 people with their backs to me and no one even acknowledged me. So I went around to side counter and finally got someone to talk to me. She told me I had to go back to other side of counter. Well I placed order finally for 2 chicken pot pies. Don't know how u could mess up a chicken pot pie that bad. It was nasty. There was no taste . It was dry and no flavor. Banquet pot pies actually taste better and only cost a dollar. I spent $20 on 2 pot pies that were not fit to eat.
CrystAl N.
Wanted to love this place because my daughter and I love pies! The chicken pot pie was super dry and had way too much pepper... my daughter didn't even eat it. The Salisbury steak pie was ok but I overheard them say they ran out of gravy and then took it down from the menu yet still served it to me. The Chips Ahoy pie alone is worth returning though.
Katherine Combs
I tried this place once months ago for their savory offerings, but I will have to come back. Their pies were so tasty. ?. Can't wait to try their sweet pies. Check out their menu online to see what is offered.
Gavin Sibley
Gotta admit. Usually I’ll take like a bite or two then take a pic but I absolutely destroyed both of these before I got the chance. Good stuff and workers were pretty cool tooIg: @gavinjames426
Derek Camp
First time going here. It is a cool idea and a nice space. There were three options on the menu, but they ran out of one by the time I ordered. I think it is a bit overpriced for a single potpie. I was not full afterward, and I was not buying a second for the price. I would say it is definitely worth checking out once, but I won't be going back.
drockcamp
First time going here. It is a cool idea and a nice space. There were three options on the menu, but they ran out of one by the time I ordered. I think it is a bit overpriced for a single potpie. I was not full afterward, and I was not buying a second for the price. I would say it is definitely worth checking out once, but I won't be going back.
I recently had the pleasure of dining at Fayetteville Pie Company, and I have to say that it was an absolute delight. From the moment we walked in, we were struck by the charming atmosphere of the restaurant - it was cozy and inviting, with a rustic, down-home vibe.As we perused the menu, we were struck by the wide variety of options available. The pies came in both sweet and savory varieties, and there was something for every taste and preference. We ended up trying a few different flavors, and they were all absolutely delicious.The pies were perfectly sized - small and cute, with a crispy, buttery crust and a generous filling. The flavors were bold and authentic, and the portions were just right.But perhaps the highlight of the evening was the service. The staff was friendly, attentive, and always on hand to answer any questions we had. They made sure that we had everything we needed and went above and beyond to ensure that our dining experience was enjoyable.In short, Fayetteville Pie Company is a must-visit destination for anyone looking for delicious, authentic pies in a charming, cozy atmosphere. Whether you're in the mood for something sweet or savory, this is the place to be. I highly recommend it!
Ashlin Evelyn
Only getting 3 stars for the concept. Pies need some improving. Maybe making the menu smaller and focusing on most requested items. Maybe my expectations are just high due to being able to eat at Croshaw’s pies in Utah.
Brian Baker
Hidden gem! The pace is easy to find and tastefully trendy on the inside. I particularly enjoyed, “Life is short, eat dessert first” quote on the wall. Expectations for meat pies were set high during my time in New Zealand where pie shops are common. I had the Chili con carne pie which came out quickly and was very good. I followed things up with a tiny dessert pie that had toffee and walnuts that was the perfect size. If I dig some to find an area for improvement, the corn bread was a touch dry. I would highly recommend a visit
Rebecca Morris
Simply delicious, you can taste every ingredient so fresh and perfectly paired. I love the soft but flaky crust. We enjoy the variety of the menu, it’s always a surprise to see what’s new to try each time we visit. Fay Pie Co. Is a Gem ?.
Chase Will PoWer
This place is amazing with great customer service, delicious food on a changing menu and it was clean! I'd easily come here again and recommend it to others. I'll be keeping an eye on the menu for more delicious pies!
This is a cute cozy spot , very clean and lovely! We were greeted on the way in and out. Service was great and fast. The Pies ? were just what we were needing on this rainy day. The texture of the breading was mouth watering and with the combination of the mixture inside was yummy
Heard great things about this place and am always for exploring locally owned eateries. Came in on a Wed evening and found the place empty; my friend and I were the only customers there. Ended up getting a beef pie (don't remember the name) and strawberry shortcake pie.The beef pie was nothing memorable. It had a dense filling, which surprisingly was quite filling. It had some decent flavor but nothing spectacular. My friend and I half suspected these aren't made daily and perhaps frozen ans then thawed; so that could explain it.The strawberry shortcake pie was surprisingly not quite what I was expecting. Being a pie-centric restaurant, I was expecting a pie crust for it; there wasn't any. Also okay and nothing awesome. The good part was, unlike most American baked- goods, it wasn't overly sweet.The restaurant itself is really nice and well put together. For what I got, I believe the food is slightly overpriced. And judging by the decor of the restuarant I got the vibe they are trying to market a "gourmet" theme, and thus an upcharge in price.Overall - okay eatery. Was great to check the block. Unfortunately nothing enticing enough to want to come back.
The Italian stallion pie was okay. Very heavy on the spice and light on the cheese. It seemed like mostly crust, which some people might like, but I prefer a lighter crust. Nice clean atmosphere. Nice employees, just a little too much going on in such a tiny pie.
The worst food. The pie crusts were dry. The vegetables looked frozen. There was no gravy. It was dry. I showed them. They replaced it and it was the same bad food. initially went and looked forward to it. The old owner was the worst. I put up a review and she became argumentative. I saw the article that they were closing. I took another shot. It had gravy but it needed seasoning. Thata unfortunate. If I had known, I would have taken over.
OK so I wanted to try Fayetteville Pie company for dinner. When I went in it didn't even seem like a restaurant. I stood at the counter where there were 3 people with their backs to me and no one even acknowledged me. So I went around to side counter and finally got someone to talk to me. She told me I had to go back to other side of counter. Well I placed order finally for 2 chicken pot pies. Don't know how u could mess up a chicken pot pie that bad. It was nasty. There was no taste . It was dry and no flavor. Banquet pot pies actually taste better and only cost a dollar. I spent $20 on 2 pot pies that were not fit to eat.
Wanted to love this place because my daughter and I love pies! The chicken pot pie was super dry and had way too much pepper... my daughter didn't even eat it. The Salisbury steak pie was ok but I overheard them say they ran out of gravy and then took it down from the menu yet still served it to me. The Chips Ahoy pie alone is worth returning though.
I tried this place once months ago for their savory offerings, but I will have to come back. Their pies were so tasty. ?. Can't wait to try their sweet pies. Check out their menu online to see what is offered.
Gotta admit. Usually I’ll take like a bite or two then take a pic but I absolutely destroyed both of these before I got the chance. Good stuff and workers were pretty cool tooIg: @gavinjames426
First time going here. It is a cool idea and a nice space. There were three options on the menu, but they ran out of one by the time I ordered. I think it is a bit overpriced for a single potpie. I was not full afterward, and I was not buying a second for the price. I would say it is definitely worth checking out once, but I won't be going back.
First time going here. It is a cool idea and a nice space. There were three options on the menu, but they ran out of one by the time I ordered. I think it is a bit overpriced for a single potpie. I was not full afterward, and I was not buying a second for the price. I would say it is definitely worth checking out once, but I won't be going back.
Restaurantji Recommends
I recently had the pleasure of dining at Fayetteville Pie Company, and I have to say that it was an absolute delight. From the moment we walked in, we were struck by the charming atmosphere of the restaurant - it was cozy and inviting, with a rustic, down-home vibe.As we perused the menu, we were struck by the wide variety of options available. The pies came in both sweet and savory varieties, and there was something for every taste and preference. We ended up trying a few different flavors, and they were all absolutely delicious.The pies were perfectly sized - small and cute, with a crispy, buttery crust and a generous filling. The flavors were bold and authentic, and the portions were just right.But perhaps the highlight of the evening was the service. The staff was friendly, attentive, and always on hand to answer any questions we had. They made sure that we had everything we needed and went above and beyond to ensure that our dining experience was enjoyable.In short, Fayetteville Pie Company is a must-visit destination for anyone looking for delicious, authentic pies in a charming, cozy atmosphere. Whether you're in the mood for something sweet or savory, this is the place to be. I highly recommend it!
Only getting 3 stars for the concept. Pies need some improving. Maybe making the menu smaller and focusing on most requested items. Maybe my expectations are just high due to being able to eat at Croshaw’s pies in Utah.
Hidden gem! The pace is easy to find and tastefully trendy on the inside. I particularly enjoyed, “Life is short, eat dessert first” quote on the wall. Expectations for meat pies were set high during my time in New Zealand where pie shops are common. I had the Chili con carne pie which came out quickly and was very good. I followed things up with a tiny dessert pie that had toffee and walnuts that was the perfect size. If I dig some to find an area for improvement, the corn bread was a touch dry. I would highly recommend a visit
Simply delicious, you can taste every ingredient so fresh and perfectly paired. I love the soft but flaky crust. We enjoy the variety of the menu, it’s always a surprise to see what’s new to try each time we visit. Fay Pie Co. Is a Gem ?.
This place is amazing with great customer service, delicious food on a changing menu and it was clean! I'd easily come here again and recommend it to others. I'll be keeping an eye on the menu for more delicious pies!