Papa Johns Pizza

4360 Fayetteville Rd, Lumberton
(910) 618-1111

Recent Reviews

Elizabeth Ann

This is an update to the original Review. I will not be coming back to this location we repeatedly had one issue after another and last night we ordered and today my boyfriend and I both have food poisoning. We are certain it came from here because neither of us ate anything else for the day.Don’t eat here.We continually have problems with this location. Every time I order carry out there’s mysteriously some issue they can’t find the ticket they can’t find the order one of the times I ended up having to double pay online and then again in store because they swore up and down it never came through which I’m not sure that could be true, and the pizza despite it being fresh just really was a sub par pizza from papa John’s it’s expensive to eat out and getting floppy pizza that looks like it came from the take and bake section at Walmart is an issue for me. If I wanted my pizza as thinly done from dough all the way through the sauce the cheese and the toppings I’d go buy a $3 pizza from Walmart. Currently a large stuffed crust is typically 18.99. The only redeeming quality is the employees. They are very polite and many of these issues are beyond their control despite many issues I do think if corporate changed some things this place would be back to 5*

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Brownie, Pepperoni Pizza

Ameer Nasri

Always one of the best pizza I had ever

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Bennett

Love the Garden Fresh without cheese, makes for the perfect vegan pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tasia Smith

Hair was on pizza and the manager did nothing about it!!!

Oliver Laws Jr.

Finally our PJ's seems to be more consistent and accurate with orders! My last 4 orders were perfect, hot, fresh and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Bryan Brown

The shack pizza didn't look like the one in the TV advisement will not buy it. Again because of false

Food: 1

Jennifer Walton

Was not impressed with the Shaqaroni. Was not as large as commercial proclaimed, it was literally a large pizza with shaqs face on the box.

Kirk Chavis

Great pizza crustParking: Good parkingWheelchair accessibility: Yes

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Danny kurdi

Great food and hard working

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Deandre Lageure

One particular young lady was extremely rude towards me, I asked her a simple question about a doordash order she replied ((don't ask me any questions I just work here)) I quit doordash for two weeks after that. It's the young lady with nose rings, I decided to quit instead of response to her rudeness, I noticed she was having a rough night. One star for her five stars for the rest of the crews.

Anthony C.

My friend died because of Papa John's . They literally worked her to death. Upper management did not care even though she made a point to let them know that she was being overworked. Think they care, think they give a fuck, No. FUCK PAPA JOHNS and the DISTRICT MANAGEMENT.

Tom G

Exactly like what you expect. No drive thru though. You either have to walk in or have it delivered.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Brenda Oden (Angel)

Doesn’t deserve a star but had to give a star to give a review! Waited on pizza for long time, boxes falling to the floor, no gloves on hands, no net on beard!! Just nasty!!! No more going back to this Papa John’s!!!! Got my money back and LEFT!!!!

Linda Dance

The worst pizza and also, worst customer service in the store and on the phone, EVER!!! The manager loaded the pizza eith hot spices, which I did not order. The pizza was NOT EDIBLE!!!!! I drove back to the store with the pizza in hand. The manager would not give a credit or give any consideration. She was a total a$$hole! I HAVE BEEN ON HOLD WITH THEIR CUSTOMER SERVICE FOR 20 MINUTES NOW. I will have my credit card charges reversed. $18!!! I WILL NOT EVER ORDER FROM PAPA JOHNS EVER AGAIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS PLACE.

Michelle Bass

The service was awesome. Food was just ok.

Load More