Bake Me Happy

152 New Market, Madison
(336) 949-9199

Recent Reviews

EVE URBINA

Went for the first time to try them out and their sweets were delicious. The girls that were working were very kind and patient...considering I couldn't make up my mind what all I wanted.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jennifer Wright

Amazing bakery!! Ordered a 3 tier Anniversary cake and 36 cupcakes. Was absolutely delicious! Great communication response time. Friendly staff. Will definitely be ordering from here again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Cupcake

Emily Harper

My husband and I got married 9.30.23 and Bake Me Happy baked our cake & cupcakes. It was the BEST and everything we asked for. They have the best desserts with SO many options to choose from. Definitely something for everyone. Such sweet people to work with and made sure everything was exactly like we envisioned. We highly recommend!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sydney Golden

They did our wedding cake and cupcakes! They did exactly what we wanted with the design on the cake and it was DELICIOUS! Everyone raved about how good the cupcakes were at the wedding. They were moist and the frosting was delicious. Flavor selection was also fantastic. They also offer a free cake on your one year anniversary and we’re excited for that :) thank you guys!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Cupcake

Olivia H

Used Bake Me Happy for our wedding and it is now the only bakery we will go to!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jennifer Stanfield

Bake Me Happy prepared cupcakes and a 6 inch cake for our wedding. Everything was delicious! Staff are amazing. Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carrie Maner

Bake Me Happy did an excellent job capturing our vision for our wedding cake for our 9.23.23 wedding. Would definitely recommend their service. Delivery was on time and cake was delicious! Look forward to our complimentary one year anniversary cake!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake

Amanda George

Placed an order for our wedding cupcakes and the testing went very smoothly. The shop was very clean and cozy. Can't wait to see the Halloween designs.Update: These cupcakes and my wedding cake are absolutely everything I was looking for and more. So moist, so beautiful, so perfect! My husband and I are definitely going to be coming back for more!

Alyssa May

Bake Me Happy made my wedding cake and cupcakes, and I couldn't be happier. We did a two tier wedding cake in the white chocolate almond raspberry and cupcakes in red velvet, brown sugar cinnamon, and vanilla buttercream. They all turned out beautifully and tasted amazing. We had the best experience working with Krystle, who captured exactly what we wanted. Their prices were also very fair! Thank you, Bake Me Happy!!

Cindy Voss

Buyer beware! They got my order wrong and wouldn’t make it right The owner wouldn’t refund my money and she wouldn’t remake the cake the way I had requested. She said $15 off was all she was going to do. Such poor customer service. Not to mention the quality of the decorating was so poorly done that I refused to put it out at the baby shower. Needless to say the showerconcept and food display was ruined because of This unscrupulous company.

Cindy V.

Buyer beware! They got my order wrong and wouldn't make it right The owner wouldn't refund my money and she wouldn't remake the cake the way I had requested. She said $15 off was all she was going to do. Such poor customer service. Not to mention the quality of the decorating was so poorly done that I refused to put it out at the baby shower. Needless to say the showerconcept and food display was ruined because of This unscrupulous company.

Heather Craft

Amazing and wonderful! My husband wanted a grooms cake that looked like a bottle of insulin(he is a diabetic). We couldn't find any pictures of it having been done before, so we sent a picture of his vial and they did and perfect cake! The three-tiered wedding cake had custom music he had written on the sides and was also beautifully done! Everyone at the wedding commented on how delicious both cakes and the cupcakes tasted. Great creations! Great price! Great customer service! 100% recommended for all your party needs!

Mallory Godwin

Our wedding cake was beautiful and so good! it went above and beyond my expectations… can’t wait to go back and get a cake for our one year!

Mikki Beall

Bake Me Happy is the best there is! We used them for our wedding at Bella Collina, and everyone RAVED about it. I never heard so many compliments on a wedding cake. Absolutely delicious! One of my friends even asked me for their contact information for any time they’re back in town.

Smokey Mower

We received amazing service and everything here is delicious. They are doing the cake for our wedding and we're extremely awesome and excited to have our business. I wish more places had this kind of service and friendly staff. Update: they did such an amazing job with our wedding cake and cupcakes and amazing service highly recommended to anyone

Load More