I am so glad that I found Sweetheart Bakery to make the desserts for a baby shower this past weekend! I met with Carol who sat with me to figure out exactly what I needed, and she even cautioned me that I was over ordering some items! I ended up with 2 varieties of cupcakes, dipped oreos, cake pops and rice Krispy treats for approximately 30 guests. The colors were perfect and the desserts were amazing! The price was more reasonable than anyone else and the taste and presentation were perfect! Support local, this bakery is top notch!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mehvish Jamal
We used Sweetheart Baking Company for our wedding reception and they were absolutely incredible! Carol was lovely to work with and so helpful in crafting a dessert display that matched our budget and tastes. Everyone LOVED the desserts, the display was BEAUTIFUL, and we appreciate how budget friendly this option was without sacrificing quality.
Emily Leubner
I would definitely recommend this bakery! Carol was friendly and easy to work with. She accommodated our special request and was able to work it into her busy schedule with short notice. We had gender reveal cake pops made and they turned out great and tasted even better! Carol and all of her staff were great to work with.
Lee Ann
They were able to help me with gender reveal cupcakes in record time! They were also delicious!
Alyssa Brown
Amazing! My company used Sweetheart Bakery for a cookie decorating party and It was exactly what we were looking for! They got our large order in last minute and I couldn’t have asked for better service. To Carol and the team, thank you so much from my company to yours!!
Jess P
Delicious crème brûlée latte!!! Dairy alternatives like oat milk. Also enjoyed the gluten free cupcake & buckeye.
Christy Smith
I ordered a cake for my mom and spoke with Carol throughout. She was very helpful and quick to respond. Unfortunately, I was unable to pick up my cake, due to being sick, and gave permission to be taken to the Fire Station or etc. I would, however, immediately look for this baker on any and all future orders.
Courtnie Webb
My daughters cake and cookies were PERFECT!
Courtney Cleveland
We ordered a 14 inch round cake for our little one’s birthday, it was the best cake we’ve ever had! They were so sweet and kind with all my questions and requests! Every one at the party raved about the cake. We will definitely be back for future events!!!
Deanna Wagner
Carol did an amazing job on our wedding cake! She was able to pivot last minute towards a new design due to flower supply and pricing issues. Looked exactly like Pinterest! She was also one of the few bakers in town who could actually make it soy free due to the groom’s food allergy. Very delicious and the consistency made it so good! We got so many compliments at the wedding that people wanted seconds and thirds!
I’ve ordered macarons and cocoa bombs from here MULTIPLE times. My husband is in love with the cookies. The flavors are always delicious and the cookies super soft and chewy. The cocoa bombs were a huge hit at our holiday parties and I look forward to getting them again this year! They’re so tasty and such a fun experience!
Colleen Marchese
I had the hot cocoa bombs with some friends and had to go back for more to give as Christmas gifts. They were awesome to watch and even better to drink!
Katherine D
Carol was such a pleasure to work with! We used her for our rehearsal dinner and wedding cakes! She did an amazing job with these cakes and everyone raved about the flavors.
Daniel K.
It's a stretch to call it a company. On the premises there is no one there. They rely on the Sun Up Cafe staff. The staff is often stretched thin and the poor hostess didn't know what to do. The selection in the display case was sparse and picked over. You have to call the owner. Try to order a 1/4 sheet cake with three days notice, forget it. It is not a bakery. Some side job that is unreliable.
Josh
Amazing!!!! This is officially my new bakery because the cakes and custom cookies are out if this world. Bit if a drive from me but it is worth it for the service and quality. Thank you!!
I am so glad that I found Sweetheart Bakery to make the desserts for a baby shower this past weekend! I met with Carol who sat with me to figure out exactly what I needed, and she even cautioned me that I was over ordering some items! I ended up with 2 varieties of cupcakes, dipped oreos, cake pops and rice Krispy treats for approximately 30 guests. The colors were perfect and the desserts were amazing! The price was more reasonable than anyone else and the taste and presentation were perfect! Support local, this bakery is top notch!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We used Sweetheart Baking Company for our wedding reception and they were absolutely incredible! Carol was lovely to work with and so helpful in crafting a dessert display that matched our budget and tastes. Everyone LOVED the desserts, the display was BEAUTIFUL, and we appreciate how budget friendly this option was without sacrificing quality.
I would definitely recommend this bakery! Carol was friendly and easy to work with. She accommodated our special request and was able to work it into her busy schedule with short notice. We had gender reveal cake pops made and they turned out great and tasted even better! Carol and all of her staff were great to work with.
They were able to help me with gender reveal cupcakes in record time! They were also delicious!
Amazing! My company used Sweetheart Bakery for a cookie decorating party and It was exactly what we were looking for! They got our large order in last minute and I couldn’t have asked for better service. To Carol and the team, thank you so much from my company to yours!!
Delicious crème brûlée latte!!! Dairy alternatives like oat milk. Also enjoyed the gluten free cupcake & buckeye.
I ordered a cake for my mom and spoke with Carol throughout. She was very helpful and quick to respond. Unfortunately, I was unable to pick up my cake, due to being sick, and gave permission to be taken to the Fire Station or etc. I would, however, immediately look for this baker on any and all future orders.
My daughters cake and cookies were PERFECT!
We ordered a 14 inch round cake for our little one’s birthday, it was the best cake we’ve ever had! They were so sweet and kind with all my questions and requests! Every one at the party raved about the cake. We will definitely be back for future events!!!
Carol did an amazing job on our wedding cake! She was able to pivot last minute towards a new design due to flower supply and pricing issues. Looked exactly like Pinterest! She was also one of the few bakers in town who could actually make it soy free due to the groom’s food allergy. Very delicious and the consistency made it so good! We got so many compliments at the wedding that people wanted seconds and thirds!
Restaurantji Recommends
I’ve ordered macarons and cocoa bombs from here MULTIPLE times. My husband is in love with the cookies. The flavors are always delicious and the cookies super soft and chewy. The cocoa bombs were a huge hit at our holiday parties and I look forward to getting them again this year! They’re so tasty and such a fun experience!
I had the hot cocoa bombs with some friends and had to go back for more to give as Christmas gifts. They were awesome to watch and even better to drink!
Carol was such a pleasure to work with! We used her for our rehearsal dinner and wedding cakes! She did an amazing job with these cakes and everyone raved about the flavors.
It's a stretch to call it a company. On the premises there is no one there. They rely on the Sun Up Cafe staff. The staff is often stretched thin and the poor hostess didn't know what to do. The selection in the display case was sparse and picked over. You have to call the owner. Try to order a 1/4 sheet cake with three days notice, forget it. It is not a bakery. Some side job that is unreliable.
Amazing!!!! This is officially my new bakery because the cakes and custom cookies are out if this world. Bit if a drive from me but it is worth it for the service and quality. Thank you!!