Service was slow food was not good at all took so long to get a beer didn’t even bother ordering a second one I would skip it I’ve been 4 times and it’s usually hit or miss and when I say that I mean it’s usually
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Aleasha Snook
The chicken sandwich and the pickle fries were really good. At the staff. Super nice and the view is beautiful.
Leah Fleming
It's a lovely, atmospheric, historic building and is much larger than it appears from the outside. The fried green tomatoes, fish and chips and chicken tenderloins were fantastic. Food was flash fried and not heavily battered. It was perfect!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips
Scott W.
A great place for the family or date night. Excellent food and try the dessert nachos. Also the best fries ever. Check them out it is worth it.
Tami B.
Not a fan of this restaurant at all. They don't have updated menus online, so we weren't quite sure if this was somewhere we wanted to eat. It was pretty limited, but we decided to stay. While everyone was pleasant, the service was slow. I was not at all impressed with the food. On top of that, they charged me an extra percentage for using my credit card.
Lucia P.
The foid was hot and fresh when it came out. This location is beautiful abs has that old feel to it. Service was great and I would go back!
Joanne R.
We love the Mill at Puppy Creek! Great ambience, delicious food, and friendly service!
Janet R.
There was a nice variety of food from which to choose. They would not split the "double hot dog" option down to one hot dog unless you order the kid's dog, but then you couldn't have it "all the way" which was with everything on it, just mustard. The fish and chips were good, especially the sweet potato fries. The nachos were a bit sparse and there wasn't very much meat in the "no-bean chili." The burger was good but the salad was just OK. The mac-n-cheese was pretty good. Our server didn't know if there was meat in the no-bean chili and brought us the nachos without it. She had to take it back. And she forgot our onion soup. Would we come back? Yes. Was it the best? No.
Amy Loves Makeup
Love this little restaurant, always a peaceful environment but disappointed they weren’t open for Valentine’s
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spinach Artichoke Dip
Carol Ege-Rock
Always an enjoyable time with great food and service!
It can not get any better from smiling customer service when u open the door to a table by the window watching the water from the dam outside to a nice menu. Very nice dining
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nancy T.
This is a venue that has changed many times over the years. It is an out of the way very nice location, scenic. The menu is good and the bartenders are great. Just put on your GPS and give it a try. They have Karaoke too on weekends.
Nancy Tetterton
Went in to watch some football and the food was good (wings and a salad) and the drinks reasonably priced. A very nice out of the way venue.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Loaded Tater Tots, The Mill Burger, Beer Flight
Bryan Fisher
Amazing atmosphere and always happily greeted at the door. I always get my usual which is the mil burger with egg
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chris Finley
The location is great for my family to come here. We have been coming here for almost a year. Lately the food has been incredibly underwhelming and the pricing doesn’t fit the food. My wife enjoys the pasta and always gets that. We change appetizers each time. The pretzel used to be good but the last time we came it tasted cold and stale. The bang’n shrimp is overpriced. You get 10 tiny shrimp for $11. Last year it seemed we got a bigger dish of it or larger shrimp. I don’t recommend the shrimp for that price. The pretzel seems to be hit or miss. I ask for the burgers to be medium and they always come out well done. The panini I got was flavorless. The jumbo wings were the best dish here in my opinion. The okra is also always good. Maybe they replaced cooks, but it’s just disappointing going there and the food lacking every time. We love the location so we’ll probably be back since we enjoy the view and simplicity of location. Just not worth the weekly meal anymore. Hopefully it changes back to how it was. It used to be an easy 4-5 star meal/service/atmosphere a year ago.
Service was slow food was not good at all took so long to get a beer didn’t even bother ordering a second one I would skip it I’ve been 4 times and it’s usually hit or miss and when I say that I mean it’s usually
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
The chicken sandwich and the pickle fries were really good. At the staff. Super nice and the view is beautiful.
It's a lovely, atmospheric, historic building and is much larger than it appears from the outside. The fried green tomatoes, fish and chips and chicken tenderloins were fantastic. Food was flash fried and not heavily battered. It was perfect!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips
A great place for the family or date night. Excellent food and try the dessert nachos. Also the best fries ever. Check them out it is worth it.
Not a fan of this restaurant at all. They don't have updated menus online, so we weren't quite sure if this was somewhere we wanted to eat. It was pretty limited, but we decided to stay. While everyone was pleasant, the service was slow. I was not at all impressed with the food. On top of that, they charged me an extra percentage for using my credit card.
The foid was hot and fresh when it came out. This location is beautiful abs has that old feel to it. Service was great and I would go back!
We love the Mill at Puppy Creek! Great ambience, delicious food, and friendly service!
There was a nice variety of food from which to choose. They would not split the "double hot dog" option down to one hot dog unless you order the kid's dog, but then you couldn't have it "all the way" which was with everything on it, just mustard. The fish and chips were good, especially the sweet potato fries. The nachos were a bit sparse and there wasn't very much meat in the "no-bean chili." The burger was good but the salad was just OK. The mac-n-cheese was pretty good. Our server didn't know if there was meat in the no-bean chili and brought us the nachos without it. She had to take it back. And she forgot our onion soup. Would we come back? Yes. Was it the best? No.
Love this little restaurant, always a peaceful environment but disappointed they weren’t open for Valentine’s
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spinach Artichoke Dip
Always an enjoyable time with great food and service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Mill Burger
Restaurantji Recommends
It can not get any better from smiling customer service when u open the door to a table by the window watching the water from the dam outside to a nice menu. Very nice dining
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a venue that has changed many times over the years. It is an out of the way very nice location, scenic. The menu is good and the bartenders are great. Just put on your GPS and give it a try. They have Karaoke too on weekends.
Went in to watch some football and the food was good (wings and a salad) and the drinks reasonably priced. A very nice out of the way venue.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Loaded Tater Tots, The Mill Burger, Beer Flight
Amazing atmosphere and always happily greeted at the door. I always get my usual which is the mil burger with egg
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The location is great for my family to come here. We have been coming here for almost a year. Lately the food has been incredibly underwhelming and the pricing doesn’t fit the food. My wife enjoys the pasta and always gets that. We change appetizers each time. The pretzel used to be good but the last time we came it tasted cold and stale. The bang’n shrimp is overpriced. You get 10 tiny shrimp for $11. Last year it seemed we got a bigger dish of it or larger shrimp. I don’t recommend the shrimp for that price. The pretzel seems to be hit or miss. I ask for the burgers to be medium and they always come out well done. The panini I got was flavorless. The jumbo wings were the best dish here in my opinion. The okra is also always good. Maybe they replaced cooks, but it’s just disappointing going there and the food lacking every time. We love the location so we’ll probably be back since we enjoy the view and simplicity of location. Just not worth the weekly meal anymore. Hopefully it changes back to how it was. It used to be an easy 4-5 star meal/service/atmosphere a year ago.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3