Great cookies, prices, and very friendly staff! Definitely recommend the oatmeal chocolate
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies
Sharon Herrera
I love these cookies! ❤️❤️❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies
Hederlin Mejia
This happened days before Christmas but anyways when I was going pay I had to wait since there was a lady in line before me, I noticed she had punch cards and got some back in return. Mind you it was my first time buying cookies there so I had no idea about them. Then when it was my turn to pay and I was never offered a punch card and I was like okay whatever. Then before I left the next lady after me was paying and they offered her a punch card. I didn’t say anything and just left but that really bothered me. I don’t plan on ever purchasing at this location again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Jordan
This is a great small cookie place. The front area where you gather your yummy cookies is a bit small as to be expected from a cookie business. Prices were right in the range on how inflation is going. Only problem I had was it was hard to stop eating the cookies once I got home. It's difficult to figure out how many cookies you can eat before you don't feel good :) great place highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cookies
Benjamin Cruzan
This place is awesome! WONDERFUL cookies!
Penny North
Omg! Stopped in last minute to get a birthday cookie. She asked me what colors and I said didn't matter then she did it in blue and I was like oh no should've done red. Heading to the Nebraska game. Mable was so sweet and redid it for me. Highly recommend this location ❤️?? no picture of the birthday cookie as I already taped the box up ?
Daydreanne Loftis
Fantastic cookies! And they were able to accommodate our last minute order and still make this beauty for only $27!
Cad
Their decision to put almond extract in their iced sugar cookies makes me not want to eat cookies from here. Seriously, almond extract? Why? Why would anyone want their non-almond cookie tasting like almond?
Jason Bagley
Eileen's Colossal Cookies are delicious. They offer a wide variety of flavors, but the family favorite is their sugar cookie with almond extract icing. Each cookie is moist and flavorful and they are very reasonably priced. You can buy a single cookie to enjoy or they sell them in packs. We highly recommend giving their cookies a try.
Brenda B.
When people hear Eileen's cookies, I see smiles and hear "oooooooo yummy!" They are large, tasty and just how you expect a great cookie to be! Soft, yet crunchy if it's supposed to be. Lots of flavors to choose from. Holiday flavors are always fun and delicious. That have cookie pizzas. That have cookies for every occasion too- sports teams, marching band, congrats, happy birthday and any other occasion you can think of! Frosted, sugar, Choc chip, and my fave Snickerdoodle are the flavors. Great for catering, parties, surprising people at work, or just a nice treat for your family. So go try these cookies and let Yelp know what you think! Enjoy!
Best cookies in Nebraska! May be a bit pricy but the day Olds are well worth it. Still very fresh. Friendly service and they do special orders. Be early on holidays as they get backed up.
Ms P
Phenomenal cookies!!! Far from my home but worth the journey!!
Lori Pruitt-Olson
The cookies were good, but I purchased the day old 3 pack of oatmeal raisin, and 2 cookies of the 3 were oatmeal chocolate chip. I couldn't tell what they were and sadly the packet had no label. The person who helped me couldn't tell either. So, I guess 1 out of 3 isn't too bad. ??♀️
R Moore
Great cookies and service! The large oatmeal monster cookies are our favorite!!
Naithan Beckwith
This place has got to be a front for something because I've had cookies 'from' here sever times in my life and 9 times now I have come here and 9 times they are closed during posted business hours. Other people have shared cookies from them but I have never been able to buy any.
Great cookies, prices, and very friendly staff! Definitely recommend the oatmeal chocolate
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies
I love these cookies! ❤️❤️❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies
This happened days before Christmas but anyways when I was going pay I had to wait since there was a lady in line before me, I noticed she had punch cards and got some back in return. Mind you it was my first time buying cookies there so I had no idea about them. Then when it was my turn to pay and I was never offered a punch card and I was like okay whatever. Then before I left the next lady after me was paying and they offered her a punch card. I didn’t say anything and just left but that really bothered me. I don’t plan on ever purchasing at this location again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
This is a great small cookie place. The front area where you gather your yummy cookies is a bit small as to be expected from a cookie business. Prices were right in the range on how inflation is going. Only problem I had was it was hard to stop eating the cookies once I got home. It's difficult to figure out how many cookies you can eat before you don't feel good :) great place highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cookies
This place is awesome! WONDERFUL cookies!
Omg! Stopped in last minute to get a birthday cookie. She asked me what colors and I said didn't matter then she did it in blue and I was like oh no should've done red. Heading to the Nebraska game. Mable was so sweet and redid it for me. Highly recommend this location ❤️?? no picture of the birthday cookie as I already taped the box up ?
Fantastic cookies! And they were able to accommodate our last minute order and still make this beauty for only $27!
Their decision to put almond extract in their iced sugar cookies makes me not want to eat cookies from here. Seriously, almond extract? Why? Why would anyone want their non-almond cookie tasting like almond?
Eileen's Colossal Cookies are delicious. They offer a wide variety of flavors, but the family favorite is their sugar cookie with almond extract icing. Each cookie is moist and flavorful and they are very reasonably priced. You can buy a single cookie to enjoy or they sell them in packs. We highly recommend giving their cookies a try.
When people hear Eileen's cookies, I see smiles and hear "oooooooo yummy!" They are large, tasty and just how you expect a great cookie to be! Soft, yet crunchy if it's supposed to be. Lots of flavors to choose from. Holiday flavors are always fun and delicious. That have cookie pizzas. That have cookies for every occasion too- sports teams, marching band, congrats, happy birthday and any other occasion you can think of! Frosted, sugar, Choc chip, and my fave Snickerdoodle are the flavors. Great for catering, parties, surprising people at work, or just a nice treat for your family. So go try these cookies and let Yelp know what you think! Enjoy!
Restaurantji Recommends
Best cookies in Nebraska! May be a bit pricy but the day Olds are well worth it. Still very fresh. Friendly service and they do special orders. Be early on holidays as they get backed up.
Phenomenal cookies!!! Far from my home but worth the journey!!
The cookies were good, but I purchased the day old 3 pack of oatmeal raisin, and 2 cookies of the 3 were oatmeal chocolate chip. I couldn't tell what they were and sadly the packet had no label. The person who helped me couldn't tell either. So, I guess 1 out of 3 isn't too bad. ??♀️
Great cookies and service! The large oatmeal monster cookies are our favorite!!
This place has got to be a front for something because I've had cookies 'from' here sever times in my life and 9 times now I have come here and 9 times they are closed during posted business hours. Other people have shared cookies from them but I have never been able to buy any.