Tony's Baltimore Grill

2800 Atlantic Ave, Atlantic City
(609) 345-5766

Recent Reviews

Robert McCann

Being a fan of Pizza I wanted to taste some East Coast Pizza, or “pies” as we were corrected at pick up. The 5 “pies” were good, the flimsy boxes were a challenge to keep everything from getting smashed together .Various toppings on each, sauce was tasty and the crust had a good chew with thin slices. Having not priced out other regional Pizza I don’t know if $19-25 per pie is a fair price for medium pizzas.Having tried pizza from all types of different cities, I’d say it was okay for handmade but smaller than I thought and definitely overpriced. Thanks, it’s a one and done experience for me.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza

Carlos Albert

This place is overrated when it comes to their pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

susan stendel

Epic Jersey throwback lounge with great food, excellent service with authentic people. I felt like I stepped back toThe 70's upon entering. The pizza, meatballs and even the onion rings were superb! Our waitress Amy was a gem and a pleasure to converse with!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Adrienne Windus

We ordered the "one size pizza" to our hotel on suggestion of our bar tender and it was awful. It took 4 phone calls to get our order ordered and when it came the pizza was small(10in?) tough and unchewable it was supposed to be a white pizza please order anything but pizza here

Food: 1

Service: 2

Bobby Deans

Stick with pizza,beer &fries, and it's good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Khary Durant

Food was not good. Almost called John Taffer/Bar Rescue.

Food: 1

Bobby Bryant

I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone I cared about. Rude management. Tainted or expired food. Only saving grace was Pam our waitress.

Food: 1

Sewfly Seamstress

Soooo, my family and I went here after attending a show. The four star service is only for our waitress Pam who was wonderful. Other than that nothing about this place was acceptable. The food was horrible and the 4.2 stars on google is totally inaccurate. We returned a pasta dish that had rancid sausage, chicken that was flavorless, sweet potato fries that were under cooked. When the manager came to speak to us he inquired about why the food was sent back. He left and returned with a condescending attitude explaining that they had made $18,000 over that day and not one thing had been returned. This was irrelevant to our situation and quite frankly doubtful. We paid the bill as not to cause problems for our waitress reiterating to the manager that the food was horrible, they should really check their food before serving. I want to say again Pam was wonderful, she is a 65 year old woman just trying to make ends meet. She deserves respect and a new job. Don’t go to this eatery it is a risk you shouldn’t take. (The only reason I gave one star is because google wouldn't allow me to post without a rating.

Service: 5

Customer Service

Our waitress Pam was a gem. The food was below average and undercooked. When we complained the manager asked “why was all this food coming back” he said he had done $18,000 that day and we were the first to complain. The sausage for the spaghetti was old and rancid. Some sweet potatoe fries were not done and soggy. We paid for the meal to eliminate arguing with the manager and left. Dont waste your money,

Food: 1

HOPE-T ST

Thank you Helen and Danny for your fabulous customer service! It’s my first time visiting the city and I’m glad I was able to sample your great menu! The meatball parm sub was absolutely delicious!!! I wish you much success! You’re a great recommendation and addition to Atlantic City, Cheers! ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ethyl Mobley

Out with friends, late night nosh.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fries, Fried Shrimp

Kristen Baran

We had Tony’s delivered to us last night we’re never disappointed with their food and they send extra parmesean cheese if you ask.

Mike Nowak

You're coming here for the 24 hour aspect of it and the atmosphere of the entire place. Food is fine and well priced, some dishes were better than others. It's definitely a home coming for anyone that loves this style of food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 3

joe celona

The famous Baltimore grill has not changed much since my last visit 40 years ago. Best roast beef sandwich in AC. A must stop if you're interested in experiencing the AC of old for sure. The family has pizza and rigatoni, and the red sausage is surprisingly delicious. There is a bar entrance and dining room entrance, so don't get confused if you're looking for a sit-down dinner. Good food and very nice people make it a memorable experience for sure.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Roast Beef

Anastacia Pallis

Real deal throwback to another era, delicious pizza (extra cheese, onion and fresh garlic my fav.), friendly service, $3 pints, who could want more. If you can’t appreciate what we have here, just go to Applebee’s or Pizza Hut.

Atmosphere: 4

Load More