We love the sandwiches but passed through today 17 September 2023 and the shop is CLOSED.........
Anthony
Red Store was and always will be one of my favorite lunch spots ever. Unfortunately, they seemed to have closed and faded into the most this week with no explanation. There isn’t a place around here that can rival Red Store’s sandwiches. The Cousin Vinny was legendary and even basic menu items like the Turkey sub were phenomenal.It’s a tough time to have a business, and I guess we only have ourselves to blame. Bummer!
Alex Bonnell
There are a good amount of sandwich shops in the area - not going to name competitors. Mikes wins in the most important categories, quality and consistency! You get what you pay for, never disappoints! Thanks!
Erin
Too much meat to topping ratio.. I had one thin piece of lettuce for a pound of meat and mayo so I went to the store so I can put more on just so I could eat it.
Tara P.
The absolute best sandwiches in the area. If you like chicken cutlet sandwiches and balsamic glaze, get the Vinny. You won't be disappointed!
Brittany B.
This place was great!! We ordered two sandwiches to stay and two to go-- all four were incredible!!! There aren't many tables inside so I would say this is a better to-go spot, but the tables they do have are in a little alcove so you're not in the busy area. We did have a wait a little bit for our to-go sandwiches even though we ordered all four at once which was kinda weird, but I guess that just makes them fresher?? They were worth the wait though!
Michael Perdomo
I had a really excellent sandwich here. Everyone working there was super friendly. Would definitely go back again.
Chris Putignano
Big Mikes is the best around. They have one of my favorite fried eggplants and chicken cutlets. You can never go wrong with the Vinny sandwich.
Dan P.
Stopped here before heading home. Staff/owner incredibly friendly. Food was incredible. Let my dog in which was incredibly nice of them which let us eat in the store vs in our car. Can't wait to come back and try more of their food.
Finn Allen
The staff was friendly and pleasant. Definitely putting this on the return again list!
We order here every weekend there sandwiches and subs are amazing deft recommend it!!
Barbara S.
Love this place!The best sandwiches around. Everything I've ever ordered is fantastic! They make a breakfast sandwich with fried bologna, which you certainly don't find on most menus. The roast beef and eggplant sandwiches are exceptional. And he has takeout dinners, usually theme based, which cannot be beat. Who would've thought that take out Chinese could be better here than most Chinese restaurants.
Matt C.
Little red store sticks out on the corner of a tree lines road on the border of rumson and the highlands.While the store is "little" the portions are nothing to play around with , sandwiches stacked high and are truly a loaded perfect bite. Stop right in and have a lunch sandwich or a simple pork roll egg and cheese from the best. Big Mike is a fantastic guy.
Rebecca Tormollan
Oh. My. God. Big Mike is not messing around when it comes to a sandwich. I drove all the way from Baltimore, MD for an infamous “My Cousin Vinny,” and BOY WAS IT WORTH IT. The flavors exploded in my mouth, it was hand crafted with love by Big Mike himself - my taste buds have never experienced anything like it. I may have shed a tear while indulging on this flavor journey. I wish I could eat this sandwich every day. Please open more locations in Maryland and Pennsylvania, Big Mike: the people need your sandwiches. I would give this place a 50,000 star review if I could. My life is complete since eating this sandwich. Thank you, Big Mike. I will be driving back strictly for this sandwich on a very regular basis.
Kim L
I've had this on my list to try for ages and I'm glad we finally made it. There is a reason it is rated well - it is delicious. I had an Italian on a semolina sub roll (pictured) and my husband had salami and swiss. The bread (very important) was fantastic and the meat tasty and quite a bit. Husband said it's probably the best sandwich he's had in ages. The staff was friendly and pleasant. Definitely putting this on the return again list!
We love the sandwiches but passed through today 17 September 2023 and the shop is CLOSED.........
Red Store was and always will be one of my favorite lunch spots ever. Unfortunately, they seemed to have closed and faded into the most this week with no explanation. There isn’t a place around here that can rival Red Store’s sandwiches. The Cousin Vinny was legendary and even basic menu items like the Turkey sub were phenomenal.It’s a tough time to have a business, and I guess we only have ourselves to blame. Bummer!
There are a good amount of sandwich shops in the area - not going to name competitors. Mikes wins in the most important categories, quality and consistency! You get what you pay for, never disappoints! Thanks!
Too much meat to topping ratio.. I had one thin piece of lettuce for a pound of meat and mayo so I went to the store so I can put more on just so I could eat it.
The absolute best sandwiches in the area. If you like chicken cutlet sandwiches and balsamic glaze, get the Vinny. You won't be disappointed!
This place was great!! We ordered two sandwiches to stay and two to go-- all four were incredible!!! There aren't many tables inside so I would say this is a better to-go spot, but the tables they do have are in a little alcove so you're not in the busy area. We did have a wait a little bit for our to-go sandwiches even though we ordered all four at once which was kinda weird, but I guess that just makes them fresher?? They were worth the wait though!
I had a really excellent sandwich here. Everyone working there was super friendly. Would definitely go back again.
Big Mikes is the best around. They have one of my favorite fried eggplants and chicken cutlets. You can never go wrong with the Vinny sandwich.
Stopped here before heading home. Staff/owner incredibly friendly. Food was incredible. Let my dog in which was incredibly nice of them which let us eat in the store vs in our car. Can't wait to come back and try more of their food.
The staff was friendly and pleasant. Definitely putting this on the return again list!
Restaurantji Recommends
We order here every weekend there sandwiches and subs are amazing deft recommend it!!
Love this place!The best sandwiches around. Everything I've ever ordered is fantastic! They make a breakfast sandwich with fried bologna, which you certainly don't find on most menus. The roast beef and eggplant sandwiches are exceptional. And he has takeout dinners, usually theme based, which cannot be beat. Who would've thought that take out Chinese could be better here than most Chinese restaurants.
Little red store sticks out on the corner of a tree lines road on the border of rumson and the highlands.While the store is "little" the portions are nothing to play around with , sandwiches stacked high and are truly a loaded perfect bite. Stop right in and have a lunch sandwich or a simple pork roll egg and cheese from the best. Big Mike is a fantastic guy.
Oh. My. God. Big Mike is not messing around when it comes to a sandwich. I drove all the way from Baltimore, MD for an infamous “My Cousin Vinny,” and BOY WAS IT WORTH IT. The flavors exploded in my mouth, it was hand crafted with love by Big Mike himself - my taste buds have never experienced anything like it. I may have shed a tear while indulging on this flavor journey. I wish I could eat this sandwich every day. Please open more locations in Maryland and Pennsylvania, Big Mike: the people need your sandwiches. I would give this place a 50,000 star review if I could. My life is complete since eating this sandwich. Thank you, Big Mike. I will be driving back strictly for this sandwich on a very regular basis.
I've had this on my list to try for ages and I'm glad we finally made it. There is a reason it is rated well - it is delicious. I had an Italian on a semolina sub roll (pictured) and my husband had salami and swiss. The bread (very important) was fantastic and the meat tasty and quite a bit. Husband said it's probably the best sandwich he's had in ages. The staff was friendly and pleasant. Definitely putting this on the return again list!