They are the only place to serve vegan ice cream pumpkin spice. The wife loved
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brown Sugar Cookie Dough, Blueberry Ice Cream with Peanut Butter Sauce, Cheesecake Peanut Butter
Brendan
The ice cream was delicious. I can’t wait to try all the flavors when I come
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Oreo, Death by Chocolate
robert bennett
Fantastic ice cream. The problem I have with this joint is is that they don’t fill the containers. Last time I was in there I bought 2 quarts of ice cream and it was at least a quarter inch gap from the rim of the container. For the amount of money that they’re charging. They should fill the
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Robert Jantz
I drive 40 miles to get this ice cream, it's that good.
Vincent Y.
Was in the Atlantic highlands area and decided to stop for some ice cream.... so happy we did. The ice cream was to die for. Nicholas's creamy had so many options and you could definitely tell that the quality of the ice cream was top notch. The service was excellent and the location couldn't have been better. They even had some seating available, cute little ice cream shop. Thanks for making this night one to remember.
Marisa M.
Very good ice cream, creamy and delicious. Not too sweat and a lot of unique flavors. My friend got corn, and I got a goat cheese ice cream. The waffle cone looked super home made and was still warm. The one thing is there was a long hair baked into it so I didn't eat a whole part of the cone, other wise everything was great :)They are also cash only. Which is a little odd because they seem pretty legit and have other locations...
Sue P.
Very good ice cream in a very cute town. I'm not from the area so this icecream shop was recommended. The prices are reasonable and there was seating inside and out. I wish we had this on Long Island. I definitely recommended this charming shop
Lexie Benedict
Nicholas Creamery is a great local spot for homemade ice cream! Their flavors are unique and surely to satisfy everyone in the family! We had the Chocolate Caramel Peanut Brownie scoop and the Brown Sugar Cookie Dough scoop. Service was great! Highly recommend!
Good ice cream, not inexpensive, but it is home made. No indoor seating, benches are outside on the sidewalk.
Orlando Navarro
Stopped early Saturday afternoon for a post-bike-ride treat. Service was quick and friendly. I had the cookies and cream shake and it wad very good. I am told that the place gets packed in the evenings so I am glad we went early. Cash only; will visit again.
Melody M.
My sister's, friend and I stumbled upon this cute shop while driving around Atlantic Highlands. So glad we did because their ice cream is delicious! We tried Strawberry shortcake, Jersey Berry, Hudson Cafe coffee crunch and Ooey Goey peanut butter shake.. so yummy! Will definitely come back to try the other flavors. FYI, this shop is CASH ONLY!
Ozzie Lourenco
Pass by, you won't regret it, but your wallet may- but you should go once. Call first and make sure they have corn ice cream. They use Jersey corn, so it's only available for a few months.. I think it starts around late July. If you are lucky they will also have fig.Coconut is ok....corn and fig definitely worth going for!!
arketekchic
Wow! This place is amazing! Miiiight have gone there twice in the 3 days we were in town, it was that good! I grew up in a small town, working in an ice cream shop that made their own ice cream, I've missed it, it's like nothing you've ever tasted before, a million times better than the mass produced brands.
Best ice cream EVER!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best ice cream in momouth county!
Service: 5
They are the only place to serve vegan ice cream pumpkin spice. The wife loved
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brown Sugar Cookie Dough, Blueberry Ice Cream with Peanut Butter Sauce, Cheesecake Peanut Butter
The ice cream was delicious. I can’t wait to try all the flavors when I come
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Oreo, Death by Chocolate
Fantastic ice cream. The problem I have with this joint is is that they don’t fill the containers. Last time I was in there I bought 2 quarts of ice cream and it was at least a quarter inch gap from the rim of the container. For the amount of money that they’re charging. They should fill the
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
I drive 40 miles to get this ice cream, it's that good.
Was in the Atlantic highlands area and decided to stop for some ice cream.... so happy we did. The ice cream was to die for. Nicholas's creamy had so many options and you could definitely tell that the quality of the ice cream was top notch. The service was excellent and the location couldn't have been better. They even had some seating available, cute little ice cream shop. Thanks for making this night one to remember.
Very good ice cream, creamy and delicious. Not too sweat and a lot of unique flavors. My friend got corn, and I got a goat cheese ice cream. The waffle cone looked super home made and was still warm. The one thing is there was a long hair baked into it so I didn't eat a whole part of the cone, other wise everything was great :)They are also cash only. Which is a little odd because they seem pretty legit and have other locations...
Very good ice cream in a very cute town. I'm not from the area so this icecream shop was recommended. The prices are reasonable and there was seating inside and out. I wish we had this on Long Island. I definitely recommended this charming shop
Nicholas Creamery is a great local spot for homemade ice cream! Their flavors are unique and surely to satisfy everyone in the family! We had the Chocolate Caramel Peanut Brownie scoop and the Brown Sugar Cookie Dough scoop. Service was great! Highly recommend!
Restaurantji Recommends
Good ice cream, not inexpensive, but it is home made. No indoor seating, benches are outside on the sidewalk.
Stopped early Saturday afternoon for a post-bike-ride treat. Service was quick and friendly. I had the cookies and cream shake and it wad very good. I am told that the place gets packed in the evenings so I am glad we went early. Cash only; will visit again.
My sister's, friend and I stumbled upon this cute shop while driving around Atlantic Highlands. So glad we did because their ice cream is delicious! We tried Strawberry shortcake, Jersey Berry, Hudson Cafe coffee crunch and Ooey Goey peanut butter shake.. so yummy! Will definitely come back to try the other flavors. FYI, this shop is CASH ONLY!
Pass by, you won't regret it, but your wallet may- but you should go once. Call first and make sure they have corn ice cream. They use Jersey corn, so it's only available for a few months.. I think it starts around late July. If you are lucky they will also have fig.Coconut is ok....corn and fig definitely worth going for!!
Wow! This place is amazing! Miiiight have gone there twice in the 3 days we were in town, it was that good! I grew up in a small town, working in an ice cream shop that made their own ice cream, I've missed it, it's like nothing you've ever tasted before, a million times better than the mass produced brands.