The Atlantic House

67 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands
(848) 300-2408

Recent Reviews

Kate Bagnell

My family and I went here for a drink and to watch a March madness game around 9:30pm on a Saturday night (restaurant closes at 11pm- says their website). The second 10pm hit, we felt so rushed out that it was almost extremely awkward. Staff began putting stools on the bar, shut the music off completely, and even shut off the stair light! I understand if the staff wants to leave, but if there is someone in the bar and your listed closing time says 11pm, you should extend a little bit of hospitality to a family watching a basketball game…… ? ? Needless to say, we will not be returning to Atlantic House in the future…

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

opinion8ter

Staff seems to be limited, but your service does not suffer. They serve generous portions of delicious food! Parking is in the rear or the building in a general lot. No fee for parking. Upstairs provides a scenic view. The restaurant works well for couples, friends and families.

DonLovesGoodFood

Great food in a nice setting. Down the street from Seastreak Ferry. Cute little town. Received excellent service from Jordan! Nice draft beer menu and also offers N/A options. ?

Love the Atlantic House!, the food, and service! My son and I have celiac and have never had an issue with gluten free option's. Our family goes regularly ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

toms

Fairly pleasant, but a bit too dark, the silverware was dirty (we had to ask for replacements). Where we sat was in a walkway leading to upper level (many walk-bys in a tight isle). The waitress was pleasant, but not so knowledgeable on the specials and prices...though the servers and service was quick. We were happy that the food was the best part. It was hot and tasty... Over-all a 3.5

DavidH

Always a great time at Atlantic House. The atmosphere is always lively with Sports on the TVs or spirited conversations all around. The food is always spot on from the Blue Cheese Kettle Chips to the Fish Tacos. The service, always outstanding as Matt always goes above and beyond

Lisa Purdon Coldwell Banker Realty

Great high end pub food. I had the double burger. Really good. Fries were just ok. Fish tacos were

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Trvlr

AH is a great place. We enjoy our meals and the servers are top notch. It is good food in a relaxed environment that makes the experience great every time. Kudos to Kenny, Matt, Brian and the rest of the crew!

KatieG

Food was great! My margarita was okay. We were disappointed our server didn't circle back after we started eating, especially to ask if we wanted anything else to drink. Overall our party of four enjoyed the foos and company, a great time was had by all!

John Ferrone

Good food, occasional live

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Mussels Fra Diavolo, Fish Tacos

Jason Pauxtis

Great spot! Have been many times since they’ve opened. Service is hit or miss, but food, drinks and ambience make up for it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Jamie M

I had the kale and quinoa salad that was on specials menu and I enjoyed it. It was a big portion. The person I was with had the smash burger and the homemade chips and loved it. The ambiance was nice at dinner time and they had a guitarist playing in the background.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

JLCphd

As always, the food and service were top notch and on par with what I've come to love and expect of AH. The cocktails were balanced and delicious. We started with the steak bites appetizer, which I think is the best thing on the menu, hands down. I always consider getting a second serving to have as my meal!!! The spicy fried chicken sandwich and fish and chips entrees were delicious and the fries were crispy and perfect on both. We are looking forward to coming back for another delicious meal with the great folks at Atlantic House soon.

Leah Hall

The service was great! We had a wonderful server who kept us happy and fed the whole time. The food was good! We got calamari and Brussels sprouts as starters and they were great. For my entree, I got the salmon with the butternut squash puree and fresh vegetables. The salmon was delicious, but the vegetables were pretty under-seasoned.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Christian N

Food is amazing. However, they always seem very shortstaffed (with young seating and waiting staff) and rushing you from the table.I wanted to space out my app and dinner order (so I had time to digest). The waitress was pushy with me putting the order in and said they would wait to bring it out. They did not, dinner came out as soon as the app was done and my food sat there and got cold because I was not ready to eat it.Even with that experience, the food is amazing and will keep me coming - back for now.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 1

Load More