Parking: Very best sofr serveBUT, hard to know where to actually pull in off the highway
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Soft Serve
Samantha Szyperski
Service is swift and the ice cream is tasty!
susan allen
Best ice crean around.
Miroslaw Kubicz
Great local ice creamery!!
Slim Summers
I OFTEN FREQUENT Barnegat Bay Ice Cream! In my opinion they have the best ice cream & so many options to choose from! There a small FAMILY OWNED BUSINESS & are some of the KINDEST PEOPLE YOU WILL EVER MEET! Their ice cream is not only DELICIOUS BUT RIDICULOUSLY FAIRLY PRICED❤️? I ALWAYS GET the banana split They also do door dash! If your a local or even just visiting our beautiful ocean side town you have to stop by their shop! Way better then Mrs Walkers ? Barnegat Bay Ice Cream Is the best best place to go from Eagleswood to Toms River!
becky raimondo
The ice cream is delicious ?
Misty Potoczak
Always enjoy the icecream here. Great prices and very friendly staff.
Kathy Konowka
Very nice place for ice cream. Quick service, nice people.
gostartraveler
Reasonable prices, parking in rear, plus seating. Great place for dessert, and hours are conducive to going after dinner, too. Will be back.
Nathan Appese
Good ice cream and excellent service the staff waa friendly. Will probably visit again.
Since mrs walkers, Rich’s had lines wrapped around we decided to explore the bay creature area.This place is filth. We should have know this ice cream was trash when we saw the driveway/parking lot is white stone around a white building while practically had no line while every ice cream store had lines.Their idea of cookie dough is not the standard flavor. It’s a mix of coffee and butter pecan with cookie dough nibbles.The pup cup is an insult, 2 dollars for tiny portion cup that one would get with Au jus sauce in a takeout order.The banana ice cream is flavorless.
Anthony Pacilli
Barnegat Bay Ice Cream is a great place to get a delicious and affordable ice cream treat. If you are in the Barnegat Township area, I highly recommend checking it out.
Kim
Hershey's and Jack & Jill Ice Creams
Tony Notaro
I was intoxicated in public again so I came here and got an ice cream cone.
Parking: Very best sofr serveBUT, hard to know where to actually pull in off the highway
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Soft Serve
Service is swift and the ice cream is tasty!
Best ice crean around.
Great local ice creamery!!
I OFTEN FREQUENT Barnegat Bay Ice Cream! In my opinion they have the best ice cream & so many options to choose from! There a small FAMILY OWNED BUSINESS & are some of the KINDEST PEOPLE YOU WILL EVER MEET! Their ice cream is not only DELICIOUS BUT RIDICULOUSLY FAIRLY PRICED❤️? I ALWAYS GET the banana split They also do door dash! If your a local or even just visiting our beautiful ocean side town you have to stop by their shop! Way better then Mrs Walkers ? Barnegat Bay Ice Cream Is the best best place to go from Eagleswood to Toms River!
The ice cream is delicious ?
Always enjoy the icecream here. Great prices and very friendly staff.
Very nice place for ice cream. Quick service, nice people.
Reasonable prices, parking in rear, plus seating. Great place for dessert, and hours are conducive to going after dinner, too. Will be back.
Good ice cream and excellent service the staff waa friendly. Will probably visit again.
Restaurantji Recommends
Since mrs walkers, Rich’s had lines wrapped around we decided to explore the bay creature area.This place is filth. We should have know this ice cream was trash when we saw the driveway/parking lot is white stone around a white building while practically had no line while every ice cream store had lines.Their idea of cookie dough is not the standard flavor. It’s a mix of coffee and butter pecan with cookie dough nibbles.The pup cup is an insult, 2 dollars for tiny portion cup that one would get with Au jus sauce in a takeout order.The banana ice cream is flavorless.
Barnegat Bay Ice Cream is a great place to get a delicious and affordable ice cream treat. If you are in the Barnegat Township area, I highly recommend checking it out.
Hershey's and Jack & Jill Ice Creams
I was intoxicated in public again so I came here and got an ice cream cone.
Delicious ? ice cream ? ??