Not a pretty place but a typical run of the mill pizzeria. The workers are friendly enough. Parking is normally available. The pizza is pretty cheap based on local averages. Pizza is a hair thick and the cheese has a nice oil content so it often slides off the pizza when separating slices!Parking: Normally open metered spaces out frontWheelchair accessibility: Wheel right in
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheesecake, Cheese Pizza
Brittaney Diaz
Literally the best pizza in Bayonne . It’s so perfect nice crispy cheesy
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesecake, Fried Chicken Center Breast, Buffalo Wings, French Fries, Garlic Bread, Fried Chicken, Seafood Pasta with Marinara Sauce, Cheese Pizza, Grilled Chicken with Caesar Salad, Turkey Wrap Cold
JLane
Menu Food is delicious, prices are good, delivery is quick. Not a fan of the pizza though, always too undercooked/doughy. Otherwise still fantastic food!
Michael McDonnell
Ordered two cold Italian subs, an amazing vodka chicken parm sub, a grilled chicken Ceasar salad and cheesecake. Service over the phone was awesome as I requested some special requests and food came in a timely fashion you can tell it was all made absolutely fresh. Glad to find this place as I'm new to the area will be my new regular spot oh I forgot wr also got a 16 inch pepperoni pizza and the cheese on it was absolutely delicious thanks Mike's we will be back!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kay Ess
Stopped in Pizzeria to get lunch. Immediately notice how over priced they are for some chicken wings. to add injury to insult, when I asked about the price of the wings I was given alot of fluff about how much the shop has to buy the wings for including the oil to fry it in and even went as far as telling me about paying the guys cooking the food. Realistically I don't care about the business overhead I care about what is important to me as a customer which is quality of food, prices and customer service. When I buy a car I'm never given the backstory on how much the fiberglass or plastics cost to make. 8.50 for some chicken wings is ridiculous for a neighborhood shop. Problem number 2, when I was given my food, I was not given any type of bag to hold my two trays. I understand that jersey has a ban on plastic bags but paper bags would have sufficed. Infact, I typically on multiple occasions ordered over the phone (The same item) in which the delivery person clearly provided me with paper bags upon delivery. I kinda got racist vibes from the whole interaction to be honest. From the price of chicken wings (What demographic is typical of ordering wings?) to being unable to get a paper bag to support ther order I placed, I will not be spending my money at this place anymore. I'd rather go somewhere where I feel welcome and am provided quality customer service. Place seems to be all about making money for them but are unable to provide satisfaction to their customers. Good luck if you decide to go here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Samy Sad
Best restaurant of all time! The pizza is just great, cheesy, and crust is the best in the world.6 out of 5, totally reccomend. The gyros and italian food is also great. Also doesnt cost much.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Virginia L.
The pizza is amazing I highly recommend try their food especially the pizza. My family came to visit they all wanted more
Erini Nini
Really good food! I usually order a beef gyro and fries but their cheesesteak is delicious first time to get it and it’s delicious also great for the price
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Darius
Great place and nice staff and great pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steve Choffey
The chicken cutlet here is off the chain…some of the best chicken cutlet I’ve ever had.
A+ all around. Let me start off with the customer service, it’s amazing. I ordered a lunch order for Tuesday pickup but by mistake it came as Monday the team over the phone was so great and helped. The day I picked it up the counter rep was so kind. The food out of this world! The pasta was so delicious! The service makes it even better. Thanks all , my new favorite spot to eat in Bayonne.
Kristen Brown
As we searched around for something to eat, we came across Mike's Pizzeria. First, it's quite humorous that they categorize themselves as an "Italian restaurant" because the food is Italian in name only, and it's far from a restaurant. Anyway, it was the end of the night and we were starving so we figured that we couldn't go wrong with the pizza . We proceeded to buy a pie and sit down to eat. There was someone else sitting down eating so we didnt think anything of it but once our pie was done we were told that they were closing and that we couldn't eat there. I explained that we had just paid for it and there was someone else eating but the guy immediately got an attitude, was very rude and told us that it didn't matter, the "system" wouldn't allow us to eat in there so we had to leave. No idea what that meant but instead of arguing, we just left. It was even more annoying because it was freezing and we ended up having to eat in the car. The pizza was alright but because of the customer service, or lack thereof, I definitely would not give them any more of my business.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Robert Brown
Pretty bad pizza with poor / rude service. Not a great combination.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Susy Saleh
Order wings and fry calamari. The wings taste horrible for sure it was not fresh. The calamari seems to be fry on old oil. Never order from this place again
renatto chavarry
These good reviews have to be family and friends because the food is mediocre and the service is terrible I do not recommend this place to anyone ??
Not a pretty place but a typical run of the mill pizzeria. The workers are friendly enough. Parking is normally available. The pizza is pretty cheap based on local averages. Pizza is a hair thick and the cheese has a nice oil content so it often slides off the pizza when separating slices!Parking: Normally open metered spaces out frontWheelchair accessibility: Wheel right in
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheesecake, Cheese Pizza
Literally the best pizza in Bayonne . It’s so perfect nice crispy cheesy
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesecake, Fried Chicken Center Breast, Buffalo Wings, French Fries, Garlic Bread, Fried Chicken, Seafood Pasta with Marinara Sauce, Cheese Pizza, Grilled Chicken with Caesar Salad, Turkey Wrap Cold
Menu Food is delicious, prices are good, delivery is quick. Not a fan of the pizza though, always too undercooked/doughy. Otherwise still fantastic food!
Ordered two cold Italian subs, an amazing vodka chicken parm sub, a grilled chicken Ceasar salad and cheesecake. Service over the phone was awesome as I requested some special requests and food came in a timely fashion you can tell it was all made absolutely fresh. Glad to find this place as I'm new to the area will be my new regular spot oh I forgot wr also got a 16 inch pepperoni pizza and the cheese on it was absolutely delicious thanks Mike's we will be back!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped in Pizzeria to get lunch. Immediately notice how over priced they are for some chicken wings. to add injury to insult, when I asked about the price of the wings I was given alot of fluff about how much the shop has to buy the wings for including the oil to fry it in and even went as far as telling me about paying the guys cooking the food. Realistically I don't care about the business overhead I care about what is important to me as a customer which is quality of food, prices and customer service. When I buy a car I'm never given the backstory on how much the fiberglass or plastics cost to make. 8.50 for some chicken wings is ridiculous for a neighborhood shop. Problem number 2, when I was given my food, I was not given any type of bag to hold my two trays. I understand that jersey has a ban on plastic bags but paper bags would have sufficed. Infact, I typically on multiple occasions ordered over the phone (The same item) in which the delivery person clearly provided me with paper bags upon delivery. I kinda got racist vibes from the whole interaction to be honest. From the price of chicken wings (What demographic is typical of ordering wings?) to being unable to get a paper bag to support ther order I placed, I will not be spending my money at this place anymore. I'd rather go somewhere where I feel welcome and am provided quality customer service. Place seems to be all about making money for them but are unable to provide satisfaction to their customers. Good luck if you decide to go here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Best restaurant of all time! The pizza is just great, cheesy, and crust is the best in the world.6 out of 5, totally reccomend. The gyros and italian food is also great. Also doesnt cost much.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza is amazing I highly recommend try their food especially the pizza. My family came to visit they all wanted more
Really good food! I usually order a beef gyro and fries but their cheesesteak is delicious first time to get it and it’s delicious also great for the price
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place and nice staff and great pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The chicken cutlet here is off the chain…some of the best chicken cutlet I’ve ever had.
Restaurantji Recommends
A+ all around. Let me start off with the customer service, it’s amazing. I ordered a lunch order for Tuesday pickup but by mistake it came as Monday the team over the phone was so great and helped. The day I picked it up the counter rep was so kind. The food out of this world! The pasta was so delicious! The service makes it even better. Thanks all , my new favorite spot to eat in Bayonne.
As we searched around for something to eat, we came across Mike's Pizzeria. First, it's quite humorous that they categorize themselves as an "Italian restaurant" because the food is Italian in name only, and it's far from a restaurant. Anyway, it was the end of the night and we were starving so we figured that we couldn't go wrong with the pizza . We proceeded to buy a pie and sit down to eat. There was someone else sitting down eating so we didnt think anything of it but once our pie was done we were told that they were closing and that we couldn't eat there. I explained that we had just paid for it and there was someone else eating but the guy immediately got an attitude, was very rude and told us that it didn't matter, the "system" wouldn't allow us to eat in there so we had to leave. No idea what that meant but instead of arguing, we just left. It was even more annoying because it was freezing and we ended up having to eat in the car. The pizza was alright but because of the customer service, or lack thereof, I definitely would not give them any more of my business.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Pretty bad pizza with poor / rude service. Not a great combination.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Order wings and fry calamari. The wings taste horrible for sure it was not fresh. The calamari seems to be fry on old oil. Never order from this place again
These good reviews have to be family and friends because the food is mediocre and the service is terrible I do not recommend this place to anyone ??