This place is adorable and ice cream is great. My family appreciates the allergy friendly options. The staff is always friendly and helpful.
Jackie Cartwright
I visited LBI Labor Day weekend and was really looking forward to this place after hearing they make homemade ice cream and more natural. So I thought it would be a safer choice. Unfortunately, I was mistaken.I asked about their ice cream sandwiches and what kind of cookie was used for the key lime pie sandwich and was told it was chocolate chip. Not what I expected (I thought they would pair it with a graham cracker cookie), but I was ok with it since I like chocolate chip. The girl at the register handed me the ice cream sandwich which was completely wrapped/packaged. It was hard to open and it would have been nice if she offered to cut it open since I was eating it there.I was extremely disappointed with the taste and quality. The cookie tasted like a vanilla sugar cookie, not chocolate chip like the girl at the register told me, and it was raw. It might have been baked about a quarter of the time it should have been. I normally like cookie dough, but this didn’t even taste good. The ice cream didn’t taste good either.The picture of the card is what was packaged with the ice cream sandwich. They didn’t separate the ingredients of the cookie from the ice cream, but either way the ingredients were not good and I was disappointed with a place that seems to promote “home made”, “fresh”, and gives the impression of natural ingredients. It doesn’t seem any different from getting the cheapest ice cream at a big grocery store or gas station.I hope they change.
I209VBjanp
No customer service or rapport. They had no regular cones, so they automatically give you a waffle cone at $1,00 upcharge - without telling you! It's supposed to have soft serve as the sign says, but "we're out of that". Much better places close by - visit them!
Shane Skwarek
What an incredible experience!We booked The WooHoo for our child's 5th birthday and hosted an "Ice Cream Making Party." Megan was engaging, patient, and went over the top to make the party a success!All of the kids got an opportunity to sample different ice cream flavors before finally getting to mix up their own specialty batch. While they waited for their custom creations to freeze up - they played a bunch of fun games.Our guests have all raved about how fun and unique the experience was.I strongly suggest considering The WooHoo for your child's next party!
Rachel L
Fun assortment of flavors. Might be my new favorite ice cream spot on the island
Valerie
The girl working the cash register today wouldn't let me order strawberry ice cream because it's only reserved for those with gluten free or tree nut allergies. I don't have a diagnosed gluten free allergy, but I prefer fruit flavors and gluten free foods because it sits better with me, but was denied that option. I was so embarrassed being denied it that I just walked away from the counter. My friends and I went to Barry's instead where I got my gluten free Dole Pineapple ice cream. I have never heard of an ice cream place denying someone ice cream that they want... I was really excited to try Woo Hoo because our waitress at dinner recommended it, but it is what it is. Maybe I'll go to the doctor's to get a true diagnosis and paperwork before ever coming back.
Christina S.
Really great and flavorful ice cream. There's a cash and credit line. Pay cash and remember to tip the kids well. Great spot for families
Sarah A.
The funniest name for an ice cream joint so of course I had to try! This place looks pretty spacious on the outside, but once inside it's fairly small. The ice cream order wasn't difficult but when asked about sprinkles, they only had rainbow and no chocolate sprinkles. The ice cream good but forgetable but that can be because I took a soft serve swirl cup. I have heard a lot of the hand-dipped ice cream is delicious though.
Donna Reid
Ordered an ice cream cake for a special occasion and it was fantastic! Ice cream is delicious and not too sweet. Decoration was simple and elegant. Far surpasses any ice cream cake ever! Thank you for making our party treat a real success! Donna
Matthew Curley
I came here looking for a quick bite, and their burger and fries were really good. I didn't try the ice cream, but it seemed pretty popular based on the crowds.
The ice cream was crazy good. I'll definitely be back again! Service was pretty fast despite the long line and it being close to closing time.
Dan S.
Super bummed they got rid of the entire ala carte menu and lack any type of variety on their kitchen menu. No more chicken bacon ranch sandwiches, spicy burgers/bowls, fish sandwiches, crab cakes etc... Super generic and plain menu with huge increase in prices. Everything includes fries now and is not worth the price imho. Just go to Holiday Snack Bar for food and cakes/pies and Barry's do me flavor for ice cream.
Sylvia G.
After reading the reviews about changes with the owner, we didn't know what to expect. Something about enclosed porch. We were very happy to find plenty of outdoor seating. As for the ice cream, delicious and house made. The reason for only 4 stars is that I tripped over the chain used to get in line. Not enough space after buying ice cream to go to the table for spoons and napkins.
Melanie Hockenbeck
Not worth the hype! I was curious and excited to try their “jerz” flavor but was disappointed when there was no Taylor ham in it. Didn’t even taste like corn- just tasted like blueberry ice cream. Tasty nonetheless but lacking
eric pey
Pretty good ice cream, had two scoops in a bowl, would return. ?
This place is adorable and ice cream is great. My family appreciates the allergy friendly options. The staff is always friendly and helpful.
I visited LBI Labor Day weekend and was really looking forward to this place after hearing they make homemade ice cream and more natural. So I thought it would be a safer choice. Unfortunately, I was mistaken.I asked about their ice cream sandwiches and what kind of cookie was used for the key lime pie sandwich and was told it was chocolate chip. Not what I expected (I thought they would pair it with a graham cracker cookie), but I was ok with it since I like chocolate chip. The girl at the register handed me the ice cream sandwich which was completely wrapped/packaged. It was hard to open and it would have been nice if she offered to cut it open since I was eating it there.I was extremely disappointed with the taste and quality. The cookie tasted like a vanilla sugar cookie, not chocolate chip like the girl at the register told me, and it was raw. It might have been baked about a quarter of the time it should have been. I normally like cookie dough, but this didn’t even taste good. The ice cream didn’t taste good either.The picture of the card is what was packaged with the ice cream sandwich. They didn’t separate the ingredients of the cookie from the ice cream, but either way the ingredients were not good and I was disappointed with a place that seems to promote “home made”, “fresh”, and gives the impression of natural ingredients. It doesn’t seem any different from getting the cheapest ice cream at a big grocery store or gas station.I hope they change.
No customer service or rapport. They had no regular cones, so they automatically give you a waffle cone at $1,00 upcharge - without telling you! It's supposed to have soft serve as the sign says, but "we're out of that". Much better places close by - visit them!
What an incredible experience!We booked The WooHoo for our child's 5th birthday and hosted an "Ice Cream Making Party." Megan was engaging, patient, and went over the top to make the party a success!All of the kids got an opportunity to sample different ice cream flavors before finally getting to mix up their own specialty batch. While they waited for their custom creations to freeze up - they played a bunch of fun games.Our guests have all raved about how fun and unique the experience was.I strongly suggest considering The WooHoo for your child's next party!
Fun assortment of flavors. Might be my new favorite ice cream spot on the island
The girl working the cash register today wouldn't let me order strawberry ice cream because it's only reserved for those with gluten free or tree nut allergies. I don't have a diagnosed gluten free allergy, but I prefer fruit flavors and gluten free foods because it sits better with me, but was denied that option. I was so embarrassed being denied it that I just walked away from the counter. My friends and I went to Barry's instead where I got my gluten free Dole Pineapple ice cream. I have never heard of an ice cream place denying someone ice cream that they want... I was really excited to try Woo Hoo because our waitress at dinner recommended it, but it is what it is. Maybe I'll go to the doctor's to get a true diagnosis and paperwork before ever coming back.
Really great and flavorful ice cream. There's a cash and credit line. Pay cash and remember to tip the kids well. Great spot for families
The funniest name for an ice cream joint so of course I had to try! This place looks pretty spacious on the outside, but once inside it's fairly small. The ice cream order wasn't difficult but when asked about sprinkles, they only had rainbow and no chocolate sprinkles. The ice cream good but forgetable but that can be because I took a soft serve swirl cup. I have heard a lot of the hand-dipped ice cream is delicious though.
Ordered an ice cream cake for a special occasion and it was fantastic! Ice cream is delicious and not too sweet. Decoration was simple and elegant. Far surpasses any ice cream cake ever! Thank you for making our party treat a real success! Donna
I came here looking for a quick bite, and their burger and fries were really good. I didn't try the ice cream, but it seemed pretty popular based on the crowds.
Restaurantji Recommends
The ice cream was crazy good. I'll definitely be back again! Service was pretty fast despite the long line and it being close to closing time.
Super bummed they got rid of the entire ala carte menu and lack any type of variety on their kitchen menu. No more chicken bacon ranch sandwiches, spicy burgers/bowls, fish sandwiches, crab cakes etc... Super generic and plain menu with huge increase in prices. Everything includes fries now and is not worth the price imho. Just go to Holiday Snack Bar for food and cakes/pies and Barry's do me flavor for ice cream.
After reading the reviews about changes with the owner, we didn't know what to expect. Something about enclosed porch. We were very happy to find plenty of outdoor seating. As for the ice cream, delicious and house made. The reason for only 4 stars is that I tripped over the chain used to get in line. Not enough space after buying ice cream to go to the table for spoons and napkins.
Not worth the hype! I was curious and excited to try their “jerz” flavor but was disappointed when there was no Taylor ham in it. Didn’t even taste like corn- just tasted like blueberry ice cream. Tasty nonetheless but lacking
Pretty good ice cream, had two scoops in a bowl, would return. ?