My partner and I come here to get pizza, soup and a drink for lunch. It’s amazing and always on point. Great prices and the people that work here are welcoming and friendly. Definitely a great local pizza spot to check out if you’re in the area.
NicK
Great Sicilian and vodka chicken pies. Also have a great Vodka Chicken Wrap for lunch. Been ordering from Reyes for years
Ellen Thompson
The food here is fabulous!! The prices are amazing!! Highly recommend!!!
Marion Chappelle
I've always like Reye's. It's always good and the staff is polite.
stephanie lindquist
Excellent thin crust pie, delicious sub bread. Great prices, quick delivery. Good stuff ✌️
Raymond Pilch
This "hole in the wall" makes excellent pizza. Quintessential Jersey place. Small. The owners are friendly and attentive.
maotoole1325
What happened to the nice customer service? They sent the wrong food. My son is allergic to what they sent. They were rude uncaring & blamed me even though I have 3 witnesses and a serious allergy to the food they sent. I will never order from here again.Dietary restrictions: Allergic to the WRONG food they sent
Kenny Coraggio
Everyone has a great smile. Happy and good vides and fastest service and great food.
Christine
Friendly staff; all portions are generous; good prices. Special Italian Cold Sub was tasty, Cheesesteak Sub too, Seafood was fresh with linguine in good, not exceptional, red sauce. No bathroom for customers. Will try pizza soon.
Mike Venere
Best pizza I’ve had, north of wildwood, and I’m fat so I know! Just drove 20 minutes out of my way to have a couple slices for lunch. Any time I’m remotely close, this is where I come.
This place is amazing the staff and owners are extremely nice we came in one night a little late but they still made us a fresh pie they work hard and are truly an amazing business that serves delicious pizza!!!! I order from here regularly
Ernst Roberts
My wife takes me for lunch and the selection and pizza is delicious.
Jeff Gotch
Review of new Management 9/25/22Found Pizza Shop on line and was Extremely surprised. Friendly staff, they definitely care about quality. Ordered a vodka pie on sesame crust with roasted garlic, easily the best pie and best crust option I’ve EVER had, garlic knots were perfect just the right amount of everything and very good red sauce. Chicken fingers were average but very tasty (6/10) but the fries were a solid 8/8.5 out of 10. Overall I can’t recommend trying this place out. Looking forward to next time I go and next pizza combination I try.
Sandy B.
This place used to be amazing but lately their quality has completely gone down. They must swap out their good ingredients to cheaper ingredients at night because the pizza tastes completely different.
Mani
This was by far the WORST.. WORST pizza I have ever tasted. I don’t see how this even aloud to be served. My pizza was so SOGGY and Oily .. the pizza was falling apart literally! Then the pepperoni had a funny taste, almost like its freezer burnt ! I took the pizza back and the women was so apologetic, but I paid $7.50 for two Soggy nasty slices of pizza! This was my first and last time at this place. I used to go to Genos right next door but it looks like they are closed on Sundays, there pizza is delicious.
My partner and I come here to get pizza, soup and a drink for lunch. It’s amazing and always on point. Great prices and the people that work here are welcoming and friendly. Definitely a great local pizza spot to check out if you’re in the area.
Great Sicilian and vodka chicken pies. Also have a great Vodka Chicken Wrap for lunch. Been ordering from Reyes for years
The food here is fabulous!! The prices are amazing!! Highly recommend!!!
I've always like Reye's. It's always good and the staff is polite.
Excellent thin crust pie, delicious sub bread. Great prices, quick delivery. Good stuff ✌️
This "hole in the wall" makes excellent pizza. Quintessential Jersey place. Small. The owners are friendly and attentive.
What happened to the nice customer service? They sent the wrong food. My son is allergic to what they sent. They were rude uncaring & blamed me even though I have 3 witnesses and a serious allergy to the food they sent. I will never order from here again.Dietary restrictions: Allergic to the WRONG food they sent
Everyone has a great smile. Happy and good vides and fastest service and great food.
Friendly staff; all portions are generous; good prices. Special Italian Cold Sub was tasty, Cheesesteak Sub too, Seafood was fresh with linguine in good, not exceptional, red sauce. No bathroom for customers. Will try pizza soon.
Best pizza I’ve had, north of wildwood, and I’m fat so I know! Just drove 20 minutes out of my way to have a couple slices for lunch. Any time I’m remotely close, this is where I come.
Restaurantji Recommends
This place is amazing the staff and owners are extremely nice we came in one night a little late but they still made us a fresh pie they work hard and are truly an amazing business that serves delicious pizza!!!! I order from here regularly
My wife takes me for lunch and the selection and pizza is delicious.
Review of new Management 9/25/22Found Pizza Shop on line and was Extremely surprised. Friendly staff, they definitely care about quality. Ordered a vodka pie on sesame crust with roasted garlic, easily the best pie and best crust option I’ve EVER had, garlic knots were perfect just the right amount of everything and very good red sauce. Chicken fingers were average but very tasty (6/10) but the fries were a solid 8/8.5 out of 10. Overall I can’t recommend trying this place out. Looking forward to next time I go and next pizza combination I try.
This place used to be amazing but lately their quality has completely gone down. They must swap out their good ingredients to cheaper ingredients at night because the pizza tastes completely different.
This was by far the WORST.. WORST pizza I have ever tasted. I don’t see how this even aloud to be served. My pizza was so SOGGY and Oily .. the pizza was falling apart literally! Then the pepperoni had a funny taste, almost like its freezer burnt ! I took the pizza back and the women was so apologetic, but I paid $7.50 for two Soggy nasty slices of pizza! This was my first and last time at this place. I used to go to Genos right next door but it looks like they are closed on Sundays, there pizza is delicious.