The place has gone down over the years. Seems the restaurant (waters edge)the ex husband bought just down the road is way better. The food is not the same as it was before covid. Worth the less than 1/2 a mile trip down the road to have better food. Service is not that great,you are always looking for a server to help,ask a question or even just refill your drink.So sad it is hard to find a place with good food AND good service.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Vee C.
Went for first time on Easter Sunday. My Brother always raved about this place. Getting inside I really like the Decor, very western vibe. Anyway my brothers favorite was always Sausage,Onions and Peppers. So that what I ordered plus a Clams Casino appetizer. Well let me start with everyone else was pleased with their orders, ( at least they weren't complaining, a good face no matter what? Possibly?) I cannot say the same. I don't believe there were any clams in the Clams Casino, at least I couldn't taste any. Very disappointing. Now let's get to my main course. How to you make sausages come out tough? Now I'm not a chef but I do cook for my family, and I've never been able to make sausage and peppers that require a steak knife to cut the sausage. (Usually I cook mine in tomato sauce and find it's often hard to serve they're so tender). Not so here. Now let's get to service. Now the server was nice enough, a very young woman, and we knew they were closing early, but I asked for some more bread and the girl got a deer in the headlight look and disappeared never to be seen again and nobody bothered to even look in our direction again, and the busboy brought us our check. All that being said, I will probably try this place again, but avoid the appetizers and the Sausage and Peppers. And if it's bad again ( and it's not a holiday cluster mess ). I'll just leave, cause if the kids aren't with me, I will make a scene. So maybe I'll revise this if I go back. But I'm willing to give them another shot on a non-holiday. But for now a reluctant two, and not a one because the kids and grandkids were happy.
Domenico Contracting & Excavating Domenico
Super meals, decent price. We drive 45 minutes to get there. They have the world's best veal franchese. We have brought friends and relatives that agree with us.We're customer's for life!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Laura Ward Malizzi
It took 1hr20 to get food and half that time toget a 7&7 cocktail. We were freezing and no one would turn up the heat. We were sitting next to the heaters.The red sauce was unflavored and scant on the pasta. The seafood platter was small portioned.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: House Salad
Anthony R.
My wife and I were pleasantly surprised to eat at Luigi's last night. We were table 12... our server was Christine. I absolutely must say that the service and the food were outrageously good and plentiful ! Keep up the GREAT JOB...!!! The BIG ANT
Dan Kontopodias
Great food, good prices, great service, good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Veal Saltimbocca, Baked Ziti with Sausage
Edwin Salau
Always a pleasure to eat at Luigi’s!One tip ….,.,. ladies always get served first! The oldest down to the youngest! Venue serve the person paying the bill????♀️??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Ed T.
A wonderful unique restaurant. We always take our friends and relatives there when they are visiting us in Allamuchy. The food is great and the waitresses are very friendly. A real feel- good place for every season.
Billy Hine
Sat in the dining room for 35 minutes with family not 1 person came over to the table in that time went to the owner by then it was too late everyone wanted to leave. A shame because I really do like the place don't know if we'll go back.
Service: 1
thecheese1966
Food was very good. Will definitely be returning. Reasonable prices. Sat at the bar. Fast friendly service.
Have been going to Luigi's for several years. It is a great place to dine with the Exception of one of the servers named Candy. Unless you are one of HER regular customers, all she does is complain and will not give her full attention to you. She constantly mocks and talks about other servers including the owner who is normally sitting customers or tending to the bar. Candy really needs to be spoken to as she really shouldn't act like this in front of people dining. She spends way too much time gossiping with her regular clientele-in fact our table was left to wait 20 minutes until we could get our check as all she was doing was talking bad about the women sitting patrons who were a table of two sitting in the rear of the restaurant. On another note, while you think she is taking your order correctly, there have been at least three times where we have had a large party and our orders all three times came out incorrectly and then she tried to put the blame on the table. I now will make sure to avoid her as I will walk out before I let her serve me. She really needs to be spoken to as this is very unprofessional in a business where she is employed and collecting a pay check.
Chris Russell
First time visitor. Had a band there that night. Ordered the prime rib. It was very good. Had drinks, and enjoyed the band.Parking: Not very well light. At night, you could almost very easily drive right by it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Baked Potato
Roy Chavarria
Food was mediocre and tasteless, one of the boneless wings was not fully cooked, pasta was watery and had a Pool of oil and water at the bottom, almost like a soup. What’s the point of large portions if it isn’t good .Waitress was very friendly and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Rita M.
Went to eat there last week with friends. The prices on the menu are not the prices when you get the bill. PLUS if you decide you don't want spaghetti (which is the side dish the meals come with) and ask for Angel hair or Penna, its a dollar up charge. Why? I can't stand when they nickle and dime you to death. Pasta is pasta, there is no difference in price. Its there way of making an extra buck!! Plus it depends on who you get. I never got charged to change the pasta before but was told its always been that way. On the plus side the food was good although we had to wait a while and it wasn't that busy for a Thursday. The waitress forgot a number of things including salad dressing on the side and bread. Might stop going over failure to know how to please the customer.
Ryan Read
Very slow service. Food was ok not great. The place has not been updated in any way and appears dirty and worn down. I like the old look but not when it appears to be run down
The place has gone down over the years. Seems the restaurant (waters edge)the ex husband bought just down the road is way better. The food is not the same as it was before covid. Worth the less than 1/2 a mile trip down the road to have better food. Service is not that great,you are always looking for a server to help,ask a question or even just refill your drink.So sad it is hard to find a place with good food AND good service.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Went for first time on Easter Sunday. My Brother always raved about this place. Getting inside I really like the Decor, very western vibe. Anyway my brothers favorite was always Sausage,Onions and Peppers. So that what I ordered plus a Clams Casino appetizer. Well let me start with everyone else was pleased with their orders, ( at least they weren't complaining, a good face no matter what? Possibly?) I cannot say the same. I don't believe there were any clams in the Clams Casino, at least I couldn't taste any. Very disappointing. Now let's get to my main course. How to you make sausages come out tough? Now I'm not a chef but I do cook for my family, and I've never been able to make sausage and peppers that require a steak knife to cut the sausage. (Usually I cook mine in tomato sauce and find it's often hard to serve they're so tender). Not so here. Now let's get to service. Now the server was nice enough, a very young woman, and we knew they were closing early, but I asked for some more bread and the girl got a deer in the headlight look and disappeared never to be seen again and nobody bothered to even look in our direction again, and the busboy brought us our check. All that being said, I will probably try this place again, but avoid the appetizers and the Sausage and Peppers. And if it's bad again ( and it's not a holiday cluster mess ). I'll just leave, cause if the kids aren't with me, I will make a scene. So maybe I'll revise this if I go back. But I'm willing to give them another shot on a non-holiday. But for now a reluctant two, and not a one because the kids and grandkids were happy.
Super meals, decent price. We drive 45 minutes to get there. They have the world's best veal franchese. We have brought friends and relatives that agree with us.We're customer's for life!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It took 1hr20 to get food and half that time toget a 7&7 cocktail. We were freezing and no one would turn up the heat. We were sitting next to the heaters.The red sauce was unflavored and scant on the pasta. The seafood platter was small portioned.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: House Salad
My wife and I were pleasantly surprised to eat at Luigi's last night. We were table 12... our server was Christine. I absolutely must say that the service and the food were outrageously good and plentiful ! Keep up the GREAT JOB...!!! The BIG ANT
Great food, good prices, great service, good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Veal Saltimbocca, Baked Ziti with Sausage
Always a pleasure to eat at Luigi’s!One tip ….,.,. ladies always get served first! The oldest down to the youngest! Venue serve the person paying the bill????♀️??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
A wonderful unique restaurant. We always take our friends and relatives there when they are visiting us in Allamuchy. The food is great and the waitresses are very friendly. A real feel- good place for every season.
Sat in the dining room for 35 minutes with family not 1 person came over to the table in that time went to the owner by then it was too late everyone wanted to leave. A shame because I really do like the place don't know if we'll go back.
Service: 1
Food was very good. Will definitely be returning. Reasonable prices. Sat at the bar. Fast friendly service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Have been going to Luigi's for several years. It is a great place to dine with the Exception of one of the servers named Candy. Unless you are one of HER regular customers, all she does is complain and will not give her full attention to you. She constantly mocks and talks about other servers including the owner who is normally sitting customers or tending to the bar. Candy really needs to be spoken to as she really shouldn't act like this in front of people dining. She spends way too much time gossiping with her regular clientele-in fact our table was left to wait 20 minutes until we could get our check as all she was doing was talking bad about the women sitting patrons who were a table of two sitting in the rear of the restaurant. On another note, while you think she is taking your order correctly, there have been at least three times where we have had a large party and our orders all three times came out incorrectly and then she tried to put the blame on the table. I now will make sure to avoid her as I will walk out before I let her serve me. She really needs to be spoken to as this is very unprofessional in a business where she is employed and collecting a pay check.
First time visitor. Had a band there that night. Ordered the prime rib. It was very good. Had drinks, and enjoyed the band.Parking: Not very well light. At night, you could almost very easily drive right by it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Baked Potato
Food was mediocre and tasteless, one of the boneless wings was not fully cooked, pasta was watery and had a Pool of oil and water at the bottom, almost like a soup. What’s the point of large portions if it isn’t good .Waitress was very friendly and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Went to eat there last week with friends. The prices on the menu are not the prices when you get the bill. PLUS if you decide you don't want spaghetti (which is the side dish the meals come with) and ask for Angel hair or Penna, its a dollar up charge. Why? I can't stand when they nickle and dime you to death. Pasta is pasta, there is no difference in price. Its there way of making an extra buck!! Plus it depends on who you get. I never got charged to change the pasta before but was told its always been that way. On the plus side the food was good although we had to wait a while and it wasn't that busy for a Thursday. The waitress forgot a number of things including salad dressing on the side and bread. Might stop going over failure to know how to please the customer.
Very slow service. Food was ok not great. The place has not been updated in any way and appears dirty and worn down. I like the old look but not when it appears to be run down