Creations by Sabrina

706 Main St, Boonton
(973) 917-3897

Recent Reviews

Kaitlyn

Sabrina was quick and efficient and nailed it! The cake was absolutely beautiful and she was so thorough to ensure it’s exactly what we were envisioning! Will definitely be ordering again!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

My Mom

In 2023 we had our daughter design our wedding cake. We went to many places and some couldn’t design it the way that it was in the sketchbook. They wanted to take off a tier or change the flowers for fake flowers. When we came to Creations we not only found the perfect flavors but they said they could make it the way it was sketched out. They asked for the colors I wanted and the type of wedding to get a sense of what we wanted. Let me tell you, we wren’t disappointed. It was as if the cake came to life. Cake arrived on time and intact. Thank you Creations for being so reliably amazing.

Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Wedding Cake

Ryan De Paul

I recently visited this charming shop, and the experience was delightful. Creations by Sabrina is a home run when it comes to sweets. From the intricate frosting designs to the unique flavor combination’s, it’s evident that they take pride in their craft. The cupcakes were not only visually appealing but also incredibly delicious. Prices are on par, making it a guilt-free indulgence. The staff is always smiling and extremely friendly, adding to the overall pleasant atmosphere. Creations by Sabrina is a must-visit for anyone seeking a delectable dessert experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hayley Lynch

Creations by Sabrina is an adorable shop with wonderful service and delicious treats. Sabrina is as sweet as her baked goods! Our favorite is the s'mores bar.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: S'Mores Bar

Jennifer Skolsky

They made the smash cake for our daughter. I'm not good with design so I gave them creative freedom with nothing more than the image of decorations I bought on Amazon. They did not disappoint. Hopefully I'll have better pictures later but I'm very happy with how easy they made the process.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

taramarie1992

Sabrina and her staff are amazing! They goAbove and beyond with every order!!!! Everything is always so delicious and beautiful !!!! Thank you! Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

shanice smith

I’ve ordered from here twice for surprise bday events I was throwing and both times I was pleased with my order. Not only did it look how I imagined it, but everyone loved the taste as well! Even though I moved from the area, they will be my number one place for specialty cakes!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Megan Griffin

Ordered a blueberry cheesecake for my husband’s birthday - literally the best cheesecake we’ve ever tasted. The fresh compote was to die for, and the cheesecake itself was so unbelievably velvety and the perfect amount of sweet. The shop is super cute and cozy, too. We’ll definitely be ordering again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Niral Kapadia

We did a wedding cake from here in June and the cake was freaking amazingly delicious!Awesome work Sabrina! Thank you for our celebration memorial!Will come here again soon

Anna Fung

Thank you "Creations by Sabrina!" for making such a beautiful cake for my sister's baby shower. Amazing service, amazing price. Cake was delicious mmm, not overly sweet.

S P

This cake was to die for! All my guests LOVED the red velvet cake. I am so glad I was able to find Creations by Sabrina on such short notice to make my cake for my grad party. I will definitely be coming here for any future cakes I need. Also, all of the staff members are extremely sweet and answered all of my questions with no hesitation. I am very pleased to have come across this amazing place (:

Lisa Rodriguez

The cake for my daughter’s first birthday party was perfection!!! They were so accommodating and squeezed us in last minute when the personal originally doing our cake bailed. Their cake was not only beautiful but so delicious, all our guests loved it. We can’t thank you enough and can’t wait to use you for all our future cakes/bakery needs!!

Bekzod Sharipov

I recently purchased a cake for my daughter's highly anticipated first birthday celebration, and I am truly disheartened to share my disappointment with the overall quality of the cake. As a parent, I had hoped to make this milestone event memorable and enjoyable, but unfortunately, the cake fell far short of expectations.One of the glaring issues with the cake was the excessive use of butter. While it is understandable that butter is a fundamental ingredient in baking, this particular cake took it to an extreme level. The overwhelming taste of butter overpowered everything else, making it challenging to appreciate any other flavors that may have been present. It was an unfortunate oversight that detracted from the celebration rather than enhancing it.Moreover, the cake lacked any distinctive flavor. As we eagerly cut into the cake to celebrate my daughter's first year of life, we were met with a disappointing absence of taste and sweetness. The cake failed to deliver the delightful experience we had hoped for, leaving everyone underwhelmed and puzzled. It was a missed opportunity to create a special memory on this important occasion.Adding to the letdown was the unappealing texture of the cake. It felt dense, heavy, and excessively greasy. The lack of moisture made each bite unenjoyable and difficult to savor. The cake's texture was far from the light, fluffy consistency that is expected from a cake, further accentuating the disappointment of the flavorless experience.As a parent, it saddens me to write such a negative review about the cake that was meant to celebrate my daughter's first year of life. I had envisioned a cake that would bring joy to her and our loved ones, but unfortunately, this cake missed the mark entirely. The excessive use of butter, lack of flavor, and unappetizing texture left us feeling dissatisfied on this important milestone.I strongly urge other parents planning a first birthday celebration to consider alternative options for their cake. It is crucial to find a cake that can deliver on both taste and texture, ensuring a delightful experience for the birthday child and all those in attendance.In conclusion, this cake was a true disappointment for my daughter's first birthday celebration. The excessive use of butter, lack of flavor, and unappealing texture made it a regrettable choice for such a special occasion. I recommend exploring other bakers or establishments that can provide a more enjoyable and satisfying cake experience, allowing for a truly memorable celebration of this significant milestone in your child's life.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

jessica faranda

Sabrina made us the most adorable baby shower fairy garden cake! It came out exactly like the picture i showed her and the cake itself was so delicous! Sabrina got back quickly every time i reached out too! I will be ordering from them again for sure!

E Ort

Beautiful cupcakes enjoyed by all! Everyone was so friendly and easy to work with. The cupcakes turned out even better than I could have imagined!

Load More