So I'm basically a " Benny " born and raised in North Jersey... I've been looking for a pizza spot down here for over a year ... some are mehhh and some have been absolutely horrible. Last night I was craving pizza and decided to give Decaro's a shot AND they offered curbside pickup; you mean I wouldn't have to funnel the little ones in and out just to pick it up? I already had high hopes just bC of that! So as I arrived it was quiet in the parking lot and I didn't have any little ones with me so I decided to run in and see what it looked like inside ... CLEAN!!! and I don't mean like dirty bucket and mop being used so we assume they're clean ... I mean clutter free and no greasy residue on the counters the glass doors didn't have finger prints which is very impressive lol. The worker behind the counter was greeting me before both feet were in the door ... (( I must be dreaming, right? )) So I tell him I'm picking up the curbside order ... he apologized right and left saying he didn't get a notification I was here. When I told him there was nothing to apologize for bC I decided to come in you could see the relief lol So now the real reason you're reading my review ... So I ended up ordering a medium PLAIN pie (( it's the test pie )) - The ride home was about 12min ... LONGEST 12 min ever bC the pizza smelt so good my mouth was watering . - Opening the box,poke the crust ... now is when I'm secretly fighting myself bC I ordered a medium and I have to share - The first bite ... and that's all it took I picked up my phone and had to check their hours bC I was really contemplating about ordering another one right then but being part of the hospitality industry I couldn't be THAT PERSON ordering ANOTHER pie right before they close especially on a Sunday BOTTOM LINE ( for the ones who are just skimming the review ) DECARO'S = AMAZINGGGGG! Staff Cleanliness Pizza
EMILY TROWBRIDGE
Best pizza around!! 10/10 recommend- Emily, Brick NJ
Phoenix X.
Decent pizza, light on the toppings though. Brooklyn square left me dying of thirst. Seems like they use msg in their sauce. Why!? I am sensitive to msg, 5 other people that normally don't complain, said they were so thirsty after the food. Typical of msg laden food. I would go back but wouldn't get their pizza. I would definitely ask them about their seasonings before they cook anything for me. Staff was good.
Chris C.
Always awesome Jersey Pizza Done Right!
peter elz
Hands down my favorite local pizza in the area.
A Guzman
Very good food and prices
Carolyn Ferris
What a long 6 months it’s been....we’ve been searching for a great pizza place since relocating to this side of Brick. We finally settled for just finding an “good” pizza, not a “great” one. But, hallelujah!!!!! we FINALLY found “THEE” best pizza place ever. I even ate the crust for once in my life. Awesome sauce with the pinwheel. Friendly staff too.Yay!!!!
Matthew Drazin
This place is absolutely the best. The staff there is super friendly and always willing to do any thing extra you may ask. Had a great pizza made for my daughters on Valentine’s Day and the wife and I had some amazing chicken pasta entrees. Again I can’t stress how great the food is and the quality of the staff is just as impressive.
Heather L.
Great food and they have a drive thru window which is super convenient! Never had a bad experience.
Lisa C.
Really good food and ordering online for pickup was very easy from their website. We placed a large order for 6 meals and it was ready within 30 minutes. Food was fresh and portions were perfect size.
We just found our new go to pizza place!! We recently bought a house nearby and were cruising around the area checking out things/places in the neighborhood and stopped in to DeCaro's for lunch. The staff was super friendly and the pizza was yummy. Another reason we can't wait to move into the neighborhood! We will most definitely be back.Oh yeah, did I mention they have a DRIVE-THRU Pick up window??What??? Awesome!!!??
Peter Khalil
Great pizza, got the buffalo chicken pizza and the margarita
Judy Kelly
Giving you two stars And haven’t even tried your pizza, BUT walked in today because of word of mouth and youR young guy said “what do you need”. I told him, paid for it ($6.45 for two slices, a little high I thought) he looks at me like what else? I said “can I have a receipt ?” He looked very annoyed, gives me a receipt, went to the back, no thank you, no nothing! I yelled to the back “have a nice day!” Don’t know if I will be back!!
Kristine C
Excellent pizza! Love the drive thru for a slice after a very long day. My sons favorite spot!!
Lisa Duelly
This is the most authentic pizzeria in NJ. The food is fresh, well made and definitely amazing! Love this place!!
So I'm basically a " Benny " born and raised in North Jersey... I've been looking for a pizza spot down here for over a year ... some are mehhh and some have been absolutely horrible. Last night I was craving pizza and decided to give Decaro's a shot AND they offered curbside pickup; you mean I wouldn't have to funnel the little ones in and out just to pick it up? I already had high hopes just bC of that! So as I arrived it was quiet in the parking lot and I didn't have any little ones with me so I decided to run in and see what it looked like inside ... CLEAN!!! and I don't mean like dirty bucket and mop being used so we assume they're clean ... I mean clutter free and no greasy residue on the counters the glass doors didn't have finger prints which is very impressive lol. The worker behind the counter was greeting me before both feet were in the door ... (( I must be dreaming, right? )) So I tell him I'm picking up the curbside order ... he apologized right and left saying he didn't get a notification I was here. When I told him there was nothing to apologize for bC I decided to come in you could see the relief lol So now the real reason you're reading my review ... So I ended up ordering a medium PLAIN pie (( it's the test pie )) - The ride home was about 12min ... LONGEST 12 min ever bC the pizza smelt so good my mouth was watering . - Opening the box,poke the crust ... now is when I'm secretly fighting myself bC I ordered a medium and I have to share - The first bite ... and that's all it took I picked up my phone and had to check their hours bC I was really contemplating about ordering another one right then but being part of the hospitality industry I couldn't be THAT PERSON ordering ANOTHER pie right before they close especially on a Sunday BOTTOM LINE ( for the ones who are just skimming the review ) DECARO'S = AMAZINGGGGG! Staff Cleanliness Pizza
Best pizza around!! 10/10 recommend- Emily, Brick NJ
Decent pizza, light on the toppings though. Brooklyn square left me dying of thirst. Seems like they use msg in their sauce. Why!? I am sensitive to msg, 5 other people that normally don't complain, said they were so thirsty after the food. Typical of msg laden food. I would go back but wouldn't get their pizza. I would definitely ask them about their seasonings before they cook anything for me. Staff was good.
Always awesome Jersey Pizza Done Right!
Hands down my favorite local pizza in the area.
Very good food and prices
What a long 6 months it’s been....we’ve been searching for a great pizza place since relocating to this side of Brick. We finally settled for just finding an “good” pizza, not a “great” one. But, hallelujah!!!!! we FINALLY found “THEE” best pizza place ever. I even ate the crust for once in my life. Awesome sauce with the pinwheel. Friendly staff too.Yay!!!!
This place is absolutely the best. The staff there is super friendly and always willing to do any thing extra you may ask. Had a great pizza made for my daughters on Valentine’s Day and the wife and I had some amazing chicken pasta entrees. Again I can’t stress how great the food is and the quality of the staff is just as impressive.
Great food and they have a drive thru window which is super convenient! Never had a bad experience.
Really good food and ordering online for pickup was very easy from their website. We placed a large order for 6 meals and it was ready within 30 minutes. Food was fresh and portions were perfect size.
Restaurantji Recommends
We just found our new go to pizza place!! We recently bought a house nearby and were cruising around the area checking out things/places in the neighborhood and stopped in to DeCaro's for lunch. The staff was super friendly and the pizza was yummy. Another reason we can't wait to move into the neighborhood! We will most definitely be back.Oh yeah, did I mention they have a DRIVE-THRU Pick up window??What??? Awesome!!!??
Great pizza, got the buffalo chicken pizza and the margarita
Giving you two stars And haven’t even tried your pizza, BUT walked in today because of word of mouth and youR young guy said “what do you need”. I told him, paid for it ($6.45 for two slices, a little high I thought) he looks at me like what else? I said “can I have a receipt ?” He looked very annoyed, gives me a receipt, went to the back, no thank you, no nothing! I yelled to the back “have a nice day!” Don’t know if I will be back!!
Excellent pizza! Love the drive thru for a slice after a very long day. My sons favorite spot!!
This is the most authentic pizzeria in NJ. The food is fresh, well made and definitely amazing! Love this place!!