Pizza's not bad, not the greatest Caldwell has to offer, but the garlic bread is good.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
Elsi Valle
We ordered a vodka sauce pie and we confirmed with the employee over the phone that we did not want a penne vodka pie. When we open the pie it’s exactly what we did not ask for a penne vodka pie.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Sandra Kieliszek
I am absolutely obsessed with their pizza. We found this place from Barstool as it received a high rating and it is now my go to. My husband and I did come here for dinner and the entrees were ok. We probably wouldn’t order anything else other than the pizza from here. The restaurant is very quaint but alittle poorly lit and since it’s only my husband and I, we always get seated in the small, tight tables against the wall that has high traffic.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Famous Thinny Thin Pizza
Anthony Anzaldi
Seriously overpriced! 14 dollars for a small Thinny thin pie…
Rick Sawicki
Quite possibly the best pizza I have ever ate! Thinly thin Zingada…fantasticI might even come back to New Jersey just to eat this pizza again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Leo Marino
Excellent food. By the time you're done with the appetizers no room for
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Famous Thinny Thin Pizza, Caesar Salad, Mozzarella Sticks
Serrubio G
Food was great. Service is always excellent...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Famous Thinny Thin Pizza, Rice Balls, Clams Casino
Trevor Nesse
This cozy restaurant, located right off downtown Caldwell’s Bloomfield Ave strip, serves delicious pizzeria classics. I had the regular thin crust (not the thinny thin) white pie well done, clams, and garlic cheese bread.They also offer mini portions of pasta so that you can try a few things.Zeppoles are incredible!! Bring your adult beverage of choice ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Claudia Caro
Probably the best pizza I've had in Jersey ?
Phil Herzbrun
Our "go to" place to eat with our friend whenever we're down in Jersey.Excellent food, but a bit pricey, although maybe that's normal for NJ?
I brought my family to Angeloni’s and it did not disappoint. My cousins from Milan were here on vacation and joined us. I was eager to try the famous Thinny Thin and it was delicious. In fact, my cousins were blown away by it and said that it would be a major hit in Italy because bar pies like it don’t exist there. The overall experience was wonderful and being a BYOB doesn’t hurt! I can’t wait to go back there again.Parking: Street parking
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Famous Thinny Thin
Christopher Penza
This place is like if depression made pizza. Thinking about this pizza makes me not want to get out of bed. We considered throwing it out but thought it wouldn't be fair to the garbage.We ordered a large plain pie and a large meatball pie. When we opened the plain it wasn't even big enough to come close to filling the box. Looked like most places medium. It was severely overcooked. The cheese had no flavor. The only thing that had flavor was the terrible tomato sauce and the burnt crust. It tasted like Shop Rite frozen pizza but cost 5 times as much.The "large" meatball was smaller than the plain and had no meatball. It was pepperoni, sausage and what I think were croutons. Someone who was suffering through the meal with me suggested that maybe the croutons were square meatball pieces. If they were, then they were the most dry meatballs in existence.This whole "experience" cost over $40.Go literally anywhere else.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Pasquale Nocito
Okay I hate to do this but this is the second time I've gotten pizza here. I just wanted a plain pie. I like my pizza a little bit thick but I get they don't cook it that way here from what it looks like. That's not why I gave a bad review. This pizza was waaaaaay overcooked. All you could pretty much taste is burnt trust. This is the second time this happened. Overall the regular Italian food is good here but I won't get pizza here again. No match for lunello's though If you're going to pay those kind of prices.
Food: 1
Service: 4
George T
Good extremely thin crust pizza. A large bearly feeds 2 adults. Can get very pricey.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Diana Chamberlain
They have a very thin crust pizza that my company raves about, I just wasn't a big fan. I wasn't allowed to order a slice of pizza since we were sitting, I was told the takeout counter only for slices.
Pizza's not bad, not the greatest Caldwell has to offer, but the garlic bread is good.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
We ordered a vodka sauce pie and we confirmed with the employee over the phone that we did not want a penne vodka pie. When we open the pie it’s exactly what we did not ask for a penne vodka pie.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I am absolutely obsessed with their pizza. We found this place from Barstool as it received a high rating and it is now my go to. My husband and I did come here for dinner and the entrees were ok. We probably wouldn’t order anything else other than the pizza from here. The restaurant is very quaint but alittle poorly lit and since it’s only my husband and I, we always get seated in the small, tight tables against the wall that has high traffic.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Famous Thinny Thin Pizza
Seriously overpriced! 14 dollars for a small Thinny thin pie…
Quite possibly the best pizza I have ever ate! Thinly thin Zingada…fantasticI might even come back to New Jersey just to eat this pizza again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent food. By the time you're done with the appetizers no room for
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Famous Thinny Thin Pizza, Caesar Salad, Mozzarella Sticks
Food was great. Service is always excellent...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Famous Thinny Thin Pizza, Rice Balls, Clams Casino
This cozy restaurant, located right off downtown Caldwell’s Bloomfield Ave strip, serves delicious pizzeria classics. I had the regular thin crust (not the thinny thin) white pie well done, clams, and garlic cheese bread.They also offer mini portions of pasta so that you can try a few things.Zeppoles are incredible!! Bring your adult beverage of choice ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Probably the best pizza I've had in Jersey ?
Our "go to" place to eat with our friend whenever we're down in Jersey.Excellent food, but a bit pricey, although maybe that's normal for NJ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I brought my family to Angeloni’s and it did not disappoint. My cousins from Milan were here on vacation and joined us. I was eager to try the famous Thinny Thin and it was delicious. In fact, my cousins were blown away by it and said that it would be a major hit in Italy because bar pies like it don’t exist there. The overall experience was wonderful and being a BYOB doesn’t hurt! I can’t wait to go back there again.Parking: Street parking
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Famous Thinny Thin
This place is like if depression made pizza. Thinking about this pizza makes me not want to get out of bed. We considered throwing it out but thought it wouldn't be fair to the garbage.We ordered a large plain pie and a large meatball pie. When we opened the plain it wasn't even big enough to come close to filling the box. Looked like most places medium. It was severely overcooked. The cheese had no flavor. The only thing that had flavor was the terrible tomato sauce and the burnt crust. It tasted like Shop Rite frozen pizza but cost 5 times as much.The "large" meatball was smaller than the plain and had no meatball. It was pepperoni, sausage and what I think were croutons. Someone who was suffering through the meal with me suggested that maybe the croutons were square meatball pieces. If they were, then they were the most dry meatballs in existence.This whole "experience" cost over $40.Go literally anywhere else.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Okay I hate to do this but this is the second time I've gotten pizza here. I just wanted a plain pie. I like my pizza a little bit thick but I get they don't cook it that way here from what it looks like. That's not why I gave a bad review. This pizza was waaaaaay overcooked. All you could pretty much taste is burnt trust. This is the second time this happened. Overall the regular Italian food is good here but I won't get pizza here again. No match for lunello's though If you're going to pay those kind of prices.
Food: 1
Service: 4
Good extremely thin crust pizza. A large bearly feeds 2 adults. Can get very pricey.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
They have a very thin crust pizza that my company raves about, I just wasn't a big fan. I wasn't allowed to order a slice of pizza since we were sitting, I was told the takeout counter only for slices.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3