I love Guerriero everyone that lives in Caldwell has been there. It's impossible to walk in without knowing someone!! Fan favorite all the way. Plus, anyone that is in to Geocaching there is a cache right in the parking lot.Kid-friendliness: Definitely a place meant for kids (and parents too)!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Marie Rosa
The gelato is my favorite. There’s new specials every few weeks. The staff always go above and beyond to make it a friendly and welcoming experience. The manager was very knowledgeable about the ingredients and flavors of each item. Will definitely be coming back very soon!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato
Hayes Norton
I'd like to thank Mike and Ileana for taking care of my son. He loved his milk shake and really appreciated the great service. Thank you for your kindness on his special day. Can't wait to come back. 5 stars !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maria funiciello
I always love coming back to this establishment they have so many new varieties to try and there all fabulous I love the new ricotta cranberry cheesecake gelato they have a wonderful polite staff good customer service there always. Coming up with new ideas and flavors they are friendly family orientated and overall the best gelato around go give them a try you won't be disappointed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato, Water Bottle
Renzo Matute
I’ve heard employees don’t get their personal tips and are split amongst managers. THIS IS UNFAIR TO ALL THE EMPLOYEES!!! And they are also working under poor working conditions and are not supervised to wear gloves while serving us which is very UNSANITARY!!! AND IVE ALSO SEEN BUGS ON THE ICE
Food: 1
Service: 2
Alex Randall
Best gelato ever tasted? not from around the area so it was nice finding this
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato, Cannoli
Zachary bishop
Great ice cream! Definitely recommend the Mint Oreo!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Precision
Ice cream here is incredible. Staff is very friendly. I’ll be back for ice cream again soon!
Jane L.
We were driving around after seeing a movie and we wanted something sweet. We noticed Guerriero Gelato and we even checked the Yelp reviews to find out feedback. Thank You Yelp. Staff friendly and accommodating. Had so many gelatos to select from. Got a sample of the Chocolate Raspberry- that is definitely a winner. Got the three scoops of gelato in a cup. *Baci Chocolate- If you love Baci Perugina- this is the one to get.*Chocolate Raspberry what a blend. *Pistachio- nice balance. I think I over did it with the chocolates.There were chairs and tables in another area where you can sit and enjoy your treats. There were wall hangings and tons of articles- magazine, news clipping, etc... about Guerriero Gelato. Love the purple color tables and chairs. Even the door to the bathroom is purple. Awesome Ambiance with music playing in the background to enjoy your sweet treats.I am definitely a fan. I was in Aruba last year and had the Gelatissimo Artisanal Gelato. Guerriero Gelato is even better. Will be back again now that we found this place."Rated #5 Place to Eat before you die." Saw this sign on glass of the store.
kadyann palmer
All ima say is they have the best, absolutely BEST banana pudding ice cream. I could swim in it. I love this place
So many flavors! Ice cream, soft serve, gelato. Already enjoyed the hazelnut - to die for, will definitely be back.
Weiting H.
This spot has such delicious gelato! They have so many unique flavors, too. I love that they even have a variety of dairy free options. I got the vegan mango peach verdi, and it's super tasty. It was the perfect amount of sweetness and tangyness.
Hayleigh Proffitt
ABSOLUTELY SOME OF THE BEST PEOPLE TO BE AROUND!!! EVERYONE GO HERE FOR YOUR CAKES!!!! THEY ARE SUPER FRIENDLY, FAST, and they make STUNNING cakes!!!! 10/10 WOULD RECOMMEND!!!!!!
Elizabeth Wells
This family-owned local business takes the cake! When you walk in you feel welcome and appreciated. Watching everyone interact with each other proves that Guerriero's is not just a place to work, they are a family. In addition to selling their amazing treats, they humbly donate meals on a weekly basis to the less fortunate in the community. Guerriero's Gelato deserves a standing ovation! Whether you decide on a beautiful handmade cake or a scoop or two of fresh gelato. I promise, you will not be disappointed!
Daelyn Dalson
Five-Stars for very hardworking, deserving, individuals that put their all into cake decorating! I’m not from NJ, but I watch Joella & Mateo on Tiktok Live all the time & can tell they love their jobs! The whole staff is always great at answering questions & keeping the vibes positive!! Keep doing what you love & don’t let people get you down!! ❤️
I love Guerriero everyone that lives in Caldwell has been there. It's impossible to walk in without knowing someone!! Fan favorite all the way. Plus, anyone that is in to Geocaching there is a cache right in the parking lot.Kid-friendliness: Definitely a place meant for kids (and parents too)!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
The gelato is my favorite. There’s new specials every few weeks. The staff always go above and beyond to make it a friendly and welcoming experience. The manager was very knowledgeable about the ingredients and flavors of each item. Will definitely be coming back very soon!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato
I'd like to thank Mike and Ileana for taking care of my son. He loved his milk shake and really appreciated the great service. Thank you for your kindness on his special day. Can't wait to come back. 5 stars !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I always love coming back to this establishment they have so many new varieties to try and there all fabulous I love the new ricotta cranberry cheesecake gelato they have a wonderful polite staff good customer service there always. Coming up with new ideas and flavors they are friendly family orientated and overall the best gelato around go give them a try you won't be disappointed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato, Water Bottle
I’ve heard employees don’t get their personal tips and are split amongst managers. THIS IS UNFAIR TO ALL THE EMPLOYEES!!! And they are also working under poor working conditions and are not supervised to wear gloves while serving us which is very UNSANITARY!!! AND IVE ALSO SEEN BUGS ON THE ICE
Food: 1
Service: 2
Best gelato ever tasted? not from around the area so it was nice finding this
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato, Cannoli
Great ice cream! Definitely recommend the Mint Oreo!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ice cream here is incredible. Staff is very friendly. I’ll be back for ice cream again soon!
We were driving around after seeing a movie and we wanted something sweet. We noticed Guerriero Gelato and we even checked the Yelp reviews to find out feedback. Thank You Yelp. Staff friendly and accommodating. Had so many gelatos to select from. Got a sample of the Chocolate Raspberry- that is definitely a winner. Got the three scoops of gelato in a cup. *Baci Chocolate- If you love Baci Perugina- this is the one to get.*Chocolate Raspberry what a blend. *Pistachio- nice balance. I think I over did it with the chocolates.There were chairs and tables in another area where you can sit and enjoy your treats. There were wall hangings and tons of articles- magazine, news clipping, etc... about Guerriero Gelato. Love the purple color tables and chairs. Even the door to the bathroom is purple. Awesome Ambiance with music playing in the background to enjoy your sweet treats.I am definitely a fan. I was in Aruba last year and had the Gelatissimo Artisanal Gelato. Guerriero Gelato is even better. Will be back again now that we found this place."Rated #5 Place to Eat before you die." Saw this sign on glass of the store.
All ima say is they have the best, absolutely BEST banana pudding ice cream. I could swim in it. I love this place
Restaurantji Recommends
So many flavors! Ice cream, soft serve, gelato. Already enjoyed the hazelnut - to die for, will definitely be back.
This spot has such delicious gelato! They have so many unique flavors, too. I love that they even have a variety of dairy free options. I got the vegan mango peach verdi, and it's super tasty. It was the perfect amount of sweetness and tangyness.
ABSOLUTELY SOME OF THE BEST PEOPLE TO BE AROUND!!! EVERYONE GO HERE FOR YOUR CAKES!!!! THEY ARE SUPER FRIENDLY, FAST, and they make STUNNING cakes!!!! 10/10 WOULD RECOMMEND!!!!!!
This family-owned local business takes the cake! When you walk in you feel welcome and appreciated. Watching everyone interact with each other proves that Guerriero's is not just a place to work, they are a family. In addition to selling their amazing treats, they humbly donate meals on a weekly basis to the less fortunate in the community. Guerriero's Gelato deserves a standing ovation! Whether you decide on a beautiful handmade cake or a scoop or two of fresh gelato. I promise, you will not be disappointed!
Five-Stars for very hardworking, deserving, individuals that put their all into cake decorating! I’m not from NJ, but I watch Joella & Mateo on Tiktok Live all the time & can tell they love their jobs! The whole staff is always great at answering questions & keeping the vibes positive!! Keep doing what you love & don’t let people get you down!! ❤️