12 Best Italian Restaurants in Caldwell

Tony D's Italian • $
3 Hanford Pl, Caldwell

Customers` Favorites

Drunken Grandma Pizza
Regular Pizza Slice
Buffalo Chicken
Cheese Pizza
Margherita

“Their pizza is terrific, and unusual - square crusts!? My wife had the gluten free which is the best we've tasted, ever. There was a small error in our order which I will put down to the fact that it was the superbowl and the place was hopping. Veggie Pizza was great with the truffle oil touch and the pepperoni was thick cut and flavorful. Will definitely order again.“

4.7 Superb49 Reviews
Divina Ristorante Italian • $$
461 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell

Customers` Favorites

Gnocchi

“Have been here a few times. It's a great little BYOB neighborhood restaurant it does get packed so make a reservation or go early. The food is always fresh. I love a restaurant that serves homemade macaroni and they do the sauce is good. You cannot go wrong with the veal Parmesan. It's thin and crispy the way I like it, I appreciate that it's a BYOB and you can bring your red or white and enjoy a delicious meal. It's small inside. They don't have a lot of tables but they get packed so I can make a reservation. i've been here a few times. It's a great little BYOB neighborhood restaurant it does get packed so make a reservation or go early. The food is always fresh. I love a restaurant that serves homemade macaroni and they do the sauce is good. You cannot go wrong with the veal Parmesan. It's thin and crispy the way I like it, I appreciate that it's a BYOB and you can bring your red or white and enjoy a delicious meal. It's small inside. They don't have a lot of tables but they get packed so I can make a reservation.Definitely give it a try“

4.6 Superb39 Reviews
Pizza & Sandwich Barn Pizza • $
323 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Marsala

“First time here today and I’ve got to say, Food was phenomenal! Fresh ! Pizza was the best I’ve had so far in town. And everyone who worked there was very polite! I’ll definitely be back for sure. 10/10Parking: Plenty of free parking in the back !“

4.7 Superb20 Reviews
Casa Nostra Italian Bistro Italian • $$
455 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Valdostana
Scallop Risotto

“What a delightful gem! From the moment we stepped in, we were embraced by the warm ambiance and greeted like family. The food? Simply divine! Each dish burst with authentic Italian flavors, reminding me of my mother’s cooking. Portions were very generous, but not comically large enough to take away from its quality, ensuring we left satisfied. We’re already planning our next visit. We’re already missing the stuffed zucchini flowers! The attention to detail and the care put into every plate truly shows the passion this family-run restaurant has for their craft. A must-visit for anyone seeking an intimate dining experience.“

4.7 Superb18 Reviews
La Famiglia Ristorante, Pizzeria & Catering Italian • $$
359 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Fingers and French Fries
Square Grandma Pizza large16
Rosa Grande Pepperoni Pizza
Italian Sub Catering
Margherita Pizza
Chicken Marsala
Seabass Special
Homemade Pasta
Nutella Pizza
Chicken Savoy

“Classic Italian restaurant. We came here for a rehearsal dinner. Everything was family style and was excellent. So many classic dishes. Everything was set up as soon as we walked in. Staff took a moment to describe the dishes to us before we ate. They were very attentive and quick. Food was excellent everything was delicious.“

4.3 Superb91 Reviews
Cedar Grill & Pizza Pizza • $
295 Bloomfield Ave Ste 2, Caldwell

Customers` Favorites

Slice of Pizza
Disco Fries

“Moved to town a few weeks ago. All other pizzerias were very expensive and not welcoming. Cedar Grills new owners are extremely kind and have reasonable and affordable pricing. The buffalo chicken is my absolute favorite and best I ever had. 10/10 do recommend them. They have great variety of fat sandwiches and appetizers too!!“

4.3 Superb24 Reviews
Stephanie's Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
283 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell

Customers` Favorites

Juniors New York Style Cheesecake
Veal Chop Milanese
Chicken Parmigiana
Eggplant Rollatini
Pollo Parmigiana
Chocolate Cake
Apple Strudel
Fiocchi

“Let me start with this we were at Fat Fish and saw Stephanie's sign. Not one time but two times we see the sign. We go to Google look at the pics, reviews and menu. Stephanie's is a place go and so freaking glad we did.One it's not a restaurant it's your kitchen and your dining room. Why I say that cause it's cozy yet elegant. You feel at home once you step in that's an awesome feeling and they nailed it.Stephanie's is a BYOB and our amazing server Ms. Michelle was tremendous. Warm bread comes to the table with butter and flavored olive oil. Ms. Stephanie's tells us the appetizer specials I guess. Wife ordered the fresh mozzarella with roasted peppers and tomatoes. Stuffed rice balls with beef and cheese in a vodka sauce also ordered.Ms. Michelle told us the specials which to our surprise we ordered from the special. Maryland blue crab stuffed ravioli in a vodka sauce is what my Wife ordered. I on the other hand ordered flounder stuffed with crab on sautéed spinach in a lemon sauce. Hot AMN that flounder dish had my complete focus. Seasoned perfect the flounder was the lemon sauce with a touch of fresh garlic. Man Chef you put your foot in that meal. Stuffed and happy my Wife and I were. Ms. Michelle awesome server Chef phenomenal Stephanie's is a World Class Italian Restaurant“

4.1 Good61 Reviews
Forte Pizzeria Italian • $$
182 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell

Customers` Favorites

Escarole and Bean Soup
Chicken Margherita
Eggplant Rollatini
Chicken Giambotta
Meat Lovers Pizza
Mussels Marinara
Veal Saltimbocca
Chicken Marsala
Grilled Octopus
Fried Calamari

“This pizzeria is so good everytime me and my family come there . We live in union country and when we want great veal Milanese over arugula, or tripe or even just pizza , we make the trip. The service is great, it’s clean the prices are excellent and the food comes out exactly how we ordered it. No matter the size party we are not waiting and never disappointed! I highly recommend this restaurant!!!!!!!“

4.1 Good88 Reviews
Calandra's Bakery Bakery • $$
234 Bloomfield Ave #5101, Caldwell

Customers` Favorites

Taylor's Ice Cream Sundae Cake
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
Mixed Small Pastries DZ
Panella Bread Medium
Gingerbread House
5 Red Velvet Cake
Pastries Donnoli
Celebration Cake
Pasteis De Nata
Pepperoni Bread

“We do the family meal deal several times a month, oh my goodness do you get your moneys worth! Such a plentiful amount of food and for a good price. You won't regret it. So my faves: rice balls app, penne vodka pasta, Caesar salad and main we have done almost all the options: top are the chicken francese, chicken Marsala and salmon. The wine is an additional $10 so don't sleep on that. And when you pick up get dessert and pretend you cooked the entire thing yourself. Win win“

3.9 Good79 Reviews
Angeloni's Restaurant and Pizzeria Pizza • $$
6 Brookside Ave, Caldwell

Customers` Favorites

Famous Thinny Thin Pizza
Pepperoni Thinny Thin
Mozzarella Sticks
Buffalo Chicken
Sicilian Pizza
Clams Casino
Garlic Bread
Caesar Salad
Everything
Rice Balls

“I am absolutely obsessed with their pizza. We found this place from Barstool as it received a high rating and it is now my go to. My husband and I did come here for dinner and the entrees were ok. We probably wouldn’t order anything else other than the pizza from here. The restaurant is very quaint but alittle poorly lit and since it’s only my husband and I, we always get seated in the small, tight tables against the wall that has high traffic.“

3.8 Good77 Reviews
Calandra's Italian Village Italian • $$
234 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell

Customers` Favorites

Seafood Di Mare
Chicken Marsala
Harvest Salad
Birthday Cake
Chicken Parm
Lobster Tail
Penne Vodka
Cookies
Bakery
Rolls

“Came here after a recommendation from a friend. Food was great. Higher price point for sure. But they’re using quality products. I only wish the bread they used was a bit softer and not so hard. Italian Sandwich was great with the addition of pesto. The bakery was awesome. Got some pastel de nata and some tiramisu. The baked goods were excellent.“

3.9 Good168 Reviews
Il Vecchio Cafe Italian • $$
234 Bloomfield Ave, Caldwell

Customers` Favorites

Antipasto Vegetariano Grilled Vegetable Platter
Pasta with Marinara or Vodka Sauce
Spaghetti and Meatballs

“I had my baby shower here and wow this place is top notch. From the delicious food to the service and the atmosphere, everything was perfect. My party had nothing but good things to say about it. If you have an important event coming up, I highly recommend this place! Side note- their tiramisu is out of this world, best i’ve ever had by a long shot.“

3.6 Good74 Reviews
Loading...

Enjoy Similar Cuisines In Caldwell

map Map