Just stopped by on the way home to grab a quick bite... they have a huge menu which made it difficult for me to order bc I wanted it all lol. I tried the Romeo burger with fries. The burger was cooked just how I asked for it and was delicious. I also got a plain slice and will definitely be ordering my pies from here- a thinner slice, not well done and burnt, lots of cheese.... just how I like it. The burger kinda took a while to come out and the girl at the front gave me complementary zeppoles that's were delicious. Check this place out. Friendly and good food.
Carla J.
We ordered a.pizza within the hours provided by UberEats. We were well within operating hours to order. The delivery would be completed by restaurant staff, however we were still waiting for our food over an hour of the stated delivery time. In trying to receive a refund, UberEats provided no help, and the order could not be cancelled. Upon checking the hours again but through Google, the hours listed were completely different than UberEats. We were charged for food we never received, and not even sure if the restaurant was actually open when we put the order in. Unacceptable.
Mike Kirby
they stole from me true story
Tara M.
Yet again a homerun. Ordered a Jessy burger and an eggplant parm wrap. Just WOW. So glad there is a place that can knock me out of the quartine. Also got a PB shake. Worth every penny
Lin Z.
this is my go to place in town for pizza but the other food is really good as well delivery is always quick and the staff are always super friendly! Love this place
Amanda A.
Decided to try this place tonight to feed the family. We where not disappointed. They have awesome specials for decent prices. Although we didn't get to try the mussels as they ran out we got buffalo wings and they where delicious. And as a complimentary for first time ordering we got free garlic bread. Which was a different twist to garlic bread but surprisingly delicious. Everything was really good. There was not one thing bad to say. With all the pizza places in the area and that have been in the area for the last 11 years, I hope this place stays. It's a great new addition to Carlstadt/East Rutherford area. Give it a try! You won't regret it. Added bonus. Super friendly owner (I think it was the owner that answered the phone and took my order) he was extremely friendly and patient when I was ordering and being that they ran out of mussels he was able to accommodate a switch to the wings but added more than the allotted 6 that originally come in the combo. Lots of praise for this place. We will be ordering again and trying other stuff too!
Marilyn Wolfinbarger
Tried them for the first time over the weekend. Really good pizza! Better than Dominos , Papa Johns. or any other local pizza place in my opinion.
Cassy B.
Romeo's has some pretty good pizza for a quick night of take out. We ordered off Grubhub and the delivery was actually really quick considering it was snowing. We got a sausage and pepper pie with buffalo wings and mussels as appetizers. The pizza was great, soft chewy crust and a great sauce. There was a good amount of toppings too. The cheese was spread out all the way to the end of the crust, that's always a good sign. The buffalo wings were crispy and flavorful. The mussels stole the show though! For a pizzeria, this appetizer was really good. Flavorful and in a delicious white wine sauce with big meaty mussels. Yumm, I even found myself dipping the crust of my pizza in the sauce to savor it all. After looking at the menu, their salads sound really appetizing. Can't wait to give this place another try.
Vito Q.
This pizzeria uses the cheapest Cheese. When you get a slice of Pizza and it's dripping oil you know That they are using the cheapest cheese available. I ordered two slices and threw the second one away. The cheese was so oily that everything slid off the slice. Also way too salty another sign of using cheap cheese. The best cheese is Grande. It does not break oil but not every one uses it
Carol F.
I'm always looking for conveniently located places to enjoy good food. Today, I had to get some laundry done in town, so I noticed that a new place opened (which replaced the previous pizzaria) very close to the laundromat. I stopped into Romeo's for a quick slice, but when I saw the menu.....I opted to add a bowl of minestrone soup. First off, the pizza was delicious - the crust was light and flavorful, the cheese was good quality and the sauce was perfect. The soup was a surprise - many more veggies than I generally find in a bowl of soup at a pizzaria. What I really appreciated was that the owner was very personable and accommodating and got me in and out as fast as I needed to, so I could get back before someone stole my clothes at the laundry!!!! I took a menu, but the hardest part will be deciding what to order next - the menu was well thought out and offers many of my favorite dishes. It's a great place to visit or order from especially when you're trying to select items to satisfy various people, since they offer such a variety of dishes including burgers. I don't eat many burgers, but the one that was served up to another table looked amazing....so if that's your thing, I think you would be satisfied! I always appreciate finding a new pearl in the neighborhood! Unlike the previous establishment that existed at that location, I know this one is going to do very well. Yay!
Just stopped by on the way home to grab a quick bite... they have a huge menu which made it difficult for me to order bc I wanted it all lol. I tried the Romeo burger with fries. The burger was cooked just how I asked for it and was delicious. I also got a plain slice and will definitely be ordering my pies from here- a thinner slice, not well done and burnt, lots of cheese.... just how I like it. The burger kinda took a while to come out and the girl at the front gave me complementary zeppoles that's were delicious. Check this place out. Friendly and good food.
We ordered a.pizza within the hours provided by UberEats. We were well within operating hours to order. The delivery would be completed by restaurant staff, however we were still waiting for our food over an hour of the stated delivery time. In trying to receive a refund, UberEats provided no help, and the order could not be cancelled. Upon checking the hours again but through Google, the hours listed were completely different than UberEats. We were charged for food we never received, and not even sure if the restaurant was actually open when we put the order in. Unacceptable.
they stole from me true story
Yet again a homerun. Ordered a Jessy burger and an eggplant parm wrap. Just WOW. So glad there is a place that can knock me out of the quartine. Also got a PB shake. Worth every penny
this is my go to place in town for pizza but the other food is really good as well delivery is always quick and the staff are always super friendly! Love this place
Decided to try this place tonight to feed the family. We where not disappointed. They have awesome specials for decent prices. Although we didn't get to try the mussels as they ran out we got buffalo wings and they where delicious. And as a complimentary for first time ordering we got free garlic bread. Which was a different twist to garlic bread but surprisingly delicious. Everything was really good. There was not one thing bad to say. With all the pizza places in the area and that have been in the area for the last 11 years, I hope this place stays. It's a great new addition to Carlstadt/East Rutherford area. Give it a try! You won't regret it. Added bonus. Super friendly owner (I think it was the owner that answered the phone and took my order) he was extremely friendly and patient when I was ordering and being that they ran out of mussels he was able to accommodate a switch to the wings but added more than the allotted 6 that originally come in the combo. Lots of praise for this place. We will be ordering again and trying other stuff too!
Tried them for the first time over the weekend. Really good pizza! Better than Dominos , Papa Johns. or any other local pizza place in my opinion.
Romeo's has some pretty good pizza for a quick night of take out. We ordered off Grubhub and the delivery was actually really quick considering it was snowing. We got a sausage and pepper pie with buffalo wings and mussels as appetizers. The pizza was great, soft chewy crust and a great sauce. There was a good amount of toppings too. The cheese was spread out all the way to the end of the crust, that's always a good sign. The buffalo wings were crispy and flavorful. The mussels stole the show though! For a pizzeria, this appetizer was really good. Flavorful and in a delicious white wine sauce with big meaty mussels. Yumm, I even found myself dipping the crust of my pizza in the sauce to savor it all. After looking at the menu, their salads sound really appetizing. Can't wait to give this place another try.
This pizzeria uses the cheapest Cheese. When you get a slice of Pizza and it's dripping oil you know That they are using the cheapest cheese available. I ordered two slices and threw the second one away. The cheese was so oily that everything slid off the slice. Also way too salty another sign of using cheap cheese. The best cheese is Grande. It does not break oil but not every one uses it
I'm always looking for conveniently located places to enjoy good food. Today, I had to get some laundry done in town, so I noticed that a new place opened (which replaced the previous pizzaria) very close to the laundromat. I stopped into Romeo's for a quick slice, but when I saw the menu.....I opted to add a bowl of minestrone soup. First off, the pizza was delicious - the crust was light and flavorful, the cheese was good quality and the sauce was perfect. The soup was a surprise - many more veggies than I generally find in a bowl of soup at a pizzaria. What I really appreciated was that the owner was very personable and accommodating and got me in and out as fast as I needed to, so I could get back before someone stole my clothes at the laundry!!!! I took a menu, but the hardest part will be deciding what to order next - the menu was well thought out and offers many of my favorite dishes. It's a great place to visit or order from especially when you're trying to select items to satisfy various people, since they offer such a variety of dishes including burgers. I don't eat many burgers, but the one that was served up to another table looked amazing....so if that's your thing, I think you would be satisfied! I always appreciate finding a new pearl in the neighborhood! Unlike the previous establishment that existed at that location, I know this one is going to do very well. Yay!
Restaurantji Recommends