This pizza is addicting. A classic joint with a way of cooking pizza that hasn’t changed for as long as I can remember. Great tasting crust with a simple sauce and excellent cheese. Quick in and out and a nice place to sit if you’ve got a minute.
Jimmy
Great pizza pies we bought through a Chatham Hickory Cinema event, 2 doors down. They were perfect and were on time as promised. The event was a party for kids and they were kind enough to cut the large pizzas into 18 slices and provided all the plates and napkins needed. Perfect! Thank you! ??❤️
Ed Masterson
They serve food and I didn't get sick from it. Besides that there was no effort or good taste to anything ordered by the 8 people I work with. I don't think they take pride in serving good food and are content with just making profit on minimal effort. They need to make the menu smaller and hire a someone to change the standard for their food in a positive way to have a chance at being considered even a decent place to eat.
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Michell Centeno
I honestly love this pizza. I’m I love. Not sure why so many negative reviews, most of them about delivery which has nothing to do with the actual goodness and flavor of pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Julia Sands
Ordered 2 large pizzas. Was supposed to take 45 mins. One hour and 45 mins later pizzas arrived. Stone cold. Sparse on sauce and cheese. Will not order again.
Food: 3
Service: 1
Michael N.
Their pizza is great with a nice thin crust. Dinners and hot subs are just as good. I especially like the sausage pizza and parmigiana subs. Staff is friendly and they remember their regular customers.
Michael Wegner
I have always loved their pizza and wish I was eating it now. The reviews should do it justice, I have never had a problem here customer service wise.
Food: 5
Heather H.
Pizza usually arrives with cheese sliding off half the pizza. They're good about sending a replacement when this happens, but kinda wish it didn't happen so much.
Jessica Santiago
If you are black, your money is not welcomed there. Pizza tastes good. But its 2023... Money has no race. Their lost. Learn to handle your hate.
Sam Liveson
Best pizza in NJ. Down-to-earth place. You can usually see someone spinning the dough when you walk in. The taste always exceeds expectations. Quality ingredients (cheese, sauce, veggies, etc.) and good prices.
This is a trustworthy business. I recently left a CVS bag in the shop (had gift cards for Christmas in it) and I called the next day and Hickory Pizza had put it away on the side for me to pick up. It saved my day as the bag could have easily “disappeared.” Thanks to Hickory for that!
Tom S.
This review isn't about food...it's about trust and being a good business. I went to CVS while waiting for my pizza...walked into Hickory when it was ready, paid and left my bag from CVS in the pizza place (had gift card for Christmas). Hickory Pizza put it on the side and when I called the next day said come on down and pick it up. Made my day!
Priscilla P.
We were picking up takeout from one of the restaurants next door and the smell coming from Hickory Pizzeria was just so alluring. We even witnessed another person picking up takeout telling his friend "do you smell how good the pizza is?" We came back the next day to try the pizza and a chicken parm sandwich and both were very good. Note: it's located in the shopping center with the ShopRite, but on the lower level
Joe Grey
The best of the best ! They even have fresh dough you can bring home to experience the goodness of there pizza at home.
Maura L.
Ordered chicken francese and both pieces were very pink inside and without a doubt undercooked. I have to cook it before I can eat it. It also did not have much egg batter. I asked for spaghetti and got linguini (and I called in over the phone so you’d think he would’ve told me they didn’t have regular spaghetti). In the past I got the chicken francese sub and it was great, but I wouldn’t order from here again after this today. It is not good chicken francese
This pizza is addicting. A classic joint with a way of cooking pizza that hasn’t changed for as long as I can remember. Great tasting crust with a simple sauce and excellent cheese. Quick in and out and a nice place to sit if you’ve got a minute.
Great pizza pies we bought through a Chatham Hickory Cinema event, 2 doors down. They were perfect and were on time as promised. The event was a party for kids and they were kind enough to cut the large pizzas into 18 slices and provided all the plates and napkins needed. Perfect! Thank you! ??❤️
They serve food and I didn't get sick from it. Besides that there was no effort or good taste to anything ordered by the 8 people I work with. I don't think they take pride in serving good food and are content with just making profit on minimal effort. They need to make the menu smaller and hire a someone to change the standard for their food in a positive way to have a chance at being considered even a decent place to eat.
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
I honestly love this pizza. I’m I love. Not sure why so many negative reviews, most of them about delivery which has nothing to do with the actual goodness and flavor of pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered 2 large pizzas. Was supposed to take 45 mins. One hour and 45 mins later pizzas arrived. Stone cold. Sparse on sauce and cheese. Will not order again.
Food: 3
Service: 1
Their pizza is great with a nice thin crust. Dinners and hot subs are just as good. I especially like the sausage pizza and parmigiana subs. Staff is friendly and they remember their regular customers.
I have always loved their pizza and wish I was eating it now. The reviews should do it justice, I have never had a problem here customer service wise.
Food: 5
Pizza usually arrives with cheese sliding off half the pizza. They're good about sending a replacement when this happens, but kinda wish it didn't happen so much.
If you are black, your money is not welcomed there. Pizza tastes good. But its 2023... Money has no race. Their lost. Learn to handle your hate.
Best pizza in NJ. Down-to-earth place. You can usually see someone spinning the dough when you walk in. The taste always exceeds expectations. Quality ingredients (cheese, sauce, veggies, etc.) and good prices.
Restaurantji Recommends
This is a trustworthy business. I recently left a CVS bag in the shop (had gift cards for Christmas in it) and I called the next day and Hickory Pizza had put it away on the side for me to pick up. It saved my day as the bag could have easily “disappeared.” Thanks to Hickory for that!
This review isn't about food...it's about trust and being a good business. I went to CVS while waiting for my pizza...walked into Hickory when it was ready, paid and left my bag from CVS in the pizza place (had gift card for Christmas). Hickory Pizza put it on the side and when I called the next day said come on down and pick it up. Made my day!
We were picking up takeout from one of the restaurants next door and the smell coming from Hickory Pizzeria was just so alluring. We even witnessed another person picking up takeout telling his friend "do you smell how good the pizza is?" We came back the next day to try the pizza and a chicken parm sandwich and both were very good. Note: it's located in the shopping center with the ShopRite, but on the lower level
The best of the best ! They even have fresh dough you can bring home to experience the goodness of there pizza at home.
Ordered chicken francese and both pieces were very pink inside and without a doubt undercooked. I have to cook it before I can eat it. It also did not have much egg batter. I asked for spaghetti and got linguini (and I called in over the phone so you’d think he would’ve told me they didn’t have regular spaghetti). In the past I got the chicken francese sub and it was great, but I wouldn’t order from here again after this today. It is not good chicken francese