35 Best Italian Restaurants near Chesilhurst

“Every time I go the food is perfectly cooked and the drinks are spectacular. We had not gone to this place since before COVID and decided to go back in November. it was just as we remembered. In fact, my wife loved it so much, she wanted to come for her birthday which was only a few weeks away in December. When we went back in December, the food was even better then I remembered from November when we were there! I suggest that you take a trip there ASAP!!!“

“The owner reminds me of the best part of going out to eat or grab takeout. She is friendly, chatty, and she aims to please. Ordered a custom sandwich of Italian specialty ingredients for a long drive. It was delicious! It was so good that the drive went better :) Added a drink, a pickle and chips. Lots of good stuff to choose from including prepared goods like chicken salad, which I can attest is very tasty. This spot is clean and organized, full to the brim with goodies. You can pick up grocery items, lunchmeat, bread, even a cannoli. The deli is a better-than-most neighborhood spot with lots to offer. I used to live in the neighborhood. However, if Pine Hill is not nearby, believe me - it's worth a trip. I'm sure you'll agree. The vibe is "Norm!" from Cheers. Even if it's your first time, you'll feel right at home. Yes, I'll be back!“

“Ordered a large pizza through Slice app. Pizza was ready on time and staff were friendly. The best part was the pizza tasted quite good. I am fairly picky when it comes to pizza. The crust had a nice crunch, sauce was tasty and the cheese was quality. Had a slice before I got home because it smelled fantastic.“

“Absolutely unbelievable value, service and ambiance. The food is exceptionally excellent quality and quantity at a very affordable price. Surprising variety of menu selections for everyone. Convenient parking. We cannot wait to return and enjoy the many other entrees on the menu. We plan on sharing our experience with all our friends and neighbors.“

“Let me tell you about this restaurant! I absolutely loved everything about it! When I say the food was on point, I mean on point! I had Chicken Bella Piazza. The sauce was so tasty. This is a BYOB ? location. Had I known I would have had a bottle. I came after work for a retirement party. One coworker was ready! Another co-worker was able to help everyone else out by running around the corner for a few bottles ?. The staff were friendly and offered suggestions. They were accurate saying both dishes were good choices. Some restaurants just say that! We stayed til closing. No pressure to leave. Thank you Siena for a great evening out. I will be back!Parking: You can park in front or on the side.“

“Nicoletta's on Main is a hidden gem worth discovering. The atmosphere is cozy, the staff are super friendly, and the food is simply delicious. They offer a solid selection of Italian classics, all prepared with care and attention to detail. It's the kind of place where you can relax, enjoy an amazing meal, and leave knowing you’ll definitely be back!“

“Just like Nona’s kitchen. The Scipelle soup is incredibly delicious. Perfect. This menu item, which is a very rare find, is a cherished dish here and Fiene’s rendition is the definitive preparation. I’ve been coming here for years to reconnect with my family roots through this soup and the recipe has not changed.You will not find better. Period.A major hit menu item was the Zuppa Inglese. This is not an Italian specialty dessert many may recognize. I’ve NEVER seen this on a menu before and I’m so glad I spotted it on the Holiday menu. Zuppa Inglese is an Italian Trifle dessert, similar in assembly to Tiramisu (which is also a menu star here). I hadn’t had this dish since the family holiday dinners of my youth. Curious how this found its way onto the menu I was informed that a matriarchal family member made this to order in advance at a the request of a good customer. Time consuming to prepare several of these were made and I was the beneficiary of a most wonderful accommodation.The folks at Fiene’s are family. They are “family” to the restaurant and to their guests as everyone here takes an ownership attitude. You will eat well. You will be treated well, like valued family members.I cannot say enough about the satisfaction of a Fiene’s experience.“

“Me and my sister decided to come randomly to try your Alfredo pasta. My sister had the shrimp Alfredo and loved it. I decided to get chicken, shrimp, and crab meat. OH MY GOD when I tell you the crab mean was so big in my Alfredo it was unbelievable. The food was amazing the bread was amazing. This had to be one of the best Alfredo pasta dishes I've had. The pricing was worth every bit.“

“First timer ordered over here. Pizza was top tier. I'm an original New Yorker and take my Pizza seriously. Service was great, everyone was helpful. Fran was delightful and welcoming. Waiters were suggesting wines, owners introduced themselves. It was all so good. I'll be back for sure. Thanks for the great service.“

“I consider myself a pizza connoisseur. It is by far my FAVORITE food so I like to try different places. This is by far the BEST pizza I've had in a REALLY long time. The sauce has the right amount of sweetness and not acidic like most. The cheese is just the right amount, not too much and definitely not too little with that good quality stringy texture to. It has that nice coating of reddish orange grease on top that we all hate to love. The crust is perfectly thin where the slice flops down making a perfect fold. Next time I'll ask them not to cook it as long but that's just a matter of preference.The service was quick and very friendly. It's also the best deal I've seen in ages. $10 for a large pizza! I can't even get a value meal at McDs for that!Rosalies I salute you. Thank you.“

“Great service from our server, Carol. Drinks and food was so delicious. We all chose to have food from dinner menu even though we were dining around 2:00. Everything was served nice and hot. Crab cakes with crab soup, vegetables, potatoes and hot bread right out of the oven. Celebrated a birthday which even had others singing too. Chocolate volcano, blueberry cheesecake, all so very tasty. This is definitely one of my favorites to dine.“

“The all you can eat seafood buffet was a great experience, the lobsters were cooked perfectly as well as the crab legs and Dungeness crabs finger licking good, best seafood buffet by far. I will definitely be going back..A must try...Thank you Stellato.“

“HOLY MOLY WAS THIS JUST THE BEST FOOD IVE DONE DID EAT IN MY LIFE! BREAD-PERFECT, WATER-QUENCHING, FOOD-FULFILLING, SERVICE-ASTRONOMICALGET YOUR ITALIAN CRAVINGS FIXED HERE!(shane was a very good bus boy, handsome too if I do say so myself) ;)“

“Great service and food. I had a special need for a military member who at one time was a resident of Medford Township. The owner was very accommodating and made me a special pizza to bring down to the Military installation on my visit today. Besides great food, the service is amazing.“

“Wonderful is an understatement. I had my husband‘s 70th birthday celebration here yesterday we had over 50 people there was more than enough room. The atmosphere was perfect for our party .today alone I’ve received five phone calls from guest at the party to complement me on my choice of restaurant, they loved the food they love the atmosphere. They love that it was easy assessable since a lot of people were coming from Philadelphia .more than not yesterday everybody expressed how they will be back. I thank you Vinnie and crew. These guys did a wonderful job. Everyone everyone was pleased, but most of all my husband , he had the veal Parm , his favorite dish !our guest also had had fettuccine Alfredo with chicken, shrimp scampi and also chicken marsala. Everything was wonderful the staff was so attentive. This is a BYOB so they had us all set up for everything we needed it. Thanks Vinnie see you soon❤️“

“My neighborhood pizza shop was recently sold, no longer a fan of their food (sorry).Anywho, I was recommended to try Capri Pizza andYup, def my new #1 go to Pizza Shop!!! I have been there a few times now and NEVER disappointed.Food is sooooo fresh and tasty. You can tell they use the richest ingredients. #Drooling#Yummz!“

“It was our 1st time there today and the woman who owns it was so friendly. We got vegetable soup, chicken cutlets, eggplant parmesan and a side of string beans and everything was delicious. All the food was homemade and you could taste the care she took in making everything. We can't wait for our next visit!“

“The food was very good even though it took a while to come out, but that meant it was cooked with extra care. The wait staff was very kind and attentive. In terms of atmosphere, it is very small, but I think they keep it that way for the local crowd.“

“A medford/medford lakes classic. Riv never fails. Family is straight from Italy. A timeless New Jersey cheese pizza done right. My brother loves the Buffalo chicken also! But the real magic is the chicken parm... (if you ask they will give you home made pasta )“

“Outstanding make you wanna smack your mama pizza! Only negative is that I feel like a jackass for only having just *now tried them out. I had to shave one star for that. Kidding aside, when such fantastic pizza is prepared and served hot from the hands of these kind, welcoming and fine, true gentlemen - you get a little extra something special in the flavor of food for the heart and soul. Gentlemen, as they are, they don’t even charge extra for it.“

“Marissa was so kind when I told her about my daughters birthday party at Color Me Mine. She was so accomadating and the pizza came out hot, delicious and on time. You can't beat that. We had the white, tomatoe pie, pepperoni, and cheese.“

“We moved from the area about 6 years back and these awesome owners remembered us! What a great family restaurant - quality delicious food served hot and with a smile! We'll be taking the drive again to grab some more pizza, lasagna and wraps!“

“Have been in the area for quite a while and I went strait to Mary's Cafe. Marion always recognizes faces and instantly she says "haven't see you in a long time". We chatted at the counter while I enjoyed my cream chipped beef. Can't wait until the Jersey tomatoes are ripe. They make tv best burgers and the tomatoes always add that extra touch. We always enjoy going to downtown Hammonton and Mary's is always at the top of our list with that small town charm and the history of the original building that was preserved.“

“A pizzeria that offers more than your standard pie, but I often opt for their Sicilian. Their cheesesteak's are fresh and packed with deliciousness. When I want something healthier, I enjoy the antipasto salad with their fresh soup. Make sure you check out the daily specials, and say hello to the owner Tony.“

“There is something about this small, intimate bar/restaurant that I love. Their broccoli rabe, white bean appetizer with sausage is something that I crave! It's so flavorful. Tonight, I enjoyed meatballs and marinara over penne, and my husband had a tasty chicken cheesesteak and wings. The garlic parm sauce has actual pieces of roasted garlic in it, which is so good on the wings. My vanilla bean creme brulee was great with a perfect sugar crust on top. When people say that small family owned restaurants are better than chain restaurants, Briglias is certainly a testament to that.“

“The service was amazing and the food was just as good too! If I’m in the area I would definitely stop by again. I got the zuppa di pesca and it was so filling! Highly recommend ! My mom is a vegetarian and their eggplant Parmesan was smoking hot and very enjoyable!“

“Absolutely love Dominic’s!We host birthday parties almost every weekend at a local Martial Arts school and Dominic’s is our go-to for pizza! They’re always on time, the pizza is always delicious, and the people are amazing.We brought our community from the Martial Arts school tonight, which ended up being over 50 people, and they crushed it! Everyone loved the food, the environment was great, and it was a total blast.Highly recommend!“

“Had a blast making fresh mozzarella with some guy from Hoboken NJ. Calls himself the Sauce Boss or something like that. 10 out of 11. Owners are super friendly and the backroom is amazing. I felt like I was in a villa on a mountain side someplace in IT LEE.“

“Danny's pizzas are really fresh, big and delicious. We've eaten here a few times and it's been a great experience each time. Fast service. Friendly people here. Love their cheesesteaks. Big menu and can you believe, Cherry soda on tap! Oh my. Pickles, chips and coleslaw accompanies your freshlyade sandwich. Stop in. Right across the street from Donio's Trucking. Great music playing too.Vegetarian options: Salads and veggies. Pizza choices and many pasta options.Parking: Close to the door ease in and ease out.Kid-friendliness: Spaghetti, meatballs, chicken fingers, ziti, salads and appetizers for bite sizes.“

“They are always consistent with their quality of food, their service, and the staff are very pleasant. We usually order our food for parties at work from here, and they have never let us down. The order is always right, food is always delicious and it's ready on time.“

“Haven't been here is years, stopped in on way through town and everything in the same. The owner was still there greeting customers and the food was excellent as always. The cheese fries are full of cheese, two types of- mozzarella and cheddar. Pizza was good. Also had a cheesesteak, it was a little dry but tasty. Can't wait to be in the area again.“

“I would give the food 3 stars and the service 5 stars. I have been to other Maplewood locations, but this was my first experience here. It is a nice restaurant. I didn't really see it as anything extremely fancy, but it was very comfortable. The garlic bread was excellent! Food was just ok. Lobster was kind of chewy, but decent. Overall a good meal with great service!“

“Been going to Olive Garden for many years and always received decent service but this Olive Garden really is the absolute best of them all. It is well staffed, customer service friendly and the food is all absolutely delicious. The bartender, Ally, is not only an absolutely stunning human being, but truly an absolute pro at everything she does. She handled an entire bar room full of people and never missed a step or a smile. We will absolutely be back.“

“Always delicious food! Met the owner today super nice guy! They even made a dish for me that is no longer on the menu. They truly care about the quality of their food and making their customers happy! Also was very accommodating of our service dog. Thank you!“

“This is my favorite place in Hammonton for Pasta Fagioli! Warm bread to go with it. Love their dinners and spectacular mushroom cheesesteaks with garlic rolls. Oh my goodness. Service fantastic and always open. Look out at the downtown Hammonton splendor and enjoy great times with family and friends. Such a great place to eat. Thank you to Marcellos for all they do for our town.Vegetarian options: Specialty pizzas, broccoli and salads delightful!Kid-friendliness: Kid dinners and options for lunch. Yummy chicken fingers and spaghetti!“