The Peddler

44 E Madison Ave, Cresskill
(201) 894-0718

Recent Reviews

Shahar Greenberg

One of my local favorites… especially the pizza ?. The staff is so nice and will take online order before 10pm if you plan on late drinks ?

Kathleen Tomkins

Karen was delightful and the food was delicious we will be back

Kitty Benden

We had a Celebration of Life for our Dad last weekend at the Peddler, and it was fantastic. Food, drinks and service were great! Thank you Steve, Peter, and Dali for truly making the celebration one to remember!

Jerry Squillante

Just love this local place. Every Thursday they have live Jazz and music on the weekends.

Jay Cohen

We went there Dec 4 2021, to listen to my friends band County Roads and have dinner. It doesn’t happen often when all 5 of us enjoy our dinner. I had the baked Scrod and it was delicious. One of my Sons had a $35 steak which isn’t a bad price these days and he gave it a ??. My other Son had a burger and fries and he enjoyed it. My Girlfriend had a chicken sandwich with bacon and she also said she would have it again. My Brother had stuffed shells and a salad. Overall we had an enjoyable night out. The service was ok, no complaints since we weren’t in a hurry. Food came out hot, drink prices were reasonable

Debra Schnellbacher (Debi)

Very nice. We didn't try the good yet but it smelled great. Bartender was very nice.

Peter Kang

Nice quiet neighborhood rest/bar. Just had drinks.

Rosa carrion

Grilled cheese should be melted. Bar tender should not eat at bar. His food looked better than ours. There was a roach on the menu on the bar. Food sucks because everyrhing was broufht out cold. Drinks good.

Rosemary M.

This is and has been a cornerstone establishment in the community for years! Warm inviting atmosphere, great good, and good clientele. On Thursday nights live music from local talent. If you are in search of good American cuisine at an affordable price check them out.

Michael Reavis

Great bar for drinks. Food is consistently good. One of my top go to options in town.

Alexandra Smith

Super friendly waitress, but the food just wasn't good. We just got burgers - super simple, but the meat wasn't flavorful at all, and the bun was like something cheap you'd get at any grocery store. And yes, everything is on plastic plates. Fries were just bad too. Pretty disappointing since I remember their old location being pretty good.

Rose Conforti

Ever since Covid, the owners decided to employ their extremely unprofessional,daughter as a bartender . she has double charged and literally stolen money off the bar . this happened to me and come to find out, many others. I understand this use to go on at old location as well so I guess she must be be getting coached from somewhere. Certainly not at any bartending school. Terrible,nasty service.

Noa Avtalion

Very kind service. Great IPA beer. The pizza has thin crust and is good.

Edward D.

Pre-Covid - used to come here for relaxed dinner where you had servers that have been there for a long time. During Covid - 100% takeout for me, though there's always a decent bar crowd of regulars. Chicken marsala is always on point which came as a surprise to me. Their mashed potatoes that come with it are always spot on, and it makes for good leftovers the next day. Other food - probably your average restaurant/bar style food. I do wish they had a revamped menu for burgers with some more options, but if you know how you like it, just customize it. Pizza is pretty decent on pizza nights too.

Jan Galla

Food is always reliable, comfort food. The service has deteriorated tremendously and isn't close to professional. Room is very noisy and customers have no qualms about talking over the noise.

Load More