The Best and Amazing ice cream! Service is great. The only problem is the bugs in the summer that gather where you order and wait for your order.
Zachajewia1110
Lots of different flavors and options, a d all are delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joanne Stetter
Last year I stopped for ice cream and was so disappointed with my order. We had been going to Jeffreeze for over 22 years. I wrote a negative review that day and heard back from the owner Dennis offering a gift card to be left for me to allow them to correct my order. I have been back several times last year and today marked my 2nd trip for 2024. I have never picked up that gift card I feel it was just a bad day for the person at the counter back last year. Today the ice cream was outstanding as usual, the service perfect.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
KRISTIN Falk
Regular customer!! Great ice
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael J. Comelleri
Fantastic, Fabulous, Frozen treats at JEFFREEZE OLD-
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joseph Jones
Jeffreeze. One word says it all. Come here and you’ll understand.
Lisa P.
You would think that an ice cream spot that's mostly outdoors would not have a line to wait in New Jersey in December, but you'd be wrong. They made it comfortable with heat lamps while you wait and the order location is tarped off but it was still cold and the wait was 20 minutes with only 4 people ahead of me in line. There was only one worker staffed there. She was very nice and doing her best. But if this location is always that busy all year, they need more staff. The ice cream itself was ok. Nothing to write home about. But it wasn't bad. I ordered a pistachio cup. Sub par to pistachio gelato at other places. My son got a black and white milkshake. He said it was "ok". My other son got a butterfinger shake or something like that. It was good but so thick and they gave you a regular straw. They really need the thicker milk shake straws.
Erin O.
I've been visiting Jeffreeze as my go-to ice cream joint for over 10 years now and it never disappoints. I'm a fiend for some good soft serve, and this little shop is one of my favorites for that, especially in the area. I also really enjoy the customer service experience and overall flavor options here, which sets them apart from other ice cream shops. It's relatively easy to miss this place driving past, since it's a small shack on the side of the road, but I highly recommend checking it out and sitting outside on a warm summer day!
John Donahue
Awesome ice cream and they had snowcaps for their blizzard things!!!
Food: 1
Recommended dishes: Sundaes
Mike Barnes
Wow....still a big selection of flavors.A small cone has 3 scoops...whoa...I settled for a 2 scoop cone that was generously scooped.
Their ice cream is amazing. Plenty of options for any taste. Terrible outside with all the bugs tho.
MommyTheBommy
Minus the gnats and you’d be able to stay and enjoy it there instead of driving with it ☹️. Don’t let long line fool you… it moves super fast and sometimes it’s pickup line making it look worse
Larry Tedeschi
Best Black and White shake I've had in a long time
John Wasche
Best Ice cream in Ocean county!Always a treat to goA little expensive, but worth it!
The Best and Amazing ice cream! Service is great. The only problem is the bugs in the summer that gather where you order and wait for your order.
Lots of different flavors and options, a d all are delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Last year I stopped for ice cream and was so disappointed with my order. We had been going to Jeffreeze for over 22 years. I wrote a negative review that day and heard back from the owner Dennis offering a gift card to be left for me to allow them to correct my order. I have been back several times last year and today marked my 2nd trip for 2024. I have never picked up that gift card I feel it was just a bad day for the person at the counter back last year. Today the ice cream was outstanding as usual, the service perfect.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Regular customer!! Great ice
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fantastic, Fabulous, Frozen treats at JEFFREEZE OLD-
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeffreeze. One word says it all. Come here and you’ll understand.
You would think that an ice cream spot that's mostly outdoors would not have a line to wait in New Jersey in December, but you'd be wrong. They made it comfortable with heat lamps while you wait and the order location is tarped off but it was still cold and the wait was 20 minutes with only 4 people ahead of me in line. There was only one worker staffed there. She was very nice and doing her best. But if this location is always that busy all year, they need more staff. The ice cream itself was ok. Nothing to write home about. But it wasn't bad. I ordered a pistachio cup. Sub par to pistachio gelato at other places. My son got a black and white milkshake. He said it was "ok". My other son got a butterfinger shake or something like that. It was good but so thick and they gave you a regular straw. They really need the thicker milk shake straws.
I've been visiting Jeffreeze as my go-to ice cream joint for over 10 years now and it never disappoints. I'm a fiend for some good soft serve, and this little shop is one of my favorites for that, especially in the area. I also really enjoy the customer service experience and overall flavor options here, which sets them apart from other ice cream shops. It's relatively easy to miss this place driving past, since it's a small shack on the side of the road, but I highly recommend checking it out and sitting outside on a warm summer day!
Awesome ice cream and they had snowcaps for their blizzard things!!!
Food: 1
Recommended dishes: Sundaes
Wow....still a big selection of flavors.A small cone has 3 scoops...whoa...I settled for a 2 scoop cone that was generously scooped.
Restaurantji Recommends
The ice-cream was great , so was the service.
Their ice cream is amazing. Plenty of options for any taste. Terrible outside with all the bugs tho.
Minus the gnats and you’d be able to stay and enjoy it there instead of driving with it ☹️. Don’t let long line fool you… it moves super fast and sometimes it’s pickup line making it look worse
Best Black and White shake I've had in a long time
Best Ice cream in Ocean county!Always a treat to goA little expensive, but worth it!