Two Men and an Appetite

55 Eagle Rock Ave, East Hanover
(973) 200-0225

Recent Reviews

Just Real

The guys girlfriend is notorious for being rude to waitstaff. She goes to a hibachi place in Fairfield. Nobody likes her. She is loud. Drinks a whole bottle of wine. Obnoxious and ever since she treated the staff rude she’s pretty much looked down on. I believe her name is Tina. A loud rude drunk. deplorable. Yelled at the staff. The manager. Plus she is not even a chef and she says she is. The food looks yuck.

Marie Homsi Khoury

I recently had Andrew and his staff cater my husbands 40th birthday and everything was amazing!!!!!!!! The food was beyond delicious. The uniqueness of the menu was perfect! The amount of food was insane! His staff was a joy to be with! They left my home spotless from set up to break down everything was easy! His prices are great! His food is delicious. The presentation is outstanding! You will not be disappointed! I hope to have Andrew and his team back at my home for another event!

Jennifer J.

We did an early family Christmas dinner catered by Two Men and an Appetite. Andrew did an amazing job making the evening special for us. We had a delicious meal prepared and served in a professional manner. There were so many choices for each part or the dinner. We couldn't have been happier.

Anita Tsigourakos

Andrew and his team recently catered our daughter’s baptism and it was incredible. To start, the menu selection is impressive for all tastes. The most difficult part of the experience was having to choose what to get off of such a creative menu because everything sounded delicious. When Andrew arrived, he and his team set up at our house quickly. The Tuscan Display was ready when guests walked in and they were completely in awe, as was I. The presentation was so beautiful and

Nicole H.

My friends and I hosted an event for 10 ladies. We order finger foods such as whipped burrata and bruschetta, empanadas, poached shrimp and more. Along with that, we ordered a couple of entrees and fresh fruit skewers. My friend was constantly adding to the menu during the planning process. They showed patience and professionalism. We were thoroughly pleased at the promptness of their arrival, the set up and the food. Everyone raved about the food and the flavor of it. For me - I was IN LOVE with the chicken empanadas. We were beyond pleased at how everything looked and turned out. We host a lot of parties. Unfortunately, we won't be able to do large ones until after COVID. But we are looking forward to using this catering company again for our parties, large and small.

Nicole Napolitano

Chef Andrew and his team at Two Men & an Appetite catered a small party in our yard this past weekend. The food was absolutely incredible, everyone was raving about every dish! Not only was everything delicious, the amount of food we had, along with the presentation was amazing. I wish I thought to take pics of the food but we were having too much fun eating & celebrating my brother’s 50th...lol. Some of the dishes we had were pulled chicken sliders with apple fennel slaw, wing bar with savoy & dry rub wings, chimichurri grilled flank steak, Bbq Baby back ribs, chili lime grilled salmon, and a variety of salads & sides including the watermelon cucumber salad which everyone couldn’t get enough of! Thanks again Chef Andrew!! ?

Nicole Cavicchia

Chef Andrew and his team at Two Men & an Appetite catered a small party in our yard this past weekend. The food was absolutely incredible, everyone was raving about every dish! Not only was everything delicious, the amount of food we had, along with the presentation was amazing. I wish I thought to take pics of the food but we were having too much fun eating & celebrating my brother’s 50th...lol. Some of the dishes we had were pulled chicken sliders with apple fennel slaw, wing bar with savoy & dry rub wings, chimichurri grilled flank steak, Bbq Baby back ribs, chili lime grilled salmon, and a variety of salads & sides including the watermelon cucumber salad which everyone couldn’t get enough of! Thanks again Chef Andrew!!

Kimberly Schwartz

Great spot!!!! Delicious food and staff is top notch!

Sonal Batra

Chef Andrew and his staff are fantastic! They take the stress out of entertaining. All the food is delicious but his whipped burrata is out of this world!

Kathy Price-Sturniolo

Two Men & an Appetite(5 Stars) were complete professionals from my first conversation with Vicki to our last bite of the night. Andrew and his team worked with me to surprise my daughter with a "Girl's Night Out filled with Laughter & Love in Honor of the Bride." Their food couldn't have complimented our venue, Caldwell Flowerland(5 Stars), and my vision of a Speakeasy any better than a Michelin Starred Resturant! They created a menu that featured all my daughter's favorites and presented that food in the most appealing way! Oh did I mention that we planned everything over the phone as I live in Ohio and the event was in New Jersey! So if you believe as I do that the Devil is in the Details Two Men And an Appetite is Red Hot!

Marc Dougherty

Very good food, quality ingredients, and great portions. The sandwiches are all very good, quite large with fresh homemade bread, and the daily specials are also all always quite good. I unpacked my container today of the daily special chicken, and there's enough there for both lunch and dinner. Great place!

Joshua Lewitter

Great friendly staff with good food! No seating but worth a quick stop in

Tim Breeman

Customer service wasn't the best but the food is amazing!! The guy behind the counter wasn't rude or being mean but he didn't scream happy either.

Robert B.

These Two men really are good.They came with a 3 man team of chefs. 3 servers and a bartender. (they also came to the house and went through the menu and presentation 4 days before event, and came back a second time two days before. They arrived punctually 3 hours before show time. A formal table was set by the servers, guests were greeted graciously and their coats attended two. The evening began with 45 minutes of pass around appetizers (mini short rib taco with two sauces,mini Ice cream tyoe cones stuffed with Hamachi tuna with either spicy or not spicy Yuzu sauce topped with Creme Fresca and salmon caviar black-non spicy red spicy , and mini taco shell stuffed with avocado shrimp mix) followed by A complex meal including 5 courses ( Fried Asparagus topped with crispy fried leeks in a Miso Vinagrette dressing, Wild Mushroom soup topped with White truffle oil and accompanied by a mini-croissant, Scallops served over bed of leeks with 2 purees Squash and Parsnip , Main course was choice of Beef bourginon in puff pastry or Seared Hamachi tuna log in a complex marinade, served with side of two purees white truffle sweet potatoes and turnips) and 8 different wines. If this was'nt enought 4 desserts (on one plate hit the table including a mini bread pudding, fried chocolate truffle Homemade Frangelica and Raisin Gelato and a chocolate pudding cake. In addition there were 8 different wines. Every dish was delicious and presented a a work of art....onto the cleanup the Kitchen and house were spotless 122 plates cleaned and put away, 52 wine glasses cleaned, refrigerator was packed perfectly , House was spotless . Use them if you get the oppurtunity !!!!!!!!

terri g.

We must compliment this great catering company. Bravo to Two Men and an Appetite who catered our Thanksgiving dinner this week. Everything from the TWO turkeys, many sides of roasted veggies and sweet and mashed potatoes, cornbread, Asian meatballs and Thai noodle salad were beautifully prepared and delicious. It was a pleasure to work with Vicki and Andrew from start to finish and they happily offered suggestions and personalized the menu for us. I highly recommend this local company and am looking forward to our next party with them.

Load More