Guido's Famous Pizza

22 Lewis St, Eatontown
(732) 389-8989

Recent Reviews

Alicia Thorne

Very disappointed with salad.In our salad was 4 ends tomato…what happened to the seeded/fleshy part of the tomato?“4 Ends” of a tomato in a salad …Really?

Mukarram

Soon as the owner greets you, you know you are gonna get some real fine pizza.Highly recommend!

Tina M.

The best pizza, the best food. I love the workers always happy and smiling. The new owners are working hard and are doing great. They didn't change any of the recipes or ingredients in the food they serve. Very friendly owners.

tristan8141

Top notch New Jersey pizza. Also great meatball parm subs. Friendly service, good speed on delivery.

Carrie G.

The pizza changed since new ownership. The Sicilian pie used to be so light and fluffy now it is dense and has zero flavor. There sauce was always flavorful now tastes like tomato paste.

M G.

I ordered frequently. Food is always fresh and tasty. I ordered a few dinners last week and a free side dishes were missing. Tonight I mentioned the slip up and the owner gave me a credit on my bill. I was impressed.

Kaleena S.

I have been picking up for for a 75 year old man in a regular basis and every single time they end up burning his food. When you walk in and see the food in the window it's always burnt. Who ever is cooking now has no idea what he is doing. The food is disgusting and always burnt.

paula craig

I had no idea they changed owners, and the new owners need a lot of improvements I called in for my food she said 30 mins. When I got there I still had to wait another whole hour and half! It was horrible, terrible had me sitting there wait that long for a pie? And a dinner. And the bottom of the dinner was burnt!! I will never ever go back to this business again!!

Daryl Murphy

The pizza here is awesome and the staff is incredibly nice... I pass three pizza shops to get here !!!?

Dan Schena

The pizza was great and the staff was kind. I would recommend them to all my friends and family.

Noemi V.

I appreciated them taking a pick up 40mins before closing, but pizza but after reassuring 3x with the person in the phone of my order it was wrong. And the cheese feels old, it's salty and most of the bread is burned

M Devorah

Stopped in for a slice of pizza, soda and a few garlic knots. Enjoyed the foods I purchased. $5.00 can't beat that!

Gamez top collectibles

Great good and staff. Pizza is cooked right looks good and take great. One of my favorite places..prices are good compared to other locations.

Denise Foley

Great place called in a pizza very courteous very kind people pizza was ready when I got there hot good to go it was still hot and I got home will be going back

MR. GOLIVE

When I first moved to eatontown 5 years ago I love this place I sont know what happened but the pizza is trash I found hair in my sub twice 2 different orders ask for extra mayonnaise and vinegar they didn't put any on at all I would go here anymore but 5 years ago 5star I will not be coming back

Load More