Mikey's Famous Pizzeria

1000 S Elmora Ave, Elizabeth
(908) 352-4040

Recent Reviews

angela forti

Bad hygiene. The counter guy was picking nose while waiting for my food to warm up ?????

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Santos Joel Mercado Caban

This pizzeria charged me 6.99 for a 4.99 vegetable soup that I ordered after looking them up online also gave me the wrong order I called them to prepare went there after they told me to come by in ten minutes made me wait for another 15 minutes to get my order left to do some other errands because my wife was sick took me hours to do shopping laundry and personally pay bills because it is Saturday and ended up delaying a few of my chores because of that to finally get home and see that what I ordered was completely wrong it is not about the money cause I would have paid whatever was the charge is the fact that they messed up my order made me wait and even more i was charged 35.70 gave the clerk 35.75 and never gave me the 5 cents back this is the last time I buy from them not worth it they are not honest and don't take responsibility of their mistakes. It is not about the money cause I had the money to pay for everything I order in fact when I got there I told them I'm picking up an order that I made by phone and even told them it was a pasta Bolognese spaghetti a vegetable soup and a meat lovers pizza and they told me ok wait 15 minutes until it is done.u know what bothers me the fact that I was charged 35.70 gave the clerk 35.75 and he didn't even gave me the change or the receipt I took it from the cash register after he walked away from it and didn't even looked back. Won't buy anything from them I suggest and firmly advise everyone to not buy anything from them.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

GiGi

Our pasta was dry because they don't know how to package food for delivery. All the juice was in the bottom of the bag from the Chicken Francese. They also under cooked the pizza. Bad experience over all. They can do way better than what they gave us. It was careless maybe because we were one of the last deliveries. That's still no excuse. I will never go back

Food: 1

Service: 1

Gina James

Drove all the way there and they were closed.....like had not even opened for the day closed. It was 12:30pm. And, yes I went during normal business hours.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Michael Ziegler

Great food. Food was ready quick and was HOT on pickup. We didn’t try the pizza but what we did try was delicious.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Alla Vodka

Gianfranco Giarretto

Very very good , I love the quality and taste of the food here . It’s an amazing place! Been ordering and picking up for over 7 years and I can’t never complaint of the taste. Everything is cooked to what I call homemade/Italian taste. I love the pizza , also the fettuccini Alfredo pasta is so delicious. Thanks for everything ??❤️ this place is one of my favorites !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gaston Gaston

Ordered for delivery. Delivery was very quick! Our food was okay but my order was wrong and they ended up sending me a cheaper meal than what I paid for.

Zaira RosS

Love this place. Food is always fresh and delicious. Delivery on time and courteous. 'd recommend it as a nice place to go, take out or delivery.

Shaynna Terrell

THE CUSTOMER SERVICE IS DISGUSTING. The workers are mean , and rude ! I placed an order on door dash and was robbed ! They tooo my money and did not reimburse me . I waited hours for food I did not receive. I called the store they told me it was on the way , I called and again for them to say they canceled my order . MY ORDER WAS NOT CANCELED, my money was taken! DONT ORDER FROM THEM . They kept hanging up on me , just a terrible experience

petter manchester

Italian decoration and setup style. The design of the place is nice and the food was good. Went as a family and tried several dishes that include pizzas, risotto and pasta. The pizzas were the stylish among all. In general the food is overpriced. It’s worth noting that the eatery will accept only cash which is strange!

yale yalitza

Best place for pizza .. after the first bite i was sent to another world .. very satisfied with the place and quality of the foodWe ate pasta, pizza (different amazing cheeses) and diet salad

suzan alikhandrew

You need to dress warm if you're dropping by in cold times.The place is cheque and relatively simple. Italian Pizza( thin) with fresh constituents and it tastes succulent but you'll need to order 2 if you eat well

Harold Harper

Crust was AMAZING! Not only was the food delicious, but the service was UNMATCHED! Some of the best I've had in the city. Would definitely come again. PS: you have to try the Serrano Chili Wings!

Vincent Martin

Love Crust. My favorite is the Margarita with extra anchovies. You can't always find anchovies, and it is so delicious! Y husband loves the meat lovers- whatever they call it there. It is our go to spot!!!

Cindie Rendon

it's each about the client experience in my opinion in the service assiduity. I was saluted when I came by and noway had an empty mug the entire time. I ever got to meet the owner, who was very personable and told us his background. Although this might be a franchise, I was very pleased with how had his operations and will be a returning customer in the near future.

Load More