The best ice cream on the bay shore. Fresh ingredients, great service, and most of all, amazing ice cream ! The coffee crunch ice cream was one of the best I’ve had in a long time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Diane Turton
The best ice cream i ever had!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato
Jason Pauxtis
Italian Rainbow Cookie ice cream, 1000/10.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephanie M.
Try the Jersey Corn Ice Cream! Unique and delicious! We also loved the Brown Sugar Cookie Dough as well!
Grace McKay
This place is ?. The brown sugar cookie dough would have been enough for an EASY 5 stars, but I also tried peanut butter palooza and coffee crunch, both of which were super flavorful and delicious. This ice cream is RICH - although surprisingly the prices were not. 3 scoops in a large cup for $5.95 is a win all around. The spoons were sturdy, I didn't try a cone because I only saw homemade waffle which looked awesome but unfortunately the one downfall of this place is that they're cash only and I was already scrounging to afford my much needed ice cream. Pst - A lot of only cash places have started taking Venmo. Although they do have an ATM inside at least.
Cambria Vallaire
This review is mainly for costumer service: I came here with my family tonight to get some ice-cream. Unfortunately, I have a dairy intolerance. The sweet girl with the braid at the front said they had more of the dairy free ice-cream in the back being the one she suggested was running low.. Another girl behind the counter walked over (without checking) and in a stern voice told us they were completely out of it. We believe she was lying or simply just didn’t care because they were close to closing. ? Fair enough. I wouldn’t want to fetch it “from the back” either at 9:30PM. My family enjoyed their icecreams though! Good spot for a late night treat.
Liam Mahon
Super friendly customer service and great ice cream! They also have much better prices then I've seen other places.
Ghh Hhhk
Delicious ice cream! Creamy, natural flavors with a good flavor selection. Staff is always polite and friendly and will offer a taste test.
Lisa D.
Girls were very rude. Not friendly, rushed order and had zero personality. I won't be returning to this location with my family
Daniel Sclafani
So delicious! Everyone in our group enjoyed our ice cream. It was so creamy & sweet, just fantastic! Between us, we got 5 or 6 different flavors and they were all incredible. I'll come back here in a heartbeat.
It’s safe to say that Nicholas Creamery sells the best ice cream in Monmouth County. The flavors are always fresh, the service is always efficient, and the owners are outstanding. I also went to school with Mr. Harary’s son and can say that they’re an amazing family. Super kind, skilled, and welcoming
Michael Puello
Overrated! I was very disappointed because I only came due to the great reviews. We tried peaches and cream, watermelon, and vanilla. The Ice-cream are not creamy, don't feel fresh and barely have any taste. Honestly one of the worse ice-cream I've ever had. Two stars because the staff was Amazing and welcoming.
Gabriela Nina
All I'm going to say is this place left so much to be desired... disappointed. I tried the old fashioned chocolate, peanut butter pallooza, peaches and cream, and watermelon with chocolate chunks, the only tasty one was PB. They were not that creamy or flavorful.
Samg381
HIGHWAY ROBBERY and CASH ONLY. Forces you to use an ATM with a steep withdrawal fee. NO EXCUSE for this nowadays. ANYONE can accept credit cards. $10 for two ping pong balls worth of ice cream. Disgraceful. This place will fail.
Yvonne C.
Yummm y yummmm yumm yummmm!!! Light, tasty and refreshingly whole ice cream!! This spot was clean, open and inviting!!We ordered the toasted coconut - and the Oreo milk shakes!! Very good !! Well balanced flavor and right amount of sweetness!!! Warm waffle cone---- DO IT!!! or you'll regret it!! Go ahead have a come today!! Enjoy!!
The best ice cream on the bay shore. Fresh ingredients, great service, and most of all, amazing ice cream ! The coffee crunch ice cream was one of the best I’ve had in a long time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best ice cream i ever had!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato
Italian Rainbow Cookie ice cream, 1000/10.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Try the Jersey Corn Ice Cream! Unique and delicious! We also loved the Brown Sugar Cookie Dough as well!
This place is ?. The brown sugar cookie dough would have been enough for an EASY 5 stars, but I also tried peanut butter palooza and coffee crunch, both of which were super flavorful and delicious. This ice cream is RICH - although surprisingly the prices were not. 3 scoops in a large cup for $5.95 is a win all around. The spoons were sturdy, I didn't try a cone because I only saw homemade waffle which looked awesome but unfortunately the one downfall of this place is that they're cash only and I was already scrounging to afford my much needed ice cream. Pst - A lot of only cash places have started taking Venmo. Although they do have an ATM inside at least.
This review is mainly for costumer service: I came here with my family tonight to get some ice-cream. Unfortunately, I have a dairy intolerance. The sweet girl with the braid at the front said they had more of the dairy free ice-cream in the back being the one she suggested was running low.. Another girl behind the counter walked over (without checking) and in a stern voice told us they were completely out of it. We believe she was lying or simply just didn’t care because they were close to closing. ? Fair enough. I wouldn’t want to fetch it “from the back” either at 9:30PM. My family enjoyed their icecreams though! Good spot for a late night treat.
Super friendly customer service and great ice cream! They also have much better prices then I've seen other places.
Delicious ice cream! Creamy, natural flavors with a good flavor selection. Staff is always polite and friendly and will offer a taste test.
Girls were very rude. Not friendly, rushed order and had zero personality. I won't be returning to this location with my family
So delicious! Everyone in our group enjoyed our ice cream. It was so creamy & sweet, just fantastic! Between us, we got 5 or 6 different flavors and they were all incredible. I'll come back here in a heartbeat.
Restaurantji Recommends
It’s safe to say that Nicholas Creamery sells the best ice cream in Monmouth County. The flavors are always fresh, the service is always efficient, and the owners are outstanding. I also went to school with Mr. Harary’s son and can say that they’re an amazing family. Super kind, skilled, and welcoming
Overrated! I was very disappointed because I only came due to the great reviews. We tried peaches and cream, watermelon, and vanilla. The Ice-cream are not creamy, don't feel fresh and barely have any taste. Honestly one of the worse ice-cream I've ever had. Two stars because the staff was Amazing and welcoming.
All I'm going to say is this place left so much to be desired... disappointed. I tried the old fashioned chocolate, peanut butter pallooza, peaches and cream, and watermelon with chocolate chunks, the only tasty one was PB. They were not that creamy or flavorful.
HIGHWAY ROBBERY and CASH ONLY. Forces you to use an ATM with a steep withdrawal fee. NO EXCUSE for this nowadays. ANYONE can accept credit cards. $10 for two ping pong balls worth of ice cream. Disgraceful. This place will fail.
Yummm y yummmm yumm yummmm!!! Light, tasty and refreshingly whole ice cream!! This spot was clean, open and inviting!!We ordered the toasted coconut - and the Oreo milk shakes!! Very good !! Well balanced flavor and right amount of sweetness!!! Warm waffle cone---- DO IT!!! or you'll regret it!! Go ahead have a come today!! Enjoy!!