They need to change the name of this place because it's definitely not John's Pizza anymore. If you liked John's Pizza 2-3 years or more ago, you will be VERY disappointed at the pizza place that's now calling themselves John's Pizza. Ownership changed hands a couple of years ago but it seemed like they were sticking with the same recipe. That went out the window. The pizza now doesn't even taste homemade. I'm not exaggerating the pizza there is now just like a 7-11 pizza. The sauce is bland and the crust is like cardboard. With as many real pizza places as there are in Fair Lawn I can't imagine this place is going to survive very long. This used to be my favorite pizza place in Fair Lawn but I'll definitely never be going back now.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Dana Braunstein
I used to order from Turvinos but I'm switching to John's, pizza was delicious!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice of Pie
Jenn Gruber
Is this place under new management again?
Food: 1
John Cleary
The pizza is horrible. Their crust seems pre-made. The sauce is tasteless. Like a pizza you would get in the middle of the country where they can't make good dough. Very nice people but if you like real nj/ny pizza this ain't the place. Hope they get a real pizza chef or
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Natalie O
Delicious gluten free pizza! Thank
Food: 5
Service: 5
tato kay
One of the BEST pizzas in the area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe Rodriguez
I travel from Texas and go out of my way to eat here. It is the best crust I've ever had
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Grayson Adam
got a slice and a drink on my lunch break and it was perfect- great pizza, super fast service, good price, all around W
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bernie L.
Decided to try this place as its under new ownership. I ordered a Pepperoni & Sicilian pie. Both were very good and comparable to other places in town. I will definitely be back.
KayG_Loves
Ordered a chicken bacon ranch pizza , and instead I got a tomato pizza. Barely any chicken or bacon, all tomato’s. I literally paid $30 for bread and tomatoes. & on top of that the driver sarcastically made a comment when delivering the pizza, stating you paid in tip on the card correct, as if we better have tipped him via card. If I paid a delivery fee , that should be included in the delivery driver’s tip ! Anyways I will never order from this place again. Not worth the money. Trash pizza !
I have not had pizza from John’s in a very, very long time and it is just as delicious today as 35 plus years ago. Excellent Sicilian pizza!!!
L. Yankovich
This little gem is under new management and folks, you should really give it a try! The food is real & really good. Everything tastes like it’s made from scratch, no short-cuts or pre-fabs used. Nice crispy thin crust pizza; delicious salads with homemade dressings; real chicken, salmon, steak and so on. Good desserts too - cheesecake, zepolis. Everything is nice and fresh, perfectly seasoned and so satisfying. Fast delivery too!
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Dev Goswami
Some of the most delicious pizza I had in Fair Lawn, very tasty.
Johnliuca
Owner treated us well and the pizza was really good.
Jeffrey Lanuez
Still the best pizza! New owner is making John’s original recipe I remember growing up. THIN, simple, and crispy. This is a must New Jersey pizza!!!
They need to change the name of this place because it's definitely not John's Pizza anymore. If you liked John's Pizza 2-3 years or more ago, you will be VERY disappointed at the pizza place that's now calling themselves John's Pizza. Ownership changed hands a couple of years ago but it seemed like they were sticking with the same recipe. That went out the window. The pizza now doesn't even taste homemade. I'm not exaggerating the pizza there is now just like a 7-11 pizza. The sauce is bland and the crust is like cardboard. With as many real pizza places as there are in Fair Lawn I can't imagine this place is going to survive very long. This used to be my favorite pizza place in Fair Lawn but I'll definitely never be going back now.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
I used to order from Turvinos but I'm switching to John's, pizza was delicious!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice of Pie
Is this place under new management again?
Food: 1
The pizza is horrible. Their crust seems pre-made. The sauce is tasteless. Like a pizza you would get in the middle of the country where they can't make good dough. Very nice people but if you like real nj/ny pizza this ain't the place. Hope they get a real pizza chef or
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Delicious gluten free pizza! Thank
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of the BEST pizzas in the area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I travel from Texas and go out of my way to eat here. It is the best crust I've ever had
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
got a slice and a drink on my lunch break and it was perfect- great pizza, super fast service, good price, all around W
Food: 5
Service: 5
Decided to try this place as its under new ownership. I ordered a Pepperoni & Sicilian pie. Both were very good and comparable to other places in town. I will definitely be back.
Ordered a chicken bacon ranch pizza , and instead I got a tomato pizza. Barely any chicken or bacon, all tomato’s. I literally paid $30 for bread and tomatoes. & on top of that the driver sarcastically made a comment when delivering the pizza, stating you paid in tip on the card correct, as if we better have tipped him via card. If I paid a delivery fee , that should be included in the delivery driver’s tip ! Anyways I will never order from this place again. Not worth the money. Trash pizza !
Restaurantji Recommends
I have not had pizza from John’s in a very, very long time and it is just as delicious today as 35 plus years ago. Excellent Sicilian pizza!!!
This little gem is under new management and folks, you should really give it a try! The food is real & really good. Everything tastes like it’s made from scratch, no short-cuts or pre-fabs used. Nice crispy thin crust pizza; delicious salads with homemade dressings; real chicken, salmon, steak and so on. Good desserts too - cheesecake, zepolis. Everything is nice and fresh, perfectly seasoned and so satisfying. Fast delivery too!
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Some of the most delicious pizza I had in Fair Lawn, very tasty.
Owner treated us well and the pizza was really good.
Still the best pizza! New owner is making John’s original recipe I remember growing up. THIN, simple, and crispy. This is a must New Jersey pizza!!!