Blue Fish Grill

50 Mine St, Flemington
(908) 237-4528

Recent Reviews

Caitlin Summer

I've been debating for a little bit on whether or not to write a review, but last weekend I was able to try this place for dinner. The Tokyo Tacos were tasteless. I was missing the ginger completely, and ended up making my own wasabi sauce for them since there was barely any on them and I didn’t taste a drop of wasabi. On top of this, the fries were sugared instead of salted. I have no idea whether or not this was a mistake, but peppered and sugared fries with dinner aren't appetizing to me.The Calamari was phenomenal. & the bite of the Calimex burrito I had made my mouth water for more. I'm not a fan of beans in burritos at all, but I didn't mind with this one. I've never been able to say that!All in all, I'd give this place another go.

Phil Pereira

Unfortunately, no longer a sit-down restaurant. They are only offering takeout.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Spicy Tuna Nachos

Elisa Merilan

Great atmosphere, friendly staff, good food, nice decor… nice place for a date or a girls night.definitely coming

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

G C

We go here regularly and happy with the experience and food. The beef barbacoa nachos are the bomb and specials are usually very good. Can't go wrong with anything on the menu really. We've had Jackson as a server last couple of visits and he's fantastic. Pleasant, responsive and attentive. Highly recommend a visit.Dine in: Yes

brett vrancken

Maybe we were hungry, maybe we just ordered the right things. Whatever the case, We are definitely coming back here, and often.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Spicy Tuna Nachos

JoAnne Dunn

Had lunch with a friend today and I ordered blacked Mahi Mahi with asparagus. It was the driest fish I have ever eaten and the asparagus was not grilled enough and was very woody. I could only eat half. My friend had the masa fried cod and cole slaw. She said it was just okay. One good thing was our server, Bella was very good!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 5

Robin Angelozzi

Absolutely love Blue Fish! Had a great server tonight, Emma, and a great meal as well! The Tempura Teriayki Salmon was superb and the Fried Cod with plantains and homemade potato chips Delicious! Great food every time we go there!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Keia Kemp

Ordered the Baja taco. The mahi-mahi was over cooked so it was like rubber and I needed a search warrant to find the avocado mash (which was only on one taco). For $18 I was hoping for something I could eat and enjoy.

Ryan Thorpe

This was our first visit to Blue Fish Grill and it was great! My wife and I shared the Frisee and Arugula Salad to start which was refreshing and delicious. She ordered the Mahi Mahi dish which she loved and I ordered the BFG Burger. That burger is one of the best I've ever had! The bun was heaven, the meat cooked and seasoned perfectly! Wow, thinking about it again is making me hungry for it. The service was quick, attentive and great. I highly recommend BFG and we'll be back soon.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: BFG Burger

Tara Zimliki

Yum!! This food never disappoints. Great service, amazing food with served piping hot with a smile and a very comfortable clean atmosphere! We will definitely be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Morkel Jakeson

3.5 stars. The food is pretty good and we eat here at least every month, but they mess up your order 75% of the time- not exaggerating. It’s so frustrating. They even leave out entire meals and we have to drive back 20 minutes or request a refund.

Alexandra Goble

Absolutely delicious loved the flavors and presentation! Will definitely be coming back again :)

Robert Quinn

We really liked this place. Inside seating isn't all that great, we'll go back in warmer weather and sit outside. Beef barbacoa platter was A+. Also highly recommend the currey mussels app. The fish tacos were not tasty, not sure why. Our waiter was very nice and knowledgeable. It's also a BYOB

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rita DeFrange

The food was good, and the service started out a little rocky...but was good in the end. The dinning room was cold and the server could have cared less...bit the owner was apologetic because the restaurant is in a old building. Not sure I would go back.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Angelo S

Food is always good here. Service is great. The thing they need work on is everything else. 2nd floor is like eating in a Cafeteria. No pictures on the walls, little things all over the floor (not swept much), Nothing on tables (water, bread, candles or flowers, salt & pepper ) and all the staff dress like they are customers. All Different ... Common guys, with a little attention to detail, your restaurant would be much more attractive to people.

Load More