Pizza is one of my favorite treats. I have been to Italy many times and have eaten pizza in Rome, Milan, Florence and Venice many times. But what I tried in this pizzeria is amazing! I highly recommend this place to everyone!
James Bourke
Best pizza in the Garden State, with the best grape soda in the world!
colonialmatt13
They offer a special on their menu, buy one dinner, get one half price. So I ordered some. The so-called owner says I can’t get the salads that come with the dinners, even though the menu says all dinners come with soup or salad. When I get the delivery, there is a $3 delivery fee. I show the menu to the driver where it says free delivery. She calls the guy up and he says it’s for the salads. I then argue with him on the phone in front of his driver. He tells me the coupon doesn’t say it comes with salads. I tell him the coupon is for dinners for which the menu states that they do come with salads. I told him I’m done with his place. The driver tries giving me back some money because she knows I’m right.
Nicholas Hansen
Worst pizza I ever had over cooked Oily bottom of pizza thst falling apart . As I was eatingI don’t recommend anybody going there Rude Owner Who didn’t understand what I said I had repeat my self 6 times
Nicholas Goldstein
How do you call yourself a pizzeria when you cannot even make a decent slice of cheese pizza? All dough - no cheese and sauce!
Kacy K
Sure wish they'd stop parking on the sidewalk in front of their restaurant. It's a safety issue for our children.
K 2.
I wish they'd stop parking on the sidewalk. My child shouldn't be forced into traffic.
Michael D.
I have tried many different pizzas in the area and this is for sure one of the worst. The pizza is really oily and burnt. I ordered a large margherita pizza with extra cheese and there was barely any cheese on it... i wonder what it wouldve looked like had i not have asked for extra cheese. If youre going to cheap out by not giving cheese, then clearly this pizza business is not for you. We the customers keep you in business, not the few bucks youre trying to save by giving less cheese. I wanted to give them another chance and this time ordered a buffalo chicken pizza and thats what completely ruined this place for me. The chicken was tough and inedible, and you guessed it. NO CHEESE. It felt like i was eating cardboard with disgusting chicken and the worst part is that they charge a high price and give you terrible ingredients. Stay away from this disgraceful place.
Irina S
Love the pizza and the owner, very friendly guy. Always a pleasure to go there and the prices are fantastic
Andrew Nikow
Order Pizza online for pickup. When I got home I found the order was totally wrong. Not even close to what I ordered. Guy at the pizzeria had no idea how their own online order system worked, but blamed me for ordering it “wrong”.
I would have given 1 Star but atleast the sauce tasted good, and the pizza was on time and warm, so giving 2 Stars.Ordered the Corleone Pizza and for the 1st time in life experienced what people mean when they say the pizza tastes like cardboard. It was just too hard and I couldn't bring myself to get through the 2nd slice eventhough I was extremely hungry ?
SamanthaSue H.
I've ordered my standard pizza from here a few times and it was fine but today I wanted something different. I reviewed the menu and decided on their focaccia. The description was mouth watering: one vegetarian; one with meat. I ordered both online for delivery. I'd eat a bit of each and save the rest in my freezer. In addition I added apple crisp to the order which I've had in the past and always enjoyed. I filled in my delivery address and credit card information and placed the order. Instead of delivery it flashed "pickup." I called the restaurant which happily agreed to deliver. The order arrived in half an hour. I opened the bag and instead of the highly anticipated focaccia there were four identical sandwiches with fillings that were unrecognizable except for slices of roasted red pepper and slab of some bland cheese. Instead of apple crisp was tiramisu. I thought they'd delivered the wrong order. Another call to the restaurant and I was told that they had neither focaccia nor apple crisp so they sent this instead. No phone call to ask about substitution; no explanation. The "sandwich" fillings were so dried out and desiccated they weren't recognizable except for the cheese and peppers. The tiramisu was quite delicious, however.
Koder R.
Pizza is simply trash, no other way to describe it.... Bland crust sucks sauce sucks flavor sucks don't bother with this place.... Do not recommend at all if you want a decent slice of pizza. .99 cents pizza is a way better option
Michael Greenhut
We used to love this place, but since the change in ownership, the quality hasn’t been quite right.
Hannah Kim
Tried corleone pizza for the first time and it didn’t disappoint. It was the perfect amount of sauce and toppings. Would definitely order another pie in the future.
Pizza is one of my favorite treats. I have been to Italy many times and have eaten pizza in Rome, Milan, Florence and Venice many times. But what I tried in this pizzeria is amazing! I highly recommend this place to everyone!
Best pizza in the Garden State, with the best grape soda in the world!
They offer a special on their menu, buy one dinner, get one half price. So I ordered some. The so-called owner says I can’t get the salads that come with the dinners, even though the menu says all dinners come with soup or salad. When I get the delivery, there is a $3 delivery fee. I show the menu to the driver where it says free delivery. She calls the guy up and he says it’s for the salads. I then argue with him on the phone in front of his driver. He tells me the coupon doesn’t say it comes with salads. I tell him the coupon is for dinners for which the menu states that they do come with salads. I told him I’m done with his place. The driver tries giving me back some money because she knows I’m right.
Worst pizza I ever had over cooked Oily bottom of pizza thst falling apart . As I was eatingI don’t recommend anybody going there Rude Owner Who didn’t understand what I said I had repeat my self 6 times
How do you call yourself a pizzeria when you cannot even make a decent slice of cheese pizza? All dough - no cheese and sauce!
Sure wish they'd stop parking on the sidewalk in front of their restaurant. It's a safety issue for our children.
I wish they'd stop parking on the sidewalk. My child shouldn't be forced into traffic.
I have tried many different pizzas in the area and this is for sure one of the worst. The pizza is really oily and burnt. I ordered a large margherita pizza with extra cheese and there was barely any cheese on it... i wonder what it wouldve looked like had i not have asked for extra cheese. If youre going to cheap out by not giving cheese, then clearly this pizza business is not for you. We the customers keep you in business, not the few bucks youre trying to save by giving less cheese. I wanted to give them another chance and this time ordered a buffalo chicken pizza and thats what completely ruined this place for me. The chicken was tough and inedible, and you guessed it. NO CHEESE. It felt like i was eating cardboard with disgusting chicken and the worst part is that they charge a high price and give you terrible ingredients. Stay away from this disgraceful place.
Love the pizza and the owner, very friendly guy. Always a pleasure to go there and the prices are fantastic
Order Pizza online for pickup. When I got home I found the order was totally wrong. Not even close to what I ordered. Guy at the pizzeria had no idea how their own online order system worked, but blamed me for ordering it “wrong”.
Restaurantji Recommends
I would have given 1 Star but atleast the sauce tasted good, and the pizza was on time and warm, so giving 2 Stars.Ordered the Corleone Pizza and for the 1st time in life experienced what people mean when they say the pizza tastes like cardboard. It was just too hard and I couldn't bring myself to get through the 2nd slice eventhough I was extremely hungry ?
I've ordered my standard pizza from here a few times and it was fine but today I wanted something different. I reviewed the menu and decided on their focaccia. The description was mouth watering: one vegetarian; one with meat. I ordered both online for delivery. I'd eat a bit of each and save the rest in my freezer. In addition I added apple crisp to the order which I've had in the past and always enjoyed. I filled in my delivery address and credit card information and placed the order. Instead of delivery it flashed "pickup." I called the restaurant which happily agreed to deliver. The order arrived in half an hour. I opened the bag and instead of the highly anticipated focaccia there were four identical sandwiches with fillings that were unrecognizable except for slices of roasted red pepper and slab of some bland cheese. Instead of apple crisp was tiramisu. I thought they'd delivered the wrong order. Another call to the restaurant and I was told that they had neither focaccia nor apple crisp so they sent this instead. No phone call to ask about substitution; no explanation. The "sandwich" fillings were so dried out and desiccated they weren't recognizable except for the cheese and peppers. The tiramisu was quite delicious, however.
Pizza is simply trash, no other way to describe it.... Bland crust sucks sauce sucks flavor sucks don't bother with this place.... Do not recommend at all if you want a decent slice of pizza. .99 cents pizza is a way better option
We used to love this place, but since the change in ownership, the quality hasn’t been quite right.
Tried corleone pizza for the first time and it didn’t disappoint. It was the perfect amount of sauce and toppings. Would definitely order another pie in the future.