Overpriced! I took a shot with this place and although the pizza is good, I just can't justify spending $11-12 for two slices of pizza and a soda! Now, I totally understand charging a little more for "specialty" slices, but seriously it's just pizza. And I know it costs next to nothing to make a pizza. I recently purchased a plain slice, a "specialty" slice, and a soda. The total came to $11 and change. Seriously? This place isn't exactly gourmet dining. I'll go a minute up the road next time and pay $2 a slice. It tastes just as good! IT'S JUST PIZZA!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Jeff
Great food and always on time and correct
t p
Waste of retail space. Terrible experience. FRIED CALAMARI an insult. Buyer beware. I wish I could rate it -10 stars.
Lynn Harold
Pizza was good but from a selfish perspective, I have to express dissatisfaction with the restaurant's logistics. I took my wheelchair-bound mother there for dinner. The entryway is difficult to navigate. All the chairs on the restaurant area are armless, and the bathroom is too tiny to allow a wheelchair in. I will not visit again but would be open to take-out.
Erica C.
Ordered the meatball sub and chicken with vodka sauce. Solid meatball sub the sauce was well balanced and not too acidic. Got the chicken cutlet on a garlic bread, which was the right call. Would definitely go back to try rest of the sandwich menu.
Greg Rickmers
Wasn’t really a fan of this style of pizza. Crust tasted off.
amn2117
I had gone here about a month ago for pizza. The pizza was less than memorable. The other thing was they were charging a credit card fee. Now many restaurants are doing this and I think as consumers we need to push back on these fees. Yes they get charged and have always been charged. What changed? Nothing. Now they are trying to pass along a “cost of doing business”. When I questioned the fee the owner told me gas stations charge a fee. Well you are not a gas station. And not all gas stations charge a fee. Clearly not a lot of intelligence there. Back to my latest visit. They are in a convenient location and I decided to try it again and use cash. They had a “grandmas pie”. They were average size. 9 in a pie. They had them cut on the diagonal. I questioned why each piece was cut. They told me that was the slice. The cost was 4.00 per essentially 1/2 of a square slice. So they found still another way to gouge their customers. When I left without buying anything after asking the price they made a rude comment that I wouldn’t pay 4.00. Stay away. Bad food. Unprofessional and taking advantage anyway they can.
SANDRA MACLEOD
Great chicken parm! Both of my wonderful grandfarhers were named Attillio, how could I not? Thanks for a great lunch!
Cesar Jimenez
I stopped by recently and ordered a baked ziti. It was so good that I’m considering driving an hour away next time I want some good ziti . The place is also nice and great staff . Thanks
I recently visited Attilio's Pizzeria in Freehold, NJ, and overall, it was a decent experience. I ordered a meat lovers pizza to go, and while it wasn't the best pizza I've ever had, it was still tasty. The pizza had a generous amount of meat toppings, but the crust was a bit thicker and doughier than I prefer.However, what really stood out to me was the poor customer service. When I arrived, there weren't many customers inside the restaurant, yet the staff seemed disinterested and not very welcoming. When I called ahead to place my order, the person who answered the phone sounded uninterested and didn't seem to want to help me.As someone who values good customer service, this was disappointing. That being said, I do want to acknowledge that this was likely a one-off experience, as Attilio's Pizzeria is typically known for having good customer service. I would be willing to give them another chance in the future and hope that the service will be better.One aspect of Attilio's Pizzeria that I did appreciate was the convenience of getting the pizza to go. The process was quick and easy, which is always a plus.Overall, I would rate Attilio's Pizzeria 4 out of 5 stars. If the customer service had been better during my visit, it would have easily been a 5-star experience. Despite the poor service, the pizza was decent, and I would recommend giving it a try if you're in the area.
Jessie Gazon
Amazing pizza with some of the kindest workers I've ever met. Always go above and beyond.
Jess
Amazing pizza with some of the kindest workers I've ever met. Always go above and beyond.
Mukesh Hingorani
So I guess ordering online is cheaper. They even told my son if we pay cash a discount will be offered. No discount was offered. In the end cash was expensive then ordering online ?
Ric T.
Food is excellent and so is the service. The ambiance is to be desired. I assume this is the place that you get a quick lunch or a slice of pizza and leave in service is usually over the counter. I walked in and wanted a table and as mentioned above, Gina's service was very accommodating, yet inexperienced. The main problem here is the place needs a thorough cleaning The tables are sticky and dusty and not much attention is paid to this aspect, hence three stars.
Great
Food: 4
Overpriced! I took a shot with this place and although the pizza is good, I just can't justify spending $11-12 for two slices of pizza and a soda! Now, I totally understand charging a little more for "specialty" slices, but seriously it's just pizza. And I know it costs next to nothing to make a pizza. I recently purchased a plain slice, a "specialty" slice, and a soda. The total came to $11 and change. Seriously? This place isn't exactly gourmet dining. I'll go a minute up the road next time and pay $2 a slice. It tastes just as good! IT'S JUST PIZZA!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Great food and always on time and correct
Waste of retail space. Terrible experience. FRIED CALAMARI an insult. Buyer beware. I wish I could rate it -10 stars.
Pizza was good but from a selfish perspective, I have to express dissatisfaction with the restaurant's logistics. I took my wheelchair-bound mother there for dinner. The entryway is difficult to navigate. All the chairs on the restaurant area are armless, and the bathroom is too tiny to allow a wheelchair in. I will not visit again but would be open to take-out.
Ordered the meatball sub and chicken with vodka sauce. Solid meatball sub the sauce was well balanced and not too acidic. Got the chicken cutlet on a garlic bread, which was the right call. Would definitely go back to try rest of the sandwich menu.
Wasn’t really a fan of this style of pizza. Crust tasted off.
I had gone here about a month ago for pizza. The pizza was less than memorable. The other thing was they were charging a credit card fee. Now many restaurants are doing this and I think as consumers we need to push back on these fees. Yes they get charged and have always been charged. What changed? Nothing. Now they are trying to pass along a “cost of doing business”. When I questioned the fee the owner told me gas stations charge a fee. Well you are not a gas station. And not all gas stations charge a fee. Clearly not a lot of intelligence there. Back to my latest visit. They are in a convenient location and I decided to try it again and use cash. They had a “grandmas pie”. They were average size. 9 in a pie. They had them cut on the diagonal. I questioned why each piece was cut. They told me that was the slice. The cost was 4.00 per essentially 1/2 of a square slice. So they found still another way to gouge their customers. When I left without buying anything after asking the price they made a rude comment that I wouldn’t pay 4.00. Stay away. Bad food. Unprofessional and taking advantage anyway they can.
Great chicken parm! Both of my wonderful grandfarhers were named Attillio, how could I not? Thanks for a great lunch!
I stopped by recently and ordered a baked ziti. It was so good that I’m considering driving an hour away next time I want some good ziti . The place is also nice and great staff . Thanks
Restaurantji Recommends
I recently visited Attilio's Pizzeria in Freehold, NJ, and overall, it was a decent experience. I ordered a meat lovers pizza to go, and while it wasn't the best pizza I've ever had, it was still tasty. The pizza had a generous amount of meat toppings, but the crust was a bit thicker and doughier than I prefer.However, what really stood out to me was the poor customer service. When I arrived, there weren't many customers inside the restaurant, yet the staff seemed disinterested and not very welcoming. When I called ahead to place my order, the person who answered the phone sounded uninterested and didn't seem to want to help me.As someone who values good customer service, this was disappointing. That being said, I do want to acknowledge that this was likely a one-off experience, as Attilio's Pizzeria is typically known for having good customer service. I would be willing to give them another chance in the future and hope that the service will be better.One aspect of Attilio's Pizzeria that I did appreciate was the convenience of getting the pizza to go. The process was quick and easy, which is always a plus.Overall, I would rate Attilio's Pizzeria 4 out of 5 stars. If the customer service had been better during my visit, it would have easily been a 5-star experience. Despite the poor service, the pizza was decent, and I would recommend giving it a try if you're in the area.
Amazing pizza with some of the kindest workers I've ever met. Always go above and beyond.
Amazing pizza with some of the kindest workers I've ever met. Always go above and beyond.
So I guess ordering online is cheaper. They even told my son if we pay cash a discount will be offered. No discount was offered. In the end cash was expensive then ordering online ?
Food is excellent and so is the service. The ambiance is to be desired. I assume this is the place that you get a quick lunch or a slice of pizza and leave in service is usually over the counter. I walked in and wanted a table and as mentioned above, Gina's service was very accommodating, yet inexperienced. The main problem here is the place needs a thorough cleaning The tables are sticky and dusty and not much attention is paid to this aspect, hence three stars.